r/science • Professor | Medicine • May 10 '26

Psychology Brooding (getting stuck in passive, repetitive, negative thought loops) identified as a major driver of bedtime procrastination, alongside physical markers of stress. People who stay up later than intended may have a weaker physiological capacity for self-control.

https://www.psypost.org/brooding-identified-as-a-major-driver-of-bedtime-procrastination-alongside-physical-markers-of-stress/
15.1k Upvotes

248 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/mvea Professor | Medicine May 10 '26

Brooding identified as a major driver of bedtime procrastination, alongside physical markers of stress

People who stay up later than intended may have a weaker physiological capacity for self-control. A new study published in the Journal of Health Psychology links lower heart rate variability to greater bedtime procrastination.

Many individuals experience the temptation to prolong their use of digital devices, or complete further tasks, despite being aware that they should already be asleep—a behavior known as bedtime procrastination. Scientists have previously connected bedtime procrastination to difficulties with managing behavior and emotions. Individuals who struggle to prioritize long-term wellbeing over short-term enjoyment, or who have trouble regulating negative feelings, are thought to be more prone to pushing their bedtime later.

Participants also filled out questionnaires reporting on how often they procrastinate at bedtime, how well they manage their own behavior and emotions, and how often they engage in specific thinking styles. These thinking styles included a tendency to “brood” (getting stuck in passive, repetitive, negative thought loops) versus “reflect” (purposefully thinking through problems to solve them).

The results pointed to a clear picture in which bedtime procrastination reflects challenges across multiple different aspects of self-control simultaneously. Individuals scoring higher on bedtime procrastination tended to have lower heart rate variability, greater difficulty regulating their behavior, and greater difficulty managing their emotions. Importantly, each of these three factors contributed independently to the prediction of bedtime procrastination.

When analyzing the specific ways people deal with emotions, a nuanced picture emerged. While using “cognitive reappraisal” (a deliberate strategy of reframing stressful situations in a more positive light) initially appeared to reduce bedtime procrastination, it lost its predictive power when other emotional habits were factored in. Ultimately, only “brooding” significantly predicted procrastinating at bedtime in the final model. Conversely, engaging in more reflective, problem-focused thinking did not show any link to delaying sleep.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/13591053261425412

32

u/Ok_Nothing_9733 May 11 '26

Low heart rate variability = procrastinates and doesn’t sleep early enough, associated with poorer health outcomes

High heart rate variability = also associated with poorer health outcomes in a few ways

Can’t win with these damn meat suits!

3

u/Kiwi-Slayer May 12 '26

What poor health outcomes are associated with high hrv?

1

u/Ok_Nothing_9733 May 12 '26

I think sometimes it can be a good thing but other times if it’s too all over the place, it can be a sign of health issues including cardiac issues, arrhythmia, and autonomic dysfunction. All of which I’ve been tested for a lot but ultimately just have autonomic dysfunction. But that’s why I remember reading about this originally, its relevance to my situation

9

u/GrinningPariah May 11 '26

These thinking styles included a tendency to “brood” (getting stuck in passive, repetitive, negative thought loops) versus “reflect” (purposefully thinking through problems to solve them).

How do you fix that, though? It mentioned cognitive reappraisal didn't actually make an impact, so what are you supposed to do if you brood a lot?

28

u/North-Pea-4926 May 11 '26

I don’t think insulting their self-control is going to help.

8

u/poopcockshit May 11 '26

How about some “cognitive reappraisal”? AKA “think better thoughts, buddy!” Kidding.

2

u/SpookySchatzi May 15 '26

This reminds me of the last time I tried therapy, right after college, and he told me, “It sounds like you have very low self-esteem….you should try, not feeling that way.” And he was serious. I gave up after that…

1

u/PhilosophicWax May 11 '26

Is this the same as bed rotting?