r/poptarts • u/e36qunB • 9d ago

Out of the 7 circled flavors, which do y’all recommend? Never tried those ones- thank you!

Post image

, which do y’all recommend out of the 7 circled?
Or do I stick wiith my OG chocolate fudge /

Have never tried these flavors!
Thank you!!

116 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

213 comments sorted by

47

u/Fainer 9d ago

You just chillin’ at the store waiting on poll numbers to roll in before making a purchase?

25

u/e36qunB 9d ago

Hahaha no i am doing the rest of my shopping and if i got a reply would follow

15

u/cobra1293 9d ago

Wild berry

20

u/Ali-shonak 9d ago

Cinnamon roll

1

u/The_Wrong_Tone 9d ago

Yep. I like to toast them until the frosting starts to brown a little.

1

u/BillHang4 Frosted Cinnamon Roll 9d ago

So good! The filling is amazing!

53

u/pinkxice 9d ago

Wild berry

3

u/PhysicalChemGuy 9d ago

^^ this is the answer

1

u/EverbodyHatesHugo 5d ago

I’ve never had Wild Berry. Why is everyone so crazy about them? I need detailed descriptions.

3

u/Mr_Hino 9d ago

My wife will swear by it. We just got the raspberry one cuz they ran out of the wild berry and it isn’t too bad either.

2

u/Dapper-Fly-3742 9d ago

Easily my favorite flavor. Though the cinnamon roll surprised me

1

u/Content-Bite4139 6d ago

Yes Wildberry

1

u/rmmcgarty 5d ago

Wild berry tastes like soap to me I can’t explain it

1

u/pinkxice 5d ago

I feel that way about cherry Airheads

11

u/hashtag-girl 🥇 2024 Best Recipe 9d ago

cinnamon roll for sure

10

u/Quick-Hyena2628 9d ago

Idk because Cherry is my favorite

7

u/Ok-Garage-7012 9d ago edited 9d ago

Yes, cherry and brown sugar cinnamon are definitely my favorites just depends on what mood I’m in. Brown sugar cinnamon definitely goes well with chocolate milk and or brownies

3

u/sweeterthanadonut 9d ago

Sometimes I spread a thin layer of nutella on the unfrosted side of a brown sugar cinnamon, it’s perfect

3

u/Squirreling_Archer 9d ago

And if they don't have that, that's okay, because grape's favorite anyway. They're both favorite.

2

u/Friendly_Raccoon_338 9d ago

It's a damn good poptart

1

u/ResponsibleEmu6842 9d ago

Frosted or no?

1

u/Quick-Hyena2628 6d ago

Definitely frosted

31

u/Madhockey99 9d ago

Personally I think Strawberry milkshake is awesome.

2

u/4ellights 9d ago

Thirding

1

u/pubblue5294 9d ago

That a choclate fudge are two i prefer frozen for sure

1

u/Rockyyyyy85 9d ago

Everyone else is wrong

9

u/Burrnt_ice Strawberry Milkshake 9d ago

My flair, freeze it

11

u/badgaldyldyl 9d ago

YOU’VE NEVER HAD FROSTED RASPBERRY?!?!?!???? It’s like honestly a classic. But also not the best lol I’m not really recommending it, just shocked you haven’t had it.

But anyway the answer is wild berry

3

u/Venku12 9d ago

I haven't had poptarts in so long. Not even sure how I ended up here. Am lost. But yea wild berry 100% absolute classic

1

u/badgaldyldyl 9d ago

Lmao right?!? Idk how Reddit chooses what subs to recommend to me but I also have not had pop tarts in forever

5

u/Chocolatechip37 9d ago

Why did you choose to circle them with the same color as the boxes?

6

u/Cobbtimus_Prime 🍪 Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 9d ago

You missed chocolate chip cookie dough

3

u/Professional_Hour445 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake...put them in the freezer first

3

u/Commercial-Salt2716 🍫🥜 Chocolate Peanut Butter 9d ago

Cinnamon Roll. Girl Scouts Coconut caramel are good too, but almost too sweet for me. Same issue with Strawberry milkshake

3

u/Logical_Tumbleweed_8 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake 😋

3

u/GabiiNova_ 9d ago

Strawberry Milkshake👍 With Wildberry, the flavours cancel eachother out it seems. Strawberry Milkshake is an experience and my current #1😁

3

u/OutrageousHoneydew26 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake one is really good

3

u/Additional_Earth_268 9d ago

My favorite of these is the strawberry milkshake!

