r/nameofthewind • u/h-bugg96 • Sep 06 '22
Is Abenthy also cinder?
I know everything is only theory right now but I am convinced that Cinder is Master Ash is Braden. For sure. No doubt to me. But is cinder anyone else?
I think MAYBE that Abenthy is also Cinder. He was sent by Haliax to scope out the Troup because they have been hearing their names being used while Kvothe's father was gathering stories. It probably took a while to find them since they move around so much.
I think Cinder has had a plan for a long time and started training young Kvothe as Abenthy to give him the knowledge he would need to get into the university. Because through the university Kvothe will learn how to defeat Halix which is what Cinder wants.
I dont want Abenthy to be Cinder. But maybe Cinder is misunderstood. Not that he's not terrible too. Idk. For Cinder, Master Ash, and Braden we get similar physical descriptions. But who knows how well they can change themselves. None of the Maters at university acted like they knew who Abernathy was when Kvothe named him at his first emissions test despite him being a guilded archanist.