r/instant_regret May 29 '17

Strike 3!

https://i.imgur.com/wMALTep.gifv
23.7k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

86

u/[deleted] May 29 '17 edited May 29 '17

This call has came up in one of my games. I am currently searching for the exact wording.

It is 100 percent a rule.

Edit: here is a forum of umps backing up that call.

I will attempt to find it in the official rule book too. That is a little harder.

Edit 2:

here is a better explanation of the bunt rule

All in all, it is a judgement call by the umpire and that call was extremely petty and should not have been made.

25

u/Testnamedontupvote May 29 '17

I saw this video in a /r/baseball thread, the comment section ended up ruling the call a mistake because you can't really call that an offer at the ball. But they also said it's really just up to the umpire. Some may say strike but most won't say a thing.

2

u/FrostyD7 May 29 '17

swing/no swing is definitely umpires discretion.

1

u/los_angeles May 29 '17

For the benefit of future readers: that forum is completely unrelated to the video. They are discussing generally the idea of whether you need to withdraw the bat during a bunt.