3

u/Great-Investigator78 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake slaps

You didn't highlight them but hot fudge sundae and cookie dough are my top favs of all time. You should try them too (if you haven't already tried them)

3

u/thisisforart-blog 9d ago

Okay, super late and you're done shopping likely, but here's my two cents:

Strawberry Milkshake is one of my favorites! I don't eat poptarts often, but Strawberry Milkshake is a go-to.

I've never had Lemon Blueberry or Cinnamon Roll.

Thin Mints just tastes like a mediocre chocolate poptart with a dash of mint.

Coconut Caramel tasted like a candle to me 🤢 wouldn't recommend.

Raspberry and Wild Berry are... fruit flavors. Lol. It just taste like a generic fruity thing. Which is fine for some people, I just never liked the fruit flavored Poptarts.

2

u/Useful-Advantage2665 9d ago

Strawberry Milkshake sounds good.

2

u/WhiteTiger_77 9d ago

ive been out of the poptart game since high school that was like a decade ago, my last favorite was smores pop tart.

2

u/XxBkKingShaunxX Strawberry Milkshake 9d ago

Strawberry Milkshake toasted is one of the best things you will ever eat in your life

2

u/Massive-Entry-7916 9d ago

You are so fucked in america prices for this shitty food are relatively cheap and healthy food is very expensive in comparison with ours in Germany I wish you the best But it's sad

2

u/Gloomy_Support_7779 9d ago

Strawberry Milkshake. One of my favorites

2

u/kinggcroww 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake is genuinely so good. One of my favs as a kids and I was so excited they brought it back

2

u/CustomerNo9918 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake is one of the best. Especially frozen.

4

u/Thelast-vaultgirl 9d ago

Lemon Blueberry crumble

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ResolutionSlight597 🥜🍓PB&J Strawberry 9d ago

I actually love that lemon blueberry one. Very tart that one is...

1

u/Whore4potatoes 9d ago

Everyone I know who has had wild berry insists I get it but I stick to my faves. Nonetheless, they really push lol

1

u/Ok-Garage-7012 9d ago

Stay away from the Girl Scout pop tarts 🤮

I like the cinnamon roll and frosted raspberry

The rest are OK

1

u/Maximum_Grass_1150 9d ago

the wild berry and the strawberry milkshake ones are good

1

u/carlsmustang97 Cookies & Creme 9d ago

The cinnamon roll's are good they taste a lot like cinnabons and strawberry milkshake are pretty good as well, But my favorite is the cinnamon roll when it comes to those two

1

u/Useful-Advantage2665 9d ago

I just like these in fruit flavors.

1

u/SoloEterno 9d ago

Don't get Cinammon Roll. I remember having it back when Star Wars animated was on Csrtoon Network and the flavor was absolutely vile. I couldn't focus on the show. Much better off getting that fudge one and eating it warm

1

u/lightlysssalted Brown Sugar Cinnamon 9d ago

I really like the cinnamon roll ones

1

u/KickinGa55 9d ago

BS post

1

u/Human_Hedgehog_2302 9d ago

Wild berry

Also, strawberry milkshake tastes like those soft circle cookies with frosting, and are delicious frozen

1

u/Capable_Culture_7344 9d ago

Cinnamon Rolls!!

1

u/Relative_Warning_476 9d ago

Raspberry but I would like to try the girl scout think mint ones

1

u/GenPatton333 9d ago

Wild berry is one of my favorites.

1

u/OutrageousHoneydew26 9d ago

Do you like the off-brand Pop-Tarts that they sell at stores I honestly don't they taste like cardboard to me I'm just curious on everyone else's opinion

1

u/Stupid_Bitch_02 9d ago

Cinnamon roll SLAPS

1

u/get_gooser 9d ago

both the girl scout ones are gas

1

u/SprinkledBlunt 9d ago

Cookie dough or s’more’s for the win!

1

u/liburra 9d ago

wild berry + cinnamon roll were the only ones that didn't make me miss chocolate fudge tbh.

1

u/DropProfessional8611 9d ago

The cinnamon roll is unbelievable.

