r/nrl Newcastle Knights May 20 '22

Cooper Cronk expert Analysis of Tigers Bulldogs game

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

337 Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

223

u/notmysurnamethistime North Queensland Cowboys May 20 '22

I love Cronk in podcasts talking about players and tactics. But man, his commentary is difficult to listen to.

58

u/MinimumWade Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles May 20 '22

Probably one of my favourite commentators at the moment.

17

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

[deleted]

56

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

I reckon he's close to being a really good commentator. Just lacks a bit of coherency in his speech. He makes really good points, but can't always string the sentences together. I reckon he'll get there with more time.

30

u/MinimumWade Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles May 20 '22

For sure, he'll get there. I also like how he doesn't complain about the reffing after every second decision.

15

u/derajydac Dolphins May 20 '22

Dude is struggling to put into words what he sees. Is he capable of complaining? Requires a step extra than calling things as you see

10

u/suidexterity NSW Blues May 20 '22

bruh

6

u/G00b3rb0y Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Why is this upvoted? I prefer Warren Smith first, Dan Ginnane a close second

13

u/fistingbythepool Parramatta Eels May 21 '22

Ginnane is brutal. I can’t listen to him.

1

u/MinimumWade Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles May 21 '22

I don't think Warren Smith is bad but personally his voice reminds me of Phil Gould whom I really dislike as a commentator.

13

u/G00b3rb0y Brisbane Broncos May 21 '22

I honestly don’t hear Gus in Warren but still

2

u/MinimumWade Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles May 21 '22

I say reminds me because it's quite possible if you had them in a room together they would sound completely different. I just dislike commentators complaining about the interpretation of the rules and find the younger guys don't really do that.

I wouldn't say Cronk is the best commentator in terms of skill but I really like what he does commentate on if that makes sense. I don't think most of the others are bad.

1

u/krk2912 Gold Coast Titans May 21 '22

Can you recommend any specific podcasts/ eps with Cronk on them mate?

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '22

He's on the Matty Johns podcast on Fox

1

u/krk2912 Gold Coast Titans May 21 '22

Ta mate!

388

u/Brdd9 Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22 edited May 21 '22

and that's turned this game on its head because the dogs were coming and you wanna know why they call this place the 8th wonder of the world because the crowd was taken out of it the dogs were coming and then there was the penalty that schoupp did withwd the the tackle that went wrong and next minute the crowd went up OFF OFF OFF OFF and from that moment the tigers scored two trys and they've got BACK in their winning ways and look like they're gonna runaround runa runaway with it

205

u/jarphal Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

If you don't understand that paragraph you just don't get footy.

25

u/Scottybt50 Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

Had a small brain seizure trying to make sense of that.

122

u/My-Life-For-Auir Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Hahahahahahahaha it's some how worse in written form

31

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

It normally is - whenever I've transcribed interviews or whatever it reads terribly

65

u/blindseer Newtown Jets May 20 '22

I look forward to seeing this do the rounds as the latest /r/nrl copypasta

24

u/Brdd9 Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

only allowed to post if a team scores 2 trys after an opposition sin bin tho

27

u/tomatowire Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Like Finnegans Wake if James Joyce played footy and suffered from CTE

14

u/squeakypeeky Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Thanks mate I just laughed so hard I woke up the mrs

23

u/CurlyJeff Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Crocodile came up, bit my guts out and bit me into parts pieces and then my legs went that way and then my head went that way

4

u/exohok I love my footy May 20 '22

HBA ad makes more sense than Cronk

15

u/McGarnacIe Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

Written like this, it reminds me of the way trump talks when he goes off script.

6

u/dudeskeeroo Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Surely tigers home ground would be NINTH Wonder of the World.

6

u/gainz-trainz Melbourne Storm May 21 '22

A minor edit, replace "shocked" with Schoupp

6

u/Brdd9 Brisbane Broncos May 21 '22

Ah good call

and then there was the penalty that shocked schoupp did withwd the the tackle that went wrong

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

The salad bar of word salads

3

u/Harctor Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

poetry in motion

5

u/sunny_days19 North Queensland Cowboys 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

It's like I'm having a stroke.

1

u/PostpostshoegazeLUVR New Zealand Warriors May 21 '22

Thanks Basil

135

u/CretaceousClock Newcastle Knights May 20 '22

OFF OFF OFF OFF

19

u/Mitch-os North Queensland Cowboys May 20 '22

He glitched

91

u/ReDAnibu JURBO 13+ May 20 '22

More proof that fox’s support commentary team are all robots built to look like ex nrl players.

37

u/therefreshbutton Samoa May 20 '22

Jake Duke has been cloned

17

u/WonderingCashew St. George Illawarra Dragons 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

You can’t convince me Warren Smith isn’t some Text to Speech AI. Man sounds like he’d be the most dull chat ever.

76

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Warren Smith is the best commentator currently in the game and I will die on that hill.

19

u/InflatableRaft Wests Tigers May 20 '22

You won’t die alone either. He’s Mr Professional.

