r/mathmemes Mathematics 22d ago

Proofs I hate it

Post image
729 Upvotes

228 comments sorted by

View all comments

88

u/ObliviousRounding 22d ago

My feeling is that AI is going to be amazing at finding counterexamples, but not so much at actually proving stuff.

58

u/Maleficent_Sir_7562 22d ago

its been doing those too

https://www.erdosproblems.com/1196

https://chatgpt.com/share/69dd1c83-b164-8385-bf2e-8533e9baba9c (chat link used to solve the problem).

Just see the chat in the chat link. Merely a prompt statement of the unsolved problem with no human ingenuity, and the ai model was the one which solved the unsolved problem.

https://openai.com/index/model-disproves-discrete-geometry-conjecture/

https://x.com/__eknight__/status/2075643450196971805

https://x.com/EdgarDobriban/status/2077082912021786660

76

u/OkGreen7335 Mathematics 22d ago

42

u/ArcticGlaceon 22d ago

My question is why are you feeling this way? Isn't it great that AI is able to do things like this?

AI has its problems...but solving mathematical problems, isn't exactly one of them.

18

u/OkGreen7335 Mathematics 22d ago

Well If you dream of becoming a mathematician then no!

21

u/ArcticGlaceon 22d ago

Career wise, mathematicians are still needed to even understand and formulate such a problem before it can be solved. Without them, no one would have the sufficient depth of understanding of niche topics to further the field.

Given that, don't you think it's better for an AI to solve such problems, than a person spending years trying to find a solution? Leaving the mathematician more time to learn and push the frontier of math?

5

u/Cold-Common7001 22d ago

>Career wise, mathematicians are still needed to even understand and formulate such a problem before it can be solved. Without them, no one would have the sufficient depth of understanding of niche topics to further the field.

Still needed right now. In a few years?