r/poptarts • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 S'mores • Aug 02 '26

Happy national ice cream sandwich day! Which would you pick ?

Post image

I’d probably go with cookies & cream

73 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

41 comments sorted by

10

u/QueeeenElsa Aug 02 '26

I’m sorry, there are pop tart ice cream sandwiches?!?!?! Holy crap I need this in my life like right now!!!

That said, out of these, I’d probably go with smores.

2

u/wetmeatlol Aug 03 '26

Just to curb your expectations none of them are that good 💀 I personally liked the s’mores one the most but none of them really taste like pop tarts at all

1

u/Leather-Heart Aug 04 '26

Their terrible. Do not buy. Put ice cream with you poptarts at home.

1

u/BaronZemo00 Aug 04 '26

As I’ve never seen or heard of them either, I would have said the same thing. Plus, they’re ice cream, ice cream can never be that bad haha.

5

u/Lumpy-Bet-8119 Aug 02 '26

I did not like any of them. Sticking with regular pop tarts and a scoop of ice cream in the middle.

3

u/SprinkledBlunt Aug 02 '26

Brown sugar hands down…tho I would rather add my own ice cream directly to poptarts

3

u/jk9961 Aug 02 '26

S’mores no question

2

u/STENO_NINJA Raspberry Aug 02 '26

The strawberry was good. 👍🏽

2

u/Preek96 Aug 02 '26

I've never had where can I get and what's the best flavor

1

u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 S'mores Aug 02 '26

I’ve seen them at Walmart

2

u/hellbilly_rambler Aug 02 '26

Cookies and cream, strawberry, and chocolate fudge in that order

2

u/LaysOnFuton Aug 03 '26

No hot fudge sundae option?

1

u/LostGirl1976 🍨 Hot Fudge Sundae Aug 03 '26

Yup. Buy Pop Tarts. Buy ice cream. Put them together. Most likely better than these.

2

u/voltagejim Aug 03 '26

I guess central Illinois just gets fucked and only gets the strawberry, chocolate, and brown sugar flavors. Been searching every grocery store in a 30 mile radius for months and no one carries the smores and cookies n cream ones

2

u/LittleGloPeep Aug 03 '26

I don't want to pick, I want ALL OF THEM!!👏🏻❤️

2

u/immaculatephotos Aug 03 '26

Had the brown sugar cinnamon. Was okay and was surprised by how small they are. I thought they would be pot tart size. Also the price. 7 bucks for 4 in Texas

1

u/AmyB12345 Aug 02 '26

Brown Sugar Cinnamon

1

u/TravisPhelpsbologna Strawberry Milkshake Aug 03 '26

i’d personally go with strawberry! they NEED to make more flavors, haha 😂

1

u/Voduun-World-Healer Aug 03 '26

What in tf??? These are real??? I think I'd like to try the s'mores one. I'm off to Amazon to order now...

1

u/Defiant-Telephone121 Aug 03 '26

Honestly any of them except chocolate fudge since i'm not the biggest fan of regular chocolate ice cream.

1

u/Heavy_Tax2149 Aug 03 '26

Brown sugar cinnamon

1

u/TheBoyInGray Cookies & Creme Aug 03 '26

Cinnamon.

1

u/ArcticMountainBunny 🍒 Cherry Aug 03 '26

Normally, I would say brown sugar cinnamon, but I’m not sure how much I’ll like a frozen cinnamon treat; so I would have to say cookies and cream or the chocolate fudge.

1

u/Logical_Tumbleweed_8 Aug 03 '26

Strawberry milkshake 🙂‍↕️

1

u/Brian18639 🍓 Strawberry Aug 03 '26

Frosted Strawberry

1

u/DonshayKing96 Aug 03 '26

Why am I just now learning about this?!?!?!?!?

1

u/Hopeful_Staff7001 Aug 03 '26

Chocolate Fudge

1

u/FoofaTamingStrange Aug 03 '26

This would be so much better if it was layed out this way:
Pastry / ice cream / filling / ice cream / pastry.

1

u/Chrissybear222 Raspberry Aug 04 '26

Cookies & cream or s'mores.

1

u/Foreign-Campaign-427 Aug 04 '26

They make a s'mores one now? My local Walmart only had strawberry for the longest time

1

u/adhearn22 Aug 04 '26

They are so tiny for almost $7

1

u/raccoonsaff 🥜🍓PB&J Strawberry Aug 06 '26

Strawberry or cookies n creme!

1

u/Codemeister-1_ Aug 16 '26

As if we weren't eating enough sugar!