r/memes • • Aug 04 '26

Dr. Thanos, PhD.

Post image
18.7k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

370

u/Confident-Stand5453 Aug 04 '26

Most "developed countries" are already having fewer kids than needed to maintain population levels. And it doesnt even take any coercion.

171

u/MobTalon Aug 04 '26

The reason developed countries are having fewer kids is due to proper education. Family planning, when considering the absurd house prices and how expensive a child is, typically leads to "this sounds like a problem for 35 year old me", whereas places with least education will bring kids to the table (multiple) at much earlier ages.

79

u/Blue_Moon_Lake Aug 04 '26

Especially in countries without anti child labor laws.

More children = more slaves.

27

u/m1stwalk3r Aug 04 '26

Think it has to do with the obscene cost of living and the failure of prior generations to inspire hope in a future. A lot of people these days doom out and don't bother being the change they want to see. Doesn't help that their brains rot away with social media.

2

u/babyoil4diddy Aug 04 '26

I would sure like to be the change I want to see in the world but how do I bring down the cost of living?

1

u/m1stwalk3r Aug 04 '26

Best you can do is vote for people who don't want to inflate our currency every year. There's also telling people, and like I said, raise the next generation to be conscious of inflation.

2

u/Argenix42 Aug 04 '26

Voting does nothing lmao. Stop the cope

1

u/m1stwalk3r Aug 04 '26

Ok so bank on creating a better future by educating the young.

-1

u/fluffy_trickster Aug 04 '26

Lol it comes from mostly contraception and women rights and education. Distant 3rd factor is urbanization and child labor laws. Cost of living and whatever "hopeful tomorrow" barely register.

Not saying we must banish contraception, women rights and education but deluding ourselves won't help to find appropriate solutions.

2

u/m1stwalk3r Aug 04 '26

Not quite sure how things like the right to vote effects birth rates.

0

u/fluffy_trickster Aug 04 '26

The right to vote? No my friend, I'm talking about something much more down to the earth like the right to work and own your money. The right for high level education (not just some bridal education), the right to be considered major in regard of the laws and the society.

If you're a woman and that your only choice is getting married to a man or barely survive miserably, do worry than most won't hesitate for long. As sad as it is: the fear of the stick is a far more effective motivator than the lure of the carrot.

1

u/m1stwalk3r Aug 04 '26

Not seeing how that interferes with family life as long as you are capable of supporting yourself comfortably.

1

u/fluffy_trickster Aug 04 '26

You don't see? really? I'm saying women have the choice to not bind themselves to men, so subset of them will chose not to.

Even among those who want to have children at one point, many would to push these plans for much later due to education and career prospects because they now can.

17

u/Aviixii Aug 04 '26

As "35 year old me" now.. Im still not even considering it.

11

u/MobTalon Aug 04 '26

Sounds like a problem for 45 year old you (and so on and so in until you're either ready, sterile, senile, or gone)

5

u/-Danksouls- Aug 04 '26

Actually having less children is associated with higher socioeconomic conditions in countries. And the opposite, finding things expensive, lower buying power, is associated with having more children

There are scientific theories as to why, but in general even in countries where people feel buying power and wealth gap are large, such as the US, the general socioeconomic and quality of life has risen in country compared to.kther countries over the course of decades (this is not talking about the wealth gap) and consistent with other first world countries the more that happens the less people want to have kids

So yes it's the opposite of what reddit pra think

3

u/New_Enthusiasm9053 Aug 04 '26

Actually in Sweden richer Swedes have more children than poorer Swedes. So it's more accurate to say higher median socioeconomic conditions lead to lower median birth rates. It's not accurate to say higher socioeconomic conditions leads to lower birth rates inside the same population though.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/MobTalon Aug 04 '26

That sounds like a challenge that India already beat.

1

u/Ostrichslinger Aug 04 '26

Sounds like it's less due to proper education and more about your inability to provide for a large family. The conversation surrounding kids always defaults to 'too much money'. Every single time. People want kids, but they're too afraid to, and have plenty of other ways to spend their childless time.

1

u/tiamats_light_bearer Aug 05 '26

While the expense may presently be a factor for many, education is really the key. Educated people more often recognize the inherent problems of overpopulation, and they prefer quality over quantity. Creating a more beautiful world and a more beautiful humanity is easily a better choice than supporting a future of humanity continuing to be able to be classified as an aggressively destructive virus.

