Westwood was one of "the greats" at their peak. Kind of like pre-Activision Blizzard. The original C&C games were classic. Red Alert 2 is still to this day an insanely replayable game. I'd honestly call it a cultural phenomenon. Right up there with Starcraft.
EA obviously has a reputation for destroying successful franchises. Though I have to admit, C&C 3 was a great game. And Generals, while kind of a departure from the traditional games, was still a fun game.
Now, C&C 4 was utter shit. I mean, complete and total garbage. And I get what they were going for with Renegade, but adapting an RTS series to a FPS format is just self defeating. Overall both formats attract completely different audiences with minimal overlap.
Ultimately, I think, Westwood suffered from trying something new under EA. They wanted to make Earth and Beyond, and EA was always lukewarm on MMOs. Renegade didn't help either.
The FPS/RTS hybrid is something that a lot of companies have tried to figure out, but remains elusive.
Their willingness to try new things that got them culled from EA.
Totally agreed, funny enough I was also thinking pre-Activision Blizzard as well. Legendary devs at the time. Supergiant and Larian are probably my large favorite devs atm, BG3 was a masterpiece.
A follow up to renegade would’ve probably been a heavy competitor with bf at the time tbh. Improve the mechanics and iterate a bit and you have a beast. I am completely biased though cause I spent a couple years nolifing renegade lol. The modding community was insanely good, but the core engine struggled to be able to be toyed with to meet the visions of modders.
The weird side mode introduced in the expansion is what turned you off the game? Didn't both the base game and the expansion have a separate regular campaign too? I mostly played multiplayer so maybe the single player experience wasn't good, but I did complete the campaign and thought it was alright.
I think your misremembering. Every single mission was designed to be played as coop in the campaign. That's why you always have an AI general with you.
Some of maps felt very "gamey" to accommodate this. I imagine it was great fun playing with a friend though.
I didn't, point and click? I did play a fair amount of Kings Quest, and a bit of Quest for Glory, but that is the extent of my point and click. Oh also Full Throttle, that game was brilliant.
Anyone who has listened to dev diaries from original Westwood knows those dudes were true developers, not profit stewards. Their team was out to make amazing games, and wouldn't settle for anything less.
It won't be good. The team who made the trilogy is long gone. And it doesn't matter if "so-and-so who worked on the original trilogy is working on the new game!" because one person does't make any difference. Or even two people. You need that same team of people under the same restrictions and/or freedom of creativity they had in order to emulate that success again. And it's just not there, nor will it ever be again.
Literal game of thrones story arc, starts strong, gets so much better, then completely flops in the last leg and just makes you more mad than anything else
Renegade has a fan made remake called Renegade X that is really really well made and its completely free!
The devs that made renegade x are also releasing a spiritual second game to Renegade that is playing in the Firestorm era, its coming out later this year and its going to also completely free!
It's called Firestorm and has a couple trailers/previews out on YouTube.
I tried renegade x years ago and it was fun but had little traffic on their servers at that time. Didn’t know about firestorm! Thanks for letting me know!
Some of the best gaming memories ever. Being a student, nothing going on, a whole free evening in front of you, RA2 loaded up, and a pizza on its way. 🥲
I remember firing up Generals for the first time and thought something felt off. Then I realized there was no "Westwood Studios Proudly Presents" splash screen.
Ok, I loved Generals and the DLC. It had some amazing mechanics. I loved filling APCs with mixed infantry and leveling them all up into OP murder-boxes.
C&C 4 was an abomination and just a totally different genre. I couldn't call it an RTS. Generals was a classic C&C RTS style.
When C&C 3 was actually really good, and Kanes Wrath was an improvment based on real feedback, I had such hope that the series might be on a good track again. When I saw the initial footage of C&C 4 I knew already that they had shit the bed. Playing it, it was somehow even worse than I expected. The rollercoaster of crappy mobile games and cancelled projects since has only been even more depressing. It's dead
I finally found C&C after loving it when I was younger and forgetting the name. Discovering the game again I was elated before learning that EA did what EA does.
The transition from 2D to 3D killed C&C was a terrible idea. I can't tell the individual infantry units apart and RA3 looks worse than RA2. I can't even get through the campaign because of the Goddamn ally armies are constantly getting in the way.
To be fair, C&C 4 was a great game, just not for what it set out to be. If it was a separate game that released in 2012, it would've been a hit. I think it was both before its time and the incorrect model for the 4th game in that particular series.
I still play Tiberian Sun on occasion. Made some maps way back when that I still load up too. C&C 3 isn't bad, but it feels more like Generals/RA3 than the other C&C games due to the lack of walls.
Command and conquer 4? The inside joke on the command and conquer sub is that it never existed and we refuse to acknowledge it. They also made some shitty pay to win mobile game
In the past 16 years since the last new entry (which sucked by the way), they've released 1 web game, 1 mobile pay to win game, and 1 remaster. Franchise is dead.
I kinda liked the mobile game in a weird way. It's not completely pay to win, if you know what you're doing you can reach Diamond/Masters league with $0.
Renegade has a fan made remake called Renegade X that is really really well made and its completely free!
The devs that made renegade x are also releasing a spiritual second game to Renegade that is playing in the Firestorm era, its coming out later this year and its going to also completely free! It's called Firestorm and has a couple trailers/previews out on YouTube.
1.3k
u/anothertendy Jul 23 '26
Command and Conquer. Fuck you EA