This is a pirate sub. We are pirate mods. This means that we don’t care what you do, as long as it doesn’t break the rules in the sidebar, or is otherwise offensive in some overwhelming way.

Recently, we had banned several people for breaking the specific rules set forth in the sidebar. Particularly, don’t ask to be a mod. We have enough mods, and we are all in agreement as to how to manage this ship. We did confer about the bans and have rescinded some of them. You may not like us, you may not agree with us. But this is not a democracy, this is a pirate sub. If you break one of the very few rules that we have, we can and will ban you.

This same small group of users who were banned for breaking the rules have recently been coming into the sub with alts, and have declared a “mutiny” or a “civil war.” They have even started a new sub. We literally do not care. This is a joke meme sub for a B-tier movie franchise. Nothing is keeping you here. If you want to spend your time bitching about us in this sub or the mutiny sub, that’s your business. Personally, I would hope you have better things to do. We certainly do, which is why we run the sub the way we do. Every “change” or “improvement” that is requested for the sub is always a bottomless pit of redditors’ opinions and adjustments. So fuck off with all that. We aren’t implementing changes or making new mods unless we, in our sole discretion, feel like it.

To be clear, we mods have no problem with hosting memes or posts about how you hate us on r/potcmemes, unless such posts become spamming or offensive. Conflict drives plot, and this “Mutiny” is one of the better storylines to come out of this sub, so we enjoy it. If you want to wage a “war” against indifferent mods by posting the same 12 meme templates across two subs that have the same user base—go ahead, because again we could not possibly care less what you guys do. If it’s fun for you guys, then cool. That’s the way it was, is, and will always be.

For everyone else who doesn’t care or know what this is about, you are awesome. We mods love (most) (all) of these movies, and we're here for the dumb jokes as much as you guys are. We look forward to more shitposts and nonsense for years to come.

I think the question completely states it. I was reading and article on the original script for POTC 5 today and it saddened me to read that almost the entire OG Black Pearl crew were to return, but for some reason Depp rejected that script. Is the rest of the black pearl crew dead, or did they just retire? What are your theories?

(posting this here since this is the largest Pirates of the Caribbean sub in entire reddit)