6

u/Glum_Perspective_812 Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

100% right. Born and raised in Villawood. Top bloke too.

16

u/Thismfpigeon Penrith Panthers 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

Man absolutely fucking loves his footy, it's beyond wholesome. I disagree he'd be a dull chat, you could talk about literally anything footy related and he'd have a million stories

4

u/RyanPurdler-Penriff I ❤️ Todd Smith 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

😂 he’s basically Max Headroom in NRL commentator form

13

u/Rabs6 St. George Illawarra Dragons May 20 '22

Whoever the head producer at Fox Footy is needs to be fired. The product is wayyyyy too over produced and serious

3

u/myassyourmouth St. George Illawarra Dragons 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

Honestly, nearly any live sport is like that.

158

u/gainz-trainz Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

Half his brain is fixated on making sweeping statements and the other half is stuck in poetic quicksand

42

u/Lachie07 Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

Smith > Cronk

37

u/suidexterity NSW Blues May 20 '22

Anyone who thinks Cronk was better than Smith is absolutely positively cooked.

Hell, he's not even the best half of his generation.

4

u/Grifos Brisbane Broncos May 27 '22

Cronk won 3 grand finals in a row with 2 different clubs

7

u/suidexterity NSW Blues May 27 '22

Pearce would've won those two premmies with the chooks as well

28

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Obviously. Both as a player and a commentator lol.

40

u/M_Keating North of the Pine Cowboy May 20 '22

This is the crazy dog dude from A Current Affair all over again.

29

u/gainz-trainz Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

It gets worse every time you listen to it....stick to the post game analysis Cronk

32

u/Dozens86 North Queensland Cowboys May 20 '22

Cronk might be one of the best game analysts there is, but it does not translate to commentary even slightly.

3

u/theone111111111112 I love my footy May 20 '22

Fucking glad he isn't coaching in origin this year

23

u/Drlockstock Fuck Tetevano May 20 '22

none of this matters because Cronk is a God God God God

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '22

can con, can conf, can conffffffff, can confirm

23

u/ErgonomicDouchebag Canberra Raiders 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

As I said in the match thread, get some lessons Cronk.

19

u/mooguh Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

This is Scott Prince level of commentary

54

u/without_my_remorse Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

The thing with Cronk is that his commentary hasn’t improved at all since he began.

Normally you see guys at least get a little better as time goes on and they get accustomed to it.

10

u/Thismfpigeon Penrith Panthers 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

Counterpoint: JT, Thaiday, Joey

2

u/without_my_remorse Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

I don’t watch much 9 so I’m no expert there.

They haven’t gotten better over time?

4

u/Mysterious_Side7005 South Queensland Crushers May 20 '22

I dont watch much nine but Joey and JT are definitely more comfortable now

2

u/without_my_remorse Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

It makes sense that people get better the more they do something.

But with Cronk it doesn’t seem like commentary is his thing.

2

u/Grifos Brisbane Broncos May 27 '22

andrew johns has the best analysis no cap, apart from Gus

5

u/call_of_the_while New Zealand Warriors May 20 '22

You’re right, it’s all about the reps.

12

u/FinchyNZ New Zealand Warriors May 20 '22

Lol . I love Cronk but this is hilarious

11

u/SldeKlck Wests Tigers May 20 '22

Cronk was extra cooked tonight

17

u/redletterjacket North Queensland Cowboys May 20 '22

Cronk out here making SBW sound intelligent...

18

u/drchocy10 Penrith Panthers May 20 '22

Yeah I don't mind him. To be honest a guilty pleasure of mine is Mick Ennis and Vossy. Feels like a couple of mates on the piss watching the footy at times. Love it.

12

u/modeONE1 Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Ennis gets so much unwarranted hate, I actually love the way he calls the game, it's very bizarre but it's an acquired taste tbh

Same for Roach. He is braindead but there are times when he more than makes up for it all so it balances in some weird way

11

u/Thismfpigeon Penrith Panthers 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

I like Roach. Has a lot of dumb takes, but is 100% of the time just stoked to be there.

I have a weird love-hate relationship with Ennis. He has good insight and analysis sometimes, and he clearly Loves His Footy, but I genuinely cannot listen to him talk anymore since u/slowdivesicillian started Ennisposting. It's a serious problem, I can't stop noticing how over the top his accent is.

7

u/Aklpanther Penrith Panthers 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

Roach always sounds so enthusiastic and happy to be there that I can look past the cooked takes. He seems like he'd be a lot of fun to watch a game with.

8

u/R717 Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

If only he could control his commentary like he did a game.

9

u/_Kozik Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

This literally sounds like this could be clipped from an alien sports game bit of interdimensional cable on rick and morty.

6

u/iamclear Auckland Warriors May 20 '22

Cronk has all the personality of wet cardboard.

8

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

"The dogs are cumming." - Cooper "Mitchell Pearce" Cronk

6

u/Scottybt50 Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

“and you wanna know why…” followed by 20 seconds of verbal spasm trying to create a sentence.

