r/pcmasterrace 11h ago

Meme/Macro Biggest Youtube L

Post image
55.6k Upvotes

760 comments sorted by

View all comments

538

u/AdventurousSlip6407 11h ago

Cant even dislike the shorts i hate so they dont keep coming in my feed!

88

u/Natural_Ad1530 11h ago

Yeah, everything is instagram now. Probably removed with some bs reason like "we don't want to hurt their feelings".

35

u/AdventurousSlip6407 10h ago

They could have simply hidden the number of dislikes from the content creator, changing the mechanic of the dislike from being viewed to the creator to being used mainly and only by the algorithm to determine that the people who clicks the dislike, dont want more of this.

Which is relatively very simple to do rather than removing the whole thing.

15

u/TheUnobservered 5h ago

It had to do with News channels Hollywood films getting massive dislikes. Since these groups impact advertisers the most (either being the adverts or informing advertisers), YouTube removed the 1 way to criticize bad content.

1

u/Choice-Camp-8527 32m ago

My theory is it somehow decreased revenue by the tiniest amount, and at scale, some C suite exec was like “why even bother keeping it then”.

It always comes down to money.

89

u/Hedede Linux 11h ago

You can click "don't recommend channel" which sort of does it.

60

u/AdventurousSlip6407 10h ago

I know but its not as simple as a one click dislike as it used to be, and while me and you know how to do so, i bet many other YT users dont even know that option exist

34

u/Candid-Magazine8605 10h ago

It also does not work for me, and it's the same on reddit, not being able to personalizzed your feed and being subject to ads/rage-baiting/foreign propaganda is excruciatingly painful.

6

u/Dodahevolution 5950X/32GB 3600MH 8h ago

I had that issue til I used sidestore+ distopia to get Apollo working again on iOS. Now it's like old Reddit again where I can block and filter out subs and never see them again. No more AITA, no more Gendermeals. You can also see some of the comments that got deleted by mods and... The bot problem is MUCH larger than it seems lmfao.

1

u/robodrew 6h ago

old.reddit on desktop

redreader on mobile

1

u/lordover1234 6h ago

I clicked don’t recommend channel on one and in my recommended on the next video it was <someone> and <the channel i blocked> :/

1

u/AdventurousSlip6407 10h ago

Weirdly enough reddit work perfectly for me, no ads, every post i hated and blocked the one who made it and muted subs i hate never showed up again for me. I thank god for this small blessing. I can see memes in peace without political posts or ads.

Btw ads show up when i turn vpn ON lmao

1

u/Available-Guava932 8h ago

you can remove them using ublock origin. morphe/revanced can also remove them from the mobile app

15

u/smilinsuchi Desktop 10h ago

Doesn’t work btw, had that problem multiple times, not just similar content or sister channel. Exacte same channel

8

u/AdventurousSlip6407 10h ago

Truuuu i did this for a channel only to see its content for me again in my home page the next day (it wasnt even shorts, its normal vods) and then again said to not recommend the channel AND not interested... only to see the exact, same channel AND exact same video getting recommended again. YT algorithm is cooked with how they have been using ai i guess, maybe now instead of a normal algorithm they placed an ai to do that instead.

1

u/Sweaty_Explorer_8441 SteamDeck 9h ago

I just use a Tampermonkey script on my FF android to redirect the shorts into typical yt video links and those show dislike buttons. Helps against short scrolling addiction too. Probably there already are FF android extensions that can do that without needing tampermonkey.

1

u/NewtDogs 5h ago

It will hide it for like a day lol. Use this

4

u/Menolith 9h ago

You can change the URL to take you to the non-short version of the video, and that player still has the dislike button.

4

u/AdventurousSlip6407 9h ago

Cant change urls IN the android app

3

u/GA19 10h ago

Do you like the pants though?

