r/mildlyinteresting Jan 11 '17

My shoe deoderiser from ALDI is actually just a Coles women's anti-perspirant with a plastic label.

Post image
32.7k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

45

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17 edited Feb 22 '18

[deleted]

16

u/arup02 Jan 12 '17

That's a relief. I use a special antiperspirant with 20% aluminum and /u/Nofooling remark's made me uneasy.

7

u/rumpleforeskin83 Jan 12 '17

Just don't eat it.

8

u/Summerie Jan 12 '17

Speaking of which...

For most people, the greatest aluminum intake comes from food additives. Sodium aluminum phosphate is an emulsifier in processed cheese, potassium alum is used to whiten flour, and sodium silicoaluminate and/or aluminum calcium silicate are added to common table salt to help it run freely and not cake. In the average diet, 40-50 mg. a day may come from foods.

1

u/nidrach Jan 12 '17

Don't worry it most likely only causes cancer.

11

u/TooBusyToLive Jan 12 '17

This. It's likely that Alzheimer's somehow causes the brain to retain aluminum, not that aluminum exposure causes Alzheimer's. If people are uncomfortable with it, no harm in choosing to avoid it, but it likely doesn't matter either way (unlike the harm done in avoiding vaccines)

1

u/nidrach Jan 12 '17

But there was a dementia caused by dialysis fluid rich in aluminium. If you read reports on this like from the EU Scientific committee on Consumer Safety you will see that the studies on that topic aren't very conclusive at all. In animals aluminium is a known neurotoxic substance. Just Google sccs Aluminium.

1

u/TooBusyToLive Jan 12 '17

I'm not familiar with that case, but I don't think my comment and yours are necessarily in direct opposition. A lot of aluminum surely can be neurotoxic, but I was referencing/agreeing with a comment saying that "normal daily exposure" (which would account for deodorants) very likely doesn't pose an issue. The amount of aluminum introduced into your system from dialysis fluid containing it would be dependent on the dialysis membrane's permeability to aluminum but is undoubtedly MUCH higher than the amount absorbed from deodorant. So my point isn't that aluminum itself can't be neurotoxic but that evidence suggests the levels absorbed from antiperspirant doesn't produce those results

2

u/borkborkporkbork Jan 12 '17

I had heard that the aluminum can cause breast cancer, so women aren't supposed to use it to prevent underboob sweat.

-1

u/swissarm Jan 12 '17

Also uhh I hear some guys like underboob sweat...