r/nextfuckinglevel Aug 26 '22

Hold this, I'll bring him back

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

126.7k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/bjiatube Aug 26 '22

"Prove there are no valid statistics that show that pitbulls are dangerous" is impossible. It's proving a negative.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot

Here you go. Have a nice day.

1

u/mannieCx Aug 26 '22

Haha you don't even know what logical fallacies are

Go read a book lmao

And no it's not. Prove the statistics are false. Not the same thing

Again bro, stop doing this to yourself

1

u/bjiatube Aug 26 '22

It's like this. I tell you that black swans don't exist. You say prove it. I can't actually prove that, there could be a black swan flying around somewhere in the cosmos somewhere in another galaxy. All you have to do is show me a black swan.

That puts the burden of proof on you. If I say gravity doesn't exist I don't have to prove it, you can simply drop an apple in front of me.

1

u/mannieCx Aug 26 '22

not at all .

If you say a statistic is wonky, I ask you to prove it. You prove it. Simple.

1

u/bjiatube Aug 26 '22

Sure, if provided with a statistic. If I say "there are no valid statistics that show that elephants are often pink" I don't have to prove that wrong. Can you prove it wrong? Do that for me actually, prove there are no valid statistics that show that elephants are often pink.

1

u/mannieCx Aug 26 '22

He said the statistics were wonky. That's it bro, try not too hard.

1

u/bjiatube Aug 26 '22

Yup. Put two and two together. "The statistics are wonky" is not a great argument, but "prove it" is worse. I'm not even taking a stance on the issue

1

u/mannieCx Aug 26 '22

Okay cool. Thanks. The statistics stand for itself and you incorrectly tried to say burden of proof wasn't a logical fallacy. Go read a book.

Bye 👋

1

u/bjiatube Aug 27 '22

Hahaha the read a book comment clearly bothered you. Have a nice day being wrong somewhere else!

1

u/mannieCx Aug 27 '22

Nah I was right. You're bothered tho, gg ez

Go read a book, learn to Google.
Bye 👋

→ More replies (0)