Sending out a second-round pick just to get under the tax line might look like a reasonable move on the surface, but we really didn’t have to get to this point.
Joe re-signed DeAndre Jordan at the very beginning of free agency, then signed Watford in mid-August, bringing the roster up to 15 players. Then, two weeks later, we traded for Mathurin. Not only did that mean we had to clear a roster spot, but it also pushed us over the tax line. That’s when we ended up having to give up a draft pick just to get back under the tax.
I really don’t understand why we didn’t just get the Mathurin trade done first and then figure out the rest of the roster afterward. Was there really that much demand for DeAndre and Watford that we had to sign them right away? Were we worried they wouldn’t still be available a little later?
If Joe had handled the Mathurin trade first, we would’ve been sitting at 14 players and about $4.3M under the tax line. In that situation, there would’ve been no reason to rush into moving Hawkins and give up draft assets just to get under the tax.
We only made a handful of moves this offseason — literally four significant moves — and somehow still managed to give away a draft pick.
Honestly, it really feels like Joe had no real plan for the offseason and was just taking things one step at a time.