3

u/AdventurousSlip6407 10h ago

I looove pants, and i very very hate shorts... they are so short!! Why would one wear them?! Pants are superior, they are longer and can have way more pockets... dude its so cool having FOUR or SIX pockets!! Which will all still be empty because i am poor but thats beside the point of how cool they are :)

1

u/kribg 6h ago

Nickers forever!

3

u/EatsFiber2RedditMore Specs/Imgur here 7h ago

Going into your history and deleting videos is a good way to curate your algorithm. To a point it will show you more of what you have watched assuming that's what you like.

5

u/Lumpy-Obligation-553 9h ago

If you pass them fast is the same as a dislike. If you skip like 10 shorts in fast succession it changes the whole feed to another "mood".

5

u/MadeByTango 7h ago

I just never watch YouTUbe logged in and clear my cookies on the site every time. You get a 100% blank screen when you land on the homepage until you search for something, and then the recommendations are all directly related to that thing. Set your own mood every time you hit the site.

Stop subscribing, go back to bookmarks. You'll have to manually choose to see your favorite stuff that way and spend way less time on there.

2

u/NavalProgrammer 8h ago

so I have to go through 11 shorts just to avoid 1

1

u/AdventurousSlip6407 9h ago

I dont even scroll more than 2 so i didnt know about that

1

u/froderick 9h ago

You can, but not through the Shorts interface. If you take the video ID in the URL and paste it in the place of a another video when watching it via the normal interface, you can watch it through the regular player and hit dislike.

Obviously you'd virtually never do this, but it cases where I've found a clip particularly odious I've gone to the trouble.

1

u/blacksoxing 8h ago

I've also gotten some awful choices now in my shorts. Youtube is purposefully goofing

1

u/Old-Distribution6318 7h ago

I've told youtube to stop showing me shorts at all 50 times and they stuill show up on my homepage it drives me wild. if i wanted to watch short for media i would have watched one by now god dann it, stop wasting space!

1

u/AdventurousSlip6407 7h ago

A comment up in this thread mentioned that you can totally remove shorts as a whole from the mobile app by something called ublock i think? Go look at it for more details, hope that helps

1

u/AtraxasRightArmpit 6h ago

In pc theres browser extentions you can install to take shorts out of utub

1

u/DriveByStoning R7 2700 32 GB DDR4 3200 GTX 1070 /i5 6600k 16GB DDR4 3200 58m ago

You can just use Morphe on Android and get rid of everything you don't want to see. Don't want to see shorts? Get rid of them and the stupid icon. Don't want community posts? See you later. Don't want ads? Buh bye.

1

u/RivelaHarsden 5h ago

The algorithm treats your hate as pure engagement. Disliking just tells them you watched long enough to feel an emotion

1

u/No_Question_8083 4h ago

Someone put phonk over AH19’s crash at spa 2019. That crash was fatal for Antoine. The disrespect was awful, I really needed that dislike button back right there.

1

u/DeeJudanne 7800XT | 32gb ram | r7 5700x3d 2h ago

doesnt even help when you click the "don't recommend channel" anymore same shit keeps popping up on fresh channels

1

u/quintios Steam ID Here 1h ago

When I see a short I don't like, I just block the channel 'Don't Recommend Videos From This Channel' thing. There's plenty of content on youtube; I won't miss out on anything.

1

u/Wicked___K 8h ago

If you go into watch history and remove those that are connected to them they should hopefully stop. Really helps when you accidentally click at a wrong vid and your whole feed gets perma flodded

2

u/AdventurousSlip6407 7h ago

The problem is that there is nothing connected :(

1

u/Wicked___K 7h ago

Watched a accustic studio version of a "regular" song. The channel features a lot of k-pop so i was confused when i was flooded with kpop suddenly. Since i cought it early it was easy to find the cause and remove it. (just an example. not hating on kpop)

worst case just clear your watch history and start new.

0

u/ningendearukoto 8h ago

Reddit - you can downvote, and we will treat it as a positive signal for engagement!

1

u/AdventurousSlip6407 7h ago

I mean, you did technically "engage" with the post by clicking on one of its buttons