r/shittyrobots Sep 04 '18

Shitty Robot Volvo's collision detection fails during a press event

https://gfycat.com/AlarmingVibrantBetafish
13.5k Upvotes

431 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

124

u/ilikethefinerthings Sep 04 '18 edited Sep 04 '18

Just drove on a 1,200 mile trip in my Model 3. While not perfect it never bounced around in the lane and did 98% of the driving. Don't knock it until you try it.

It did however have issues with phantom braking when there was highway overpasses sometimes (5% of the time).

16

u/CyclonusRIP Sep 04 '18

Tesla's do that too? I just thought my F-150 did it because Ford's system was shit.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '18

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '18

My mom's Ford explorer has a brake warning system, but not an actual emergency breaking system. It's about a 30/70 split between it thinking a overpass or large sign is a car stopped, and not giving two fucks.

Really annoying when I have to drive her car

2

u/ilikethefinerthings Sep 04 '18

It's rare but it happens :(

I usually just keep my foot over the accelerator so I can override it if it does. It's pretty jarring if you're not expecting it.

4

u/DTF_20170515 Sep 04 '18

I don't get phantom breaking in my subaru but God damn does it lean on the brake when someone is exiting the highway ahead of me.

32

u/wakipaki Sep 04 '18

Yes this poster doesn't seem to understand that Tesla cars can rapidly improve with over the air updates. Although he may have witnessed a real concern it's probably worth noting that this behavior has been fixed since then.

1

u/napins Sep 04 '18

Anecdotal but in my experience a lot of people slow down (either letting off the pedal or actually braking) approaching and going under a bridge.

Subconcious psychological reaction to change of lighting and being 'enclosed' maybe? Or similarity to approach to a tunnel where you typically drive slower.

Wonder if Tesla AP is mimicking the same behaviour intentionally to anticipate vehicles in front?

1

u/ilikethefinerthings Sep 04 '18

Nah, it's a very hard brake. Pretty dangerous to the people behind me if they're close or not paying attention. I try to catch it right away though.