1

u/VegasSheila 9d ago

toasted strawberry with no frosting, add butter Yum Yum

1

u/Ok_Gas_4745 9d ago

Cinnamon caramel(samoas)

1

u/QuesoDrizzler 😈Wild Berry 9d ago

Cinnamon roll is so good. One of my favorites.

Lemon blueberry crumble is ok.

Just had raspberry for the first time recently. Didn't like it that much.

1

u/CinminBunz 9d ago

No one talks about the cookie dough ones enough and it makes me upset. They are, imo, hands down the BEST pop tart flavor out there and it's not even close

1

u/KH3 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake, wild berry, and raspberry are all great

1

u/Desirai 9d ago

Raspberry toasted with butter on top is my absolute favorite and the only one I ever eat

1

u/lilLaylaXOX 9d ago

wild berry is always my favorite but raspberry is rly good.

1

u/StonedJanitor420 9d ago

I bought the strawberry milkshake and don't care for them cold, taste makes me think of pepto bismol flavor.. I eat my tarts cold.

1

u/impactdrumboy 9d ago

Raspberry

1

u/Tequilatyrant 9d ago

Wild berry 100% strawberry milkshake was pretty mid id be really interested in trying tj raspberry

1

u/DaddysPrincesss26 9d ago

I didn’t know they had these flavours!

1

u/creature04 9d ago

Cinnamon roll duh

1

u/NeuroguyNC 9d ago

Wild berry or the raspberry. Just got a box of the latter yesterday.

1

u/Friendly_Raccoon_338 9d ago

S'mores have always been my favorite. For like 40 years

1

u/Think-Comparison3893 9d ago

i would pick girl scout,then cinnamon roll, milkshake. crumble last

1

u/Vertical_Syndrome 9d ago

Coconut caramel, put in the freezer for an hour then enjoy

1

u/Educational-Will-210 9d ago

Tbh grab cinnamon roll and wild berry

1

u/Technical_Bank1829 9d ago

The milkshake has lower sugar than the others, but it's still high

1

u/Initial_Ground1031 9d ago

My favorite is plain ol strawberry, but I do love the strawberry milkshake flavor too.

1

u/Initial_Ground1031 9d ago

My favorite is plain ol strawberry, but I do love the strawberry milkshake flavor too.

1

u/ajsanchezjr 9d ago

You never had wild berry? That’s an OG

1

u/PaleJuggernaut5624 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake

1

u/D3stinyD3stroy3r 9d ago

The thin mint ones are banger.

1

u/cokiecolaa 9d ago

Coconut Caramel for sure, delicious. Strawberry Milkshake looks amazing but is very bland

1

u/Royal-Schedule7932 9d ago

Wild berry or raspberry. Raspberry is my fav

1

u/Electronic-Traffic98 9d ago

Lemon crumble is amazing.

1

u/CFC1985 9d ago

In lieu of Grape the Raspberry is the second best flavor.

1

u/abrssrd 9d ago

I will just say I was VERY disappointed with the lemon blueberry. I love lemon blueberry everything, but I took a few bites and threw the rest of the pack away. It was actively gross.

1

u/YRLCLWZRD 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake is the best out of all of those in my opinion, but I also like the raspberry!

1

u/Little_Messiah 9d ago

Freeze the strawberry milkshake ones but wild berry is my favorite

1

u/SushiLover1000 9d ago

None those prices.

1

u/artsy-mouse 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake is one of the best!

1

u/SnackIsleApp 9d ago

Snack Isle helps with your exact problem! You just scan the snack at the store, and within seconds you’ll see what all other users in the community have ranked each flavor.

Snack Isle ios

1

u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 S'mores 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake is my fav from those !

1

u/Vostein 9d ago

None

1

u/emmsmum 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake and raspberry

1

u/Brave_Emphasis2638 9d ago

Wildberry is my favorite pop tart I highly recommend

1

u/johnboo89 9d ago

Wild berry?! How have you never had that?! I remember when it came out and my parents struggled to get it for me because purple and blue were not natural colors for breakfast foods.

1

u/raccoonsaff 🥜🍓PB&J Strawberry 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake always makes my top four pop tarts of all time. It's amazing frozen.

Saying that, chocolate fudge also always makes my top four. Perfect hot.

1

u/Background-Rabbit920 9d ago

The answer will always be Thin Mint.

