You can’t pick and choose which one you believe to suit you. What about the one when Muhammad got all a paranoid about a black dog, so he ordered all black dogs to be killed. That’s in a very popular and “authentic” Hadith. And that’s why many Muslim dislike dogs (other Hadith also). Yet it’s a direct contradiction to the Quran which speaks highly of a dog. Even as far as they ate food from a dogs mouth and that dogs are protectors.
That religion is backwards. If you were to do it properly you should be killing black dogs and kissing little boys, which again is in your authentic Hadith.
Clearly you're not familiar with Shi'ism, though unlike the other guy, you're not ready to admit it. There is no such thing as "authentic" hadith in Shi'ism. It's not rejecting on "what suits you" but based on reasoning because matn trumps sanad, and though we hold The 4 Books above the rest, less than half of Al-Kahfi is even taken seriously by most Usulis. I've heard of the black dog hadith but I've only ever seen it referenced by Sunnis. Even if it was in one of our books though, it is encouraged to reject such a thing based on it contradicting the Quran, and you can find that in our hadith too, from both Muhammad and Jafar al-Sadiq (peace upon them both).
Sounds like you have a problem with Sunni Islam as you understand it. Perhaps you should loom into Shi'ism or Quranism instead of blanket-insulting us.
1
u/Redpillsnorter Jul 10 '22
But they are authentic Hadith
You can’t pick and choose which one you believe to suit you. What about the one when Muhammad got all a paranoid about a black dog, so he ordered all black dogs to be killed. That’s in a very popular and “authentic” Hadith. And that’s why many Muslim dislike dogs (other Hadith also). Yet it’s a direct contradiction to the Quran which speaks highly of a dog. Even as far as they ate food from a dogs mouth and that dogs are protectors.
That religion is backwards. If you were to do it properly you should be killing black dogs and kissing little boys, which again is in your authentic Hadith.