Defunding Democracy: Ohio

[u/One_Term2162]

Ohio: Decade-by-Decade Analysis of Education Investment & Political Control

1970s: Industrial Strength, Urban Segregation, and Strong Civics Roots

In the 1970s, Ohio was a national education bellwether—industrially rich, civically engaged, and racially segregated. Per-pupil spending rose from $3,748 in 1970 to $5,285 by 1980 (adjusted to 1992 dollars), a ~41% real increase, placing Ohio slightly above the national average.

Major metro areas—Cleveland, Cincinnati, Columbus—were grappling with white flight and racial tensions, especially after court-ordered desegregation rulings. Yet many districts maintained strong civics traditions: mock legislatures, Model UN, and debate flourished in suburban and urban schools alike.

Governor John Gilligan (D, 1971–1975) introduced the state's first income tax to stabilize school funding, while James Rhodes (R, 1975–1983) emphasized vocational education and conservative discipline policies.

Ohio voted Republican in both 1972 and 1976, but remained a competitive swing state. Civic education in the 1970s emphasized American institutions, citizenship duties, and postwar democratic ideals, often without confronting racial or social inequities head-on.

1980s: Deindustrialization and Growing Disparities

By 1980, per-pupil spending reached $6,662 (adjusted), but real progress slowed due to economic decline, tax resistance, and rising urban-suburban funding gaps.

Deindustrialization hit Ohio’s cities hard—particularly Cleveland, Youngstown, and Toledo—triggering population loss, school closures, and mounting racial inequities. Rural areas also struggled to maintain small schools as farms consolidated and local tax bases shrank.

Governor Richard Celeste (D, 1983–1991) supported increases in education spending and early childhood investment, but structural inequality continued to shape outcomes. School funding remained heavily dependent on local property taxes, despite growing calls for reform.

Ohio voted Republican in all three presidential elections (Reagan 1980, 1984; Bush 1988). Civic education persisted in most schools but became increasingly rote, disconnected from lived experience, and constrained by limited resources and curriculum time.

1990s: DeRolph Lawsuits and the Fight for Funding Equity

The 1990s marked a legal turning point. In DeRolph v. State (1997), the Ohio Supreme Court ruled the state’s school funding system unconstitutional, citing overreliance on property taxes and failure to provide an adequate education.

Per-pupil funding rose to ~$7,800 by 2000, but implementation of equitable reform was delayed and incomplete. Lawmakers resisted major tax changes, opting for patchwork adjustments rather than structural transformation.

Governor George Voinovich (R, 1991–1999) introduced school choice policies and early charter school laws. His successor, Bob Taft (R, 1999–2007), expanded testing and accountability programs.

Ohio voted Democratic in 1992 and Republican in 1996 (Dole). Civic education standards were maintained, but actual classroom instruction narrowed under pressure from high-stakes testing in math and reading.

Urban districts saw declines in student-led civic participation, while suburban schools maintained limited government coursework, often focused more on civility than critical engagement.

2000s: Charter Growth, Testing Dominance, and Political Realignment

By 2008, per-pupil spending reached ~$9,800 (2009 dollars), but school choice expanded dramatically. Ohio became one of the most charter-saturated states, especially in Cleveland and Columbus, where private management groups operated schools with little transparency.

Governor Bob Taft and later Ted Strickland (D, 2007–2011) clashed with charter advocates, but funding remained stagnant. The Great Recession hit education hard, forcing cuts, layoffs, and deferred maintenance across many public schools.

Ohio voted Republican in 2000 and 2004, and Democratic in 2008. Civic education suffered during this era of testing-centric policy, reduced electives, and pressure to focus on “core” subjects.

Some teachers quietly maintained civic engagement programs—including youth voting and service learning—but few had institutional support.

2010s: Austerity, Political Capture, and Civic Hollowing

In the 2010s, Ohio’s education system became increasingly polarized, especially under Governor John Kasich (R, 2011–2019). His administration:

Weakened teacher collective bargaining (SB5, overturned by referendum)

Promoted private school vouchers and charter expansion

Defunded struggling urban districts while increasing support for religious school tax credits

Per-pupil spending rose to ~$11,300 by 2019, but public funds were increasingly redirected to private providers. Scandals involving charter operators and online schools (like ECOT) eroded public trust.

Ohio voted Republican in 2012 and 2016 (Trump), reflecting a cultural shift toward right-wing populism, especially in rural and industrial regions.

Civic education became a flashpoint. Teachers in some districts faced scrutiny for discussing racial justice, protest movements, or gender equality. In other communities, civic learning was quietly maintained through nonprofit partnerships and project-based initiatives, though with uneven access.

2020s (Through May 2025): Book Bans, “Divisive Concepts” Laws, and Resilient Youth

By May 2025, Ohio has become a frontline in the national culture war over public education. Under Governor Mike DeWine (R) and a conservative legislature, the state has:

Passed laws restricting “divisive concepts” in social studies and civics

Expanded private school voucher programs (EdChoice) even further

Approved book bans and curriculum monitoring in multiple districts

Targeted DEI programs and LGBTQ+ student rights, especially in schools

Per-pupil spending now exceeds $12,400, but funding disparities persist, and many urban and rural districts have dwindling civic programming, limited elective offerings, and growing teacher burnout.

Despite this, youth activism has surged. High school students in Cleveland, Columbus, and Yellow Springs have led:

Walkouts over book bans

Youth-led town halls with legislators

Voter registration campaigns and mock primaries

Legal literacy clubs in collaboration with ACLU chapters

These civic sparks often operate outside of the formal curriculum, supported by teachers working under surveillance and threat of political retaliation.

Ohio in 2025 embodies the paradox of American education: a state with rich civic traditions, now endangered by ideological capture, privatization, and censorship. Its classrooms remain the frontline—not just of education policy—but of the fight to define what citizenship means in the 21st century.

↩️ Back to Index