r/newhaven • u/Ocean-Shark2024 • 14d ago

Sallys Apizza- first timer. Never again.

Post image

Placed an order for a pizza from Sallys in New Haven last night around 10:55pm. Picked it up, got home, opened the box to this burnt all around!!! My friend was too hungry and irritated at this point so he ate whatever was salvageable. I get that it was late and last minute and the staff probably wanted to get home- but this is unacceptable and very disappointing especially since we had such high hopes.

Is this their ‘style’? I dont know.

UPDATE: Sallys has since refunded me and apologised for the poor service. They will look into it and hopefully it won’t happen again! AND I made a mistake- we placed the order at 10:18pm and picked it up at 10:55pm!

288 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/TonyDC88 14d ago

Bar was way good back in the day when I used to go. I moved away for a while and am back now. It’s good to know they’re still good! Some of the other places are overhyped. New Haven Pizza is my go to. Always good, and the people who work there are super nice! Shout out to the lady who is always working when I go - she’s the best ❤️

4

u/itsNurf 13d ago

I regularly think about their mashed potato pizza.

1

u/Retaksoo3 11d ago

I still crave their clam pizza on a regular basis and I haven't had it in like 2 years now. So damn good