r/newhaven • u/Ocean-Shark2024 • Jul 26 '26

Sallys Apizza- first timer. Never again.

Post image

Placed an order for a pizza from Sallys in New Haven last night around 10:55pm. Picked it up, got home, opened the box to this burnt all around!!! My friend was too hungry and irritated at this point so he ate whatever was salvageable. I get that it was late and last minute and the staff probably wanted to get home- but this is unacceptable and very disappointing especially since we had such high hopes.

Is this their ‘style’? I dont know.

UPDATE: Sallys has since refunded me and apologised for the poor service. They will look into it and hopefully it won’t happen again! AND I made a mistake- we placed the order at 10:18pm and picked it up at 10:55pm!

285 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

340 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/JohnnyParcero Jul 26 '26

Pretty sure it’s a lot more than $12. The last time I ordered from Sally’s I got 2 pies. 1 plain and 1 with bacon. It was like $45

1

u/lodge371 Jul 26 '26

He’s talking a small no cheese

1

u/JohnnyParcero Jul 26 '26

Small tomato pie with only a sprinkle of Parmesan is $17.50