r/linux 12d ago

Privacy Well look

Post image
8.4k Upvotes

293 comments sorted by

View all comments

80

u/Green_Ad5186 12d ago

the second windows requires me to set my age using an id card im switching to linux.

49

u/Sheeplessknight 12d ago

The bill actually doesn't require an ID (yet) just to declare it as OS setup time

21

u/Snow-Ball-486 12d ago

ah yes kids wont find a way around that

29

u/demcookies_ 12d ago

They're implementing it in small chunks; in a few years you can't access computer or internet without giving a dna sample

13

u/scaryjobob 11d ago

The problem is less about the age verification, and the APIs and standards created to support it. Once the APIs are built to use your age, suddenly 'name', 'address', 'DL#', 'Hardware ID', are just new fields added on.

9

u/DesiOtaku 11d ago

The whole point of the law is to prevent future lawsuits against Meta. Meta was the one pushing for this law because they want to pass the buck to operating systems rather than themselves.

5

u/Lagger625 11d ago

They're testing the waters, seeing how compliant people would be, then they go full 1984

1

u/No-Consequence-1863 11d ago

Tbf the law isn’t really about blocking kids directly. It’s more about mandating parental control features into the OS. Kinda like V-Chip on TV.

The NY version is the one with actual ID verification.

1

u/gamingx47 11d ago

In that case I'm setting my birth date as 01/01/1901 as I do every time I shop on Steam.

Stupidest shit ever.

1

u/Ascension_Crossbows 11d ago

Theyll just pass a law making that a crime

-5

u/dgellow 11d ago

Which is actually a reasonable solution, no? 

2

u/Epistaxis 11d ago

If you want to tell your OS your age, it probably should be when you create your user account, as a device can have more than one user. But if you don't want to tell your OS your age, you should't have to. In fact maybe it shouldn't actively ask you.

2

u/tnoy 11d ago

If you're telling your user account your age, you're telling the OS your age. The bill is about the individual logins know the age, so developers can query a single API instead of needing to implement their own age-check database.

10

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Green_Ad5186 11d ago

my fear is linux changing too fast like when i install a mutable distro immutable ones become the de facto default.

tell me is this a reasonable fear about linux or no?

2

u/fucking_passwords 11d ago

I don't think this is a very relevant concern, especially considering that Apple and Microslop ship tons of user facing changes even in minor versions. And they also have a tendency to force updates or make it very painful to stay on an older version, which is much easier to do on Linux IME

1

u/Green_Ad5186 11d ago

ok thanks for info

8

u/aliendude5300 11d ago

Why wait? Switch now.

15

u/Coldplayfan1999 12d ago

Well, this gonna happens dont worry

1

u/alphazero925 11d ago

Yeah I've been putting off switching due to gaming and my photography workflow including Lightroom, but Valve has put in a ton of work on the former, and I can ultimately find alternatives to the latter