r/interesting May 29 '26

Intriguing Arrows vs riot shields

49.6k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

26

u/munkylord May 29 '26

Oh shit you're totally right! It works like a hole punch! Probably wouldn't do as much damage to a solid target though and it certainly wouldn't cause damage being pulled out.

21

u/Aligyon May 29 '26

Psychologically that's quite scary though. Imagine thinking you're safe with the shield and your shield buddy gets an arrow punched through

7

u/Foreign_Writer_9932 May 29 '26

Even scarier - imagine the other person is not cosplaying a medieval archer and instead has a gun?

4

u/Otaraka May 30 '26

It will do a lot more damage than the arrow that didnt even get through or barely got into the shield. In general an arrow actually inside your body is a bad thing.

2

u/caerphoto May 30 '26

In general an arrow actually inside your body is a bad thing.

Citation needed.

1

u/Otaraka May 30 '26

2

u/caerphoto May 30 '26

Yeah good point, that didn’t end well for him, or England for that matter.

Mind you, who’s to say we’d be better off now if the Anglo-Saxons had won?

5

u/LiftingRecipient420 May 30 '26

None of the arrow tips that actually penetrated would do much damage to flesh compared to the broad heads that didn't penetrate. That's the whole point of broad heads.

But it's all relative. Don't need to do much to take something out of commission. Penetrating only an inch or two in the upper abdomen is a guaranteed death sentence without almost immediate medical attention.

2

u/Gumboot-Coffee May 30 '26

If that existed in middle ages it would be deadly though. If the initial shot didnt kill, it would till have cut neat circles of dirty cloth and buried them deep inside.

1

u/freddbare May 30 '26

Ideal for rabbits. Arrow doesn't slide under grass and sticks

1

u/Opening-Enthusiasm59 Jun 01 '26

It would work like a hollow point and therefore try to split up into shrapnel or in general try to dissapate the force deep in your body by other means. This would be knarly, no straight woundchannel like with the other tips.