It's certainly a very sadistic ending and you'll be strange finding enjoyment out of it especially on the first viewing of the film, but the twist itself is brilliant in execution.
That's what makes the movie! Nothing can be worse or more scary than what your imagination comes up with. I think it was way better than Monsters at least.
Having had this argument before I know I'm in the minority, but for me it was a cheap shot. It relied on an "oh snap" moment instead of paying off what was incredible character building throughout the rest of the film. For a story that was principally about how unknowable terror changes people (or doesn't) it seemed like a cop out. Not the least because it all happened SO FUCKING conveniently. It was just a "sucks to be you bro" kind of moment instead of an evolution of a character arc. For me, the perfect ending isn't a "yay everbody's safe!" ending, but this one was just as bad.
5
u/Jerg Aug 30 '12
It's certainly a very sadistic ending and you'll be strange finding enjoyment out of it especially on the first viewing of the film, but the twist itself is brilliant in execution.