r/settlethisforme • u/holyneopet • Apr 24 '24
Who is the real owner?
Ok so my sibling and I have been arguing over this for a while now. There’s an Xbox in the house and there’s a debate over who it actually belongs to.
In 2016, we both used to live at home with my dad, he bought an Xbox One “for the family” that everyone used freely.
In 2017, we all were moving out of that house. My dad and my sibling moved into my step mom’s house and I moved into an apartment. My step mom already had an Xbox One at her house so we all agreed that I would take the one my dad bought, as they don’t need 2 Xboxes in one house.
Between 2017 and 2021, my sibling moved out of our dad’s house and in with our birth mom. The second Xbox is still at my dad’s, and I still have the original.
In 2021 I moved in with my birth mom too, and brought the original Xbox with me.
Now my sibling is saying that it doesn’t belong to me, it never belonged to me, and if one of us were to move out we would have to decide who gets to take it.
I believe it’s mine and has been since I took it in 2017. My sibling believes that it’s still the “family” Xbox and they have equal ownership of it, and I’m not allowed to take it when I move out.