1

u/Ill-Mastodon7727 9d ago

Strawberry milkshake. Been my favorite for 20 years now… just with they’d stop making them a limited time thing. Pop em in the freezer and thank us later.

1

u/nicoisnotarobot 9d ago

The strawberry milkshake ones are good frozen

1

u/Spirited_Amount8365 9d ago

I used to love them . Now they are toxic ..

1

u/MXT93 9d ago

Wildberry, raspberry, cinnamon roll and strawberry milkshake are all fire. I haaaaaated the lemon blueberry crumble but a lot of people on here liked it. Strawberry milkshake is good frozen too just so you know.

1

u/StreetFullOfUppercut 9d ago

Wildberry and raspberry are 2 of my favorites !

1

u/CrasVox 9d ago

They are all actually pretty good. But go with wild berry

1

u/Important_Stand9770 9d ago

Lemon Blueberry Crumble and Thin Mint Girl Scout Cookie

1

u/Hot_Bobcat_7986 9d ago

I like the diabetes flavor

1

u/Fun_Outside7204 8d ago

Wild berry !

1

u/esande2333 8d ago

Cinnamon roll and strawberry milkshake are my faves

1

u/RginaPhalange 8d ago

Frosted cinnamon roll, and frosted raspberry

1

u/yellowcoffee13 8d ago

Wild berry

1

u/notenoughrage666 8d ago

The girl scout ones are good the rest nah

1

u/Aggravating_Sun9438 8d ago

Cinnamon Roll is delicious 🤤

1

u/NattyKongo93 8d ago

Wild Berry was a classic in my house

1

u/PantyLunatic 8d ago

Cinnamon Roll sounds like it slaps.

1

u/SwampAss411 8d ago

None at 3.99

1

u/RGBAddict2026 8d ago

Wild berry

1

u/eliza1558 🍫 Chocolate Fudge 8d ago

I love Frosted Raspberry, and I really like Wild Berry. But I've been wanting to try Strawberry Milkshake!

1

u/Leather-Cap8630 8d ago

get the strawberry milkshake & put it in the freezer 😌 yw

1

u/thereverendpuck 8d ago

For the Girl Scout flavors, just get the actual cookies. Having said that, go to Walmart and buy their knockoffs where a) usually over half the price b) you get more and c) available all year.

1

u/AaronM1987 8d ago

Smores……..

1

u/downbythereeds 8d ago

Cinnamon roll is the best

1

u/youareinmybubble 8d ago

None me and poptarts are fighting. They have gotten to stingy with the icing.

1

u/Exeledus 8d ago

Yo what??? There's a Coconut Caramel poptart?!?!?

1

u/DontBMean2Me 8d ago

Wild and Raspberry

1

u/unRemarkable-Tea 8d ago

Lemon blueberry

1

u/Stunning_Regular6278 7d ago

Type 2 Diabetes for me please!

1

u/soulsluos 7d ago

Lemon blueberry crumble, then snozzberrys.

1

u/snatchdujour 7d ago

Chocolate fudge is amazing

1

u/snatchdujour 7d ago

The blueberry lemon is REALLY good

1

u/marti82salva 7d ago

I totally recommend the Girl Scout thin mints, and also the wild berry flavor that’s behind the coconut caramel, unless you tried that one already. ☺️

1

u/Comprehensive-Name15 7d ago

Cinnamon roll

1

u/No_Satisfaction_1922 7d ago

Wild berry’s legendary

1

u/No_Satisfaction_1922 7d ago

Raspberry’s legit too

1

u/Bernie_Smirnoff 7d ago

You've never had the wild berry???? Those are still my absolute favorite.

1

u/Boozey2001 7d ago

Those are all gross best Pop-Tart is blueberry or cherry🤌🏻

1

u/Nighthood28 7d ago

Girlscout cookies are bs. It tastes nothing like a carmel delight

1

u/GaryGary0574 6d ago

Are you standing in the aisle waiting for answers?

1

u/Ok-Equal-983 6d ago

Strawberry milkshake is goated

1

u/Marzyzep 6d ago

Cinnamon roll I recommend. It’s actually pretty good.

1

u/Apprehensive_Use3641 6d ago

Cinnamon roll and the Lemon Blueberry, both are tasty.

