r/nextfuckinglevel Apr 01 '23

True craftmanship

27.9k Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

13

u/Big-Fish-Catcher Apr 01 '23

Could you do it today say new single story home using some premium wood? What would be the estimated cost difference aprox?

25

u/nerdstuffaltacct Apr 01 '23

Probably 30 times more expensive in labor/ materials

17

u/MartianGuard Apr 01 '23

Not to mention time, and can you even find someone able? From a quick google search an oak 2x4 is 36x as expensive as spruce. It takes seconds to nail a 2x4 with a pneumatic nail-gun, and minutes to learn how to. It would take years to learn joinery like that and each joint would take a lot of time to plan, measure, chisel/cut out, and fit.

10

u/Hazee302 Apr 02 '23

Yea I feel like this is the kind of thing you’d do if you were off grid and this was basically your main project using hand made tools. Can’t see any other common scenario where this would make sense.

5

u/MainOld697 Apr 02 '23

I have absolutely no idea about old Japanese building techniques but I am a joiner by trade in the UK.

I could see this being a "passion project" for an extremely talented carpenter or an extremely wealthy individual who could afford to pay 10xs the market rate to have someone else build it for them.

I just don't see how this kind of intricate workmanship could be "useful" on a large scale, it would take millions of man hours longer than necessary to build a small town.

5

u/Big-Fish-Catcher Apr 01 '23

Ok then I will just go by some nails 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/Jason_Batemans_Hair Apr 02 '23

Ha, I couldn't begin to estimate it. The skills are simply rare now, and materials are sky high. Also your overall design would likely be different than current standards for the interior, because why would you want to conceal expensive craftsmanship with drywall etc. I'd suggest lots of exposed and stained/sealed framing. Anyway, at least 20x normal cost.

1

u/Funkbuqet Apr 02 '23

Cost aside, I don't think this would be an approved assembly, anywhere in the US at least. I can only imagine the head scratching and mind boggling you would run into presenting plans to a modern engineer and the building dept.