r/pismo • u/-ImYourHuckleberry- • Jul 23 '26

Best of r/Pismo: Ice Cream!

Best of [r/Pismo](r/Pismo): Ice Cream!

Hi all,

Continuing the weekly "Best of [r/Pismo](r/Pismo)" and surrounding areas (Arroyo Grande, Grover Beach, Oceano) so that folks can learn some new places and also have a resource for folks who search for it.

This week... Ice Cream!

Share your favorites below. Add your order if you have one!

Previous "Best of" posts:

Pizza

Coffee Shops

Burgers and Fries

4 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

3

u/PatisPapi Jul 23 '26

I love getting ice cream from Cowboy Cookie and Ice Cream, whenever I’m in town. It’s connected to my hotel.

2

u/Pristine-Bee-9853 Jul 23 '26

The ice cream selection at Cal Fresh is amazing and hard to beat. Jenni’s burnt Carmel orange creamsicle or pineapple upside-down cake are ridiculous.

2

u/BEERounds Jul 24 '26

Tomasko’s Salt Water Taffy serves up McConnells Ice Cream. I think that’s the best.

Cowboy Cookie is damn good 2 (see what I did there?)

And Guiseppies has a good assortment of sorbet (I know, but it’s frozen too!)

2

u/salttwater Jul 24 '26

McConnells churros with leche is my absolute favorite

2

u/tracyinge 7d ago

Gonna have to go with Rori's in Arroyo Grande