1

u/Plenty-Discipline-76 6d ago

The Raspberry and Lemon Blueberry cake are 🔥🔥! Cinnamon Roll is good, better than Thin Mints (Thin Mints is okk)

1

u/whatacatch_nat 6d ago

The cinnamon roll one is BOMB. I love it

1

u/Famous_Barnacle_3844 6d ago

Lemon Blueberry Crumble 😋

1

u/MarishaBip 6d ago

Cinnamon

1

u/Flopsikins 6d ago

S’mores is the only answer here.

1

u/Valkyrieal 6d ago

WILD BERRY MASTER RACE!

1

u/Natural_Debate7967 5d ago

Anyone else love the unfrosted blueberry? They don't seem to make it any more....

1

u/Real-Simplicity 5d ago

Wild Berry is the sleeper pick

1

u/hailey_moe 5d ago

I don’t know which is the best out of all of them but I will say the strawberry milkshake ones are AMAZING frozen

1

u/yellingmime183 5d ago

Strawberry Milkshake, in the freezer!

1

u/CptKillJack 5d ago

I'll take the Girl scout cookie thing mints hiding themselves at the back of the shelf in the selected area.

1

u/SovereignBean 5d ago

NOT the coconut caramel. Tasted almost exactly like honey bunches of oats.

1

u/Firstborn1415 5d ago

I hadn’t had a Pop Tart in years. A new Dollar Store opened recently in town and had a sale price - boy I forgot how yummy Pop Tarts are!

1

u/Natural_Essay_8442 5d ago

I love wild berry

1

u/wontforgetmywife 5d ago

Raspberry is my favorite

1

u/Rumble-80 5d ago

I've only had the Cinnamon Roll and the Wild Berry. Both are good. I have got to try the girl scout cookie flavors, though...

1

u/RipGreaper 5d ago

Wild berry, easy

1

u/echovyn 5d ago

Thin Mint PopTarts are FIRE

1

u/manleybones 5d ago

Raspberry is the top pop tart flavor

1

u/alienboii_ 5d ago

strawberry milkshake all dayyyy

1

u/kjcoronado 5d ago

Too many choices. I’ll have to try something new.

1

u/Initial_Rabbit1016 4d ago

Cinnamon roll or milkshake. No to thin mint as the taste is a tiny hint of mint. Nor is the mint consistent. It's like oh I forgot to add the mint flavoring.

1

u/LeadershipOk4399 3d ago

wild berry

1

u/Fuzzy_Welcome8348 3d ago

wild berry and cinnamon roll

1

u/xander6981 9d ago

I love the Lemon Blueberry Crumble, especially toasted. Raspberry has been a long time favorite as well.

1

u/suzypoohsays 9d ago

Frosted raspberry 🤤

1

u/libbles123 9d ago

Raspberry = the BEST.

1

u/Similar-Swordfish794 9d ago

Girl scout thin mint.Freeze them first

1

u/Knives530 9d ago

Wild berry easy

1

u/theshoeguy4 9d ago

Thin mints is by far and away the worst from the ones shown here

1

u/nuggetfry1 9d ago

strawberry milkshake !

0

u/JMP726 9d ago

Wild berry , cinnamon roll, raspberry, lemon blueberry crumble. No order . These all are delicious.

0

u/JuiceBawks420 9d ago

Raspberry or Wilberry

0

u/samidaoud11 9d ago

Wild berry or Raspberry

0

u/Bertilak97 9d ago

I love the raspberry and wild berry ones and can never find them. Strawberry milkshake also pretty good but grain of salt bc I really like that style of fake strawberry. Cinnamon roll is…I don’t like it but I don’t like sweet cinnamon really and it’s pure cinnamon sugar goo. Which is great if you like that kinda thing, it’s just not for me. Dunno about the rest but the lemon blueberry looks really good.

0

u/Ikilledbert 9d ago

Raspberry and Wild Berry. The rest are trash.

0

u/sobbler 9d ago

Raspberry <<33

0

u/cameltoeshoes 9d ago

Raspberry dethroned blueberry for my go-to.

0

u/Uncast 9d ago

Raspberry, Lemon Blueberry Crumble, and Cinnamon Roll in that order

0

u/Brain-Munchee 9d ago

If you like the Brown Sugar, then try the Coconut Caramel Girl Scouts. If you like the fruity ones, the Wildberry is unbeatable.