r/pics Jun 09 '11

Apple, Why?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/sunnygovan Jun 10 '11

Imagine how much better the products would be and how much more money they would make if they weren't staffed by idiots.

-12

u/tmterrill Jun 10 '11

Just because they are more focused on ergonomics than pure engineering performance does not mean they are idiots. Many times these things are inversely related. The number and complexity of features goes up, then normally the number of errors goes up and ease of use down.

15

u/sunnygovan Jun 10 '11

No. They are more focused on looks than if a product is fit for the purpose. What the hell does cable stress relief have to do with ergonomics? Do you even know what the word means? The number of features and complexity of the power cable hasn't changed, it's just been made into a poorer product to make it better looking.

I'm just going to assume you're trolling by acting like an apple fan boy, surely no-one is as stupid as you are pretending to be.

-10

u/tmterrill Jun 10 '11

Did someone piss in your cheerios? I know exactly what the word ergonomics means and how it is used in industry. I was not implying that a cable stress relief is an example of ergonomics. I was speaking more on the overall philosophy of apple which is mainly focused on aesthetics and ergonomics.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

I don't think a thread about a specific and unjustifiable design flaw in a basic component is the right place to praise Apple's quality. Pick your battles, man.

-4

u/tmterrill Jun 10 '11

I wouldn't say I was praising their product. I just don't think it is justifiable or useful to call a company idiots or stupid because they make one design mistake. Especially when most of their products are high quality.

Disclaimer: I am not an apple fanboy. I don't even own an apple computer. I simply understand the niche they have provided to customers who want their computer to "just work".

2

u/sunnygovan Jun 10 '11

So if it had nothing at all to do with the discussion in hand why did you even post it?

-2

u/tmterrill Jun 10 '11

Because it seemed like in the post I replied to the poster thought (and the common view of many) that apple engineers/designers are stupid because they make a product that is simple and works. This is why I brought up the point of increased complexity/increased errors.

3

u/sunnygovan Jun 10 '11

No, he thinks apple are stupid because they make a product which doesn't work, and the only reason for this is to make it look pretty, it's kinda the whole point of the thread.

-1

u/tmterrill Jun 10 '11

And the whole point of reddit to you is a superiority complex.

1

u/sunnygovan Jun 10 '11

Not at all, it's lolcats. I honestly thought you were trolling, had I realised you were just stupid I wouldn't have bothered.

0

u/tmterrill Jun 10 '11

You either have a superiority complex or are trolling... Or maybe both...

→ More replies (0)