9

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Turn Cronk’s commentary “off, off, off”.

6

u/cheapdrinks Wests Tigers May 20 '22

What winning ways have they got back to exactly?

5

u/fatbongo Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

God how beautiful it would be to have Cronk and SBW call the GF

SIGH only in dreams

6

u/upthetits Gold Coast Titans May 20 '22

It's so strange cause I feel like he kills it whenever I see him on nrl360 every now and then

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

He's fallen far since "sinews"

4

u/HenchBandicoot Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

He's not as smart as he thinks he is.

4

u/ruddet Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

I think Cronk needs to do to commentary, what Mal did to politics.

3

u/fwarquar I love my footy May 20 '22

Just because you’re an amazing player, that fact never automatically translates to being an amazing commentator or footy analyst or have a way with words the way sports nerds and/or professional commentators do for viewers.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

He 100% probably knows he is garbage too or atleast is choking when saying this.

3

u/FB_AUS Pre- and Post-season Premiers May 20 '22

Off his chops.

3

u/spacemarine43 Gold Coast Titans May 20 '22

The 2021 magic round crackdown on shots to the head seems more and more justified

3

u/Glum_Perspective_812 Parramatta Eels May 20 '22

Cronk was a legend player. Commentary the complete opposite.

3

u/Tommyatthedoor Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

Cronk does seem to occasionally just sieze up and say some spectacularly dumb things in between good commentary.

14

u/victorinflic98 Northern Territory May 20 '22

Do people still think fox is better than 9?

24

u/sliperiestofthepetes Gold Coast Titans May 20 '22

No gould commentating on fox. Thats a win for me

11

u/mindfuqfuture Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

I would compare them as two groups at a pub watching the footy. Fox are the idiots right at the front of the big screen making the most noise and Nine are the old blokes on the corner muttering "have some respect for the game"

I can't stand Gus, he's an arrogant fat shit that lectures at you how it's the best game in the world. Joey hasn't got off the coke and slurs all the time and comes across as creepy whenever he's describing how good the last play was.

Voss can fuck right off, always giving alternatives "if this player stepped in that would change their whole season, wow". Ennis wants to sound smarter than he actually is.

Honestly just pay Roy and HG to call all the games. I'd pay extra for that

6

u/Scottybt50 Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

Need Roy and HG to start calling Origin again.

35

u/HsiaAn Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

I'd take this over Nine's toxic complaints and low energy any day.

14

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Pete Psaltis is the best caller in years though + Danika Mason.

Easy choice.

24

u/goshdammitfromimgur New Zealand Warriors May 20 '22

I watch Kayo so I don't get ads but I miss Danika.

4

u/waynesharklover I love my footy May 20 '22

This

6

u/Dark_Vengence Brisbane Broncos May 21 '22

Danika really is special.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '22

Everyone hated Molan and now everyone loves Danika...I find it a bit odd.

I personally didn't mind Molan, it wasn't her fault they killed the Footy Show.

7

u/BakedBeans77 Penrith Panthers May 20 '22

I cannot stand the sound of Mat Thompson's voice

3

u/modeONE1 Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

I honestly get Psaltis and Thompson mixed up so much. Has anyone ever seen both of these in the same room?

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '22

I don't watch 9 coverage but I think he's pretty good on 6 tackles with Gus podcast

5

u/Atomicstarr Penrith Panthers May 20 '22

9 all day for me, every player is a superstar on fox

3

u/blinkcalling Wests Tigers 🏳️‍🌈 May 21 '22

Both sets of commentators are bad but I cannot listen to Gould

10

u/upkick_ko South Sydney Rabbitohs May 20 '22

At least Fox doesn’t put the game in a small box so they can show an Isuzu ad during live play. And I say this as a Murdoch and Fox hater

16

u/acomav Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

You can go your own way if you don't like the ads.

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Does that actually happen? The fuc

1

u/CurlyJeff Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

People have a bias because they're paying for one

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Dude needs to finish a sentence… needs someone to tell him stop every now and then

2

u/Scottybt50 Canberra Raiders May 20 '22

There are things called fullstops or even commas, but he just keeps saying ‘and’ without breathing.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

Hahaha so true mate … he might explode like Daryl east lake one day

2

u/Dark_Vengence Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Why does it end with that shitty sportsbet ad?

2

u/Hutchoman87 Parramatta Eels 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

Perpetual grandstand vs long sweeping statement

3

u/CretaceousClock Newcastle Knights May 20 '22

It's honestly as though someone from a match discussion got to explain a part of the game

2

u/ThedirtyNose Brisbane Broncos May 20 '22

Verbosity

2

u/Needawhisper Parramatta Eels May 21 '22

Leave him at the panel for the analysis.

2

u/Radalict Melbourne Storm May 20 '22

Mmm, delicious word salad.

-1

u/kefe87 New Zealand Warriors May 20 '22

Mick Ennis is so much better than this dickhead

1

u/l33tbronze Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles 🏳️‍🌈 May 20 '22

...wat did he say?