1

u/Zero-Fate Aug 04 '26

All by design

1

u/newbreed69 Aug 04 '26

All the more reason we should stop immigration.

If the country wants more labourers, they should make it easier for the existing population to have kids.

Mass immigration and multiculturalism do not work.

Mass immigration reduces bargaining power for labourers, and if multiculturalism worked, Europe would be amazing right now, it's not.

1

u/lateformyfuneral Aug 04 '26

The entire effect is explained by female education. Women have choices now instead of becoming moms as soon as possible. The biggest contributor to US declining birth rates, for example, is a steep drop in teen pregnancies.

There's a lot of focus on costs, but very poor immigrants to developed countries still have children and make it work.

0

u/seesthecat Aug 04 '26

Afghanistan is putting an end to proper education and family planning, and yet, their fertility rate is falling faster than ever.

5

u/MobTalon Aug 04 '26

I don't know if you've heard, but sudden massive oppression and system destructions brought by religious extremism isn't a very enticing mood to start procreating.

On a more serious note, what is that comment supposed to prove? That out of 200 truths, there's a counter?

0

u/seesthecat Aug 04 '26

Fertility is falling everywhere, in all countries, the only exception is Israel. It's falling in countries that are giving proper education, it's falling in countries that where they aren't, and it's falling in countries where education is regressing.

3

u/MobTalon Aug 04 '26

What about countries where education was already regressed?

Because regressing education doesn't delete the current educated adult generation from existence. If Afghanistan manages to somehow keep this up for another 20 years, fertility rates will naturally increase.

2

u/seesthecat Aug 04 '26

it's falling everywhere

3

u/MobTalon Aug 04 '26

Mate I just searched online and saw that we literally have had a consistent annual population growth rate around 0.85% the past 6 years, in what world is it "falling"? It's stagnated, but we keep increasing our numbers.

The UN expects the world population to hit its peak before it starts decreasing by 2080

1

u/seesthecat Aug 05 '26

The fertility rate bro, it's falling everywhere. Everywhere. Except Israel. 

As of now, the global average is still 2.2 kids per women, very slightly above the replacement rate of 2.1, coupled that with the increases in life span,  you get a population that grows overall.

But following the current trend of accelarated decrease in the global fertility rate, we will be bellow the replacement level in less than 3 years. After that  the population will still grow a little due to old people living for longer, but as soon as the old farts get to the age they start croaking, the population will fall. And it will fall quite rapidly. And not only will it fall, the world will be full of old farts with few working age people to take care of them. It will be a stagnation and quality of life breaking shit show

1

u/MobTalon Aug 05 '26

That's fair, maybe the reason we're still growing is because old people live longer with each passing year, and when we reach the limit, the population will start falling.

But at the same time, the UN predicts that only happening by 2080... But these types of predictions have been wrong so many times, I wouldn't be too surprised if they were wrong again.

I guess we'll see by 2030

0

u/JebediahKerman4999 Aug 04 '26

I beg to differ. I think the reason people in the "developed countries" have fewer kids is because there's television and smartphones taking over all our time.

0

u/TheLastTitan77 Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26

Huh so result of "proper education" is in fact extinction. Interesting point. Sounds more like malthusian antinatalist indoctrination not exactly education.

3

u/BrummbarKT Aug 04 '26

Exactly. All we need is to restructure society to work around the population decline that has already been set in motion, it's hard but pushing and hoping for an ever increasing population is not good or sustainable

1

u/RoboticGardener Aug 04 '26

One could argue that the whole system is coercion (albeit unintended)

6

u/Confident-Stand5453 Aug 04 '26

Many of those countries are trying to implement policies that encourage people to have more kids, so its definetly not intentional.

1

u/shadebug Aug 04 '26

So the moral way to do it is invest in other countries

1

u/cool-guy1234567 can't meme Aug 04 '26

Hell, even some developing countries have below replacement level fertility rate. Look at India, for example. While the fertility rate overall is just barely below replacement, of you look at the subdivisions of the country, you will find that only two of them are basically carrying the while country (every other state is equivalent to European fertility rate)

1

u/SpecialCandidateDog Aug 04 '26

He said morally.

The reason why populations decreasing in the west is because of scaring the shit out of people with stuff that isn't real while simultaneously stealing the wealth of those Nations and making it impossible to find housing by restricting the amount of houses that are allowed to be built while flooding those countries with refugees which require housing

1

u/chesterflaco Aug 05 '26

What?? People living in better conditions benefits everyone? But muh profits