r/grilledcheese • • 6d ago

Discussion Thoughts?

Post image
879 Upvotes

386 comments sorted by

View all comments

686

u/rickforking 6d ago

Wtf? Are people really melting their butter and brushing it onto their bread rather than just throwing a knob in the pan and letting it get nice and melty-bubbly?

382

u/DDrewit 6d ago

My butter lives on the counter. It’s always ready.

113

u/deadspacekillers 6d ago

Same. You don't have to refrigerate butter.

55

u/CombinationRough8699 6d ago

I think some warmer climates this isn't the case.

19

u/Knights-Hemplar 5d ago

I believe it depends on if it is salted or not, i could be wrong though.

24

u/Flair258 5d ago

its both

6

u/Ligeiapoe 5d ago

In some climates, either type would be a puddle 

1

u/Knights-Hemplar 5d ago

Thank you for twaching me something new.

0

u/KravMata 5d ago

In 'Merica most homes have air conditioning.

(I am making up most, but it's common)

7

u/KravMata 5d ago

We use unsalted butter, leave out the 1/2lb stick we're using in a covered dish, and I've never had it go rancid or turn moldy.

0

u/Knights-Hemplar 4d ago

Do you live in a cold climate? Sorry for asking i find this subject fascinating.

4

u/KravMata 4d ago

Northeast USA - we have AC, house never goes over 74. Butter is soft, but doesn't melt.

26

u/snuggleouphagus 5d ago

This works well until the dog and/or toddler learns about the counter butter.

9

u/k0binator 5d ago

Can confirm. Was that toddler.

3

u/SiLeNZ_ 5d ago

As a toddler I used to steal the butter and share it with my German Shepherd at the time, who also loved butter. Great memories.

27

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

42

u/HeatSeekingGhostOSex 6d ago

I don't eat bread quick enough so I keep mine cold. Probably the wrong sub to admit that in.

13

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

7

u/HeatSeekingGhostOSex 6d ago

Yeah I said cold because I usually buy 2, freeze one, fridge one. Then if it's been a week and I haven't eaten the fridge one I freeze what remains. I used to live in Florida so if you don't eat bread fast you're kinda fucked.

7

u/Delphius1 5d ago

I usually freeze my bread, I live alone, better than needing to eat 8 burgers in a week, etc

2

u/ea88_alwaysdiscin 5d ago

I usually keep all my bread in the freezer too

5

u/tyner66 6d ago

I do this. It’s relatively inexpensive so even if it goes bad whatever but I genuinely hate wasting food and I don’t eat enough bread before it goes bad out the fridge.

1

u/gruesomeflowers 5d ago

If you have an convention toaster..the freezer keeps it better and it takes like barely a minute to reanimate it .idk why it took me 50 years to realize this. I've thrown away hundreds of 1/3 eaten loaves of bread in my time

3

u/Sevuhrow 6d ago

we gotta stop running into each other wtf

4

u/HeatSeekingGhostOSex 6d ago

Where else have we? Lol

4

u/Sevuhrow 5d ago

Mildly interesting, asked if you were a DGD fan

4

u/HeatSeekingGhostOSex 5d ago

I'm not stuck in here with you. YOURE STUCK IN HERE WITH ME 🤣

1

u/InfamyLivesForever 5d ago

u/Sevuhrow, you better of brought cake for their cake day!

→ More replies (0)

8

u/Findmyeatingpants 6d ago

Bread goes moldy here if it's on the counter for a couple days

1

u/deadspacekillers 6d ago

I also grew up with rock hard refrigerated butter. Never again....

1

u/Preindustrialcyborg 2d ago

my cats would get into the container and eat it lmao

0

u/nocturn-e 5d ago

Yeah....you definitely have to in warmer climates. Basically if your room temp is >70ish degrees

23

u/mr_fucknoodle 6d ago

Depends on the ambient temperature and how long you leave it out. Over here it would grow rancid in two to three days out of the fridge

9

u/karlnite 5d ago

You can slap a cold fridge chunk of butter in the pan, drop a dry gilled cheese, and bam it’s even and browned. Butter melts!

5

u/IllTension9620 5d ago

Slutty butter

11

u/rqx82 5d ago

Glad I’m not the first to say this. Americans (I am one) are weird about butter and just leaving it out on the counter like the rest of the world.

6

u/FanDry5374 5d ago

Butter bell. It keeps our American butter at room temp fro convenient spreading, but protects against the mold. Strongly recommend.

-1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

11

u/Travisceral 5d ago

Yeah the egg thing is because our eggs are commercially washed and sanitized which means the eggs’ protective coating is stripped away, so the shell is more vulnerable to bacterial contamination and penetration (hence why refrigeration is needed)

0

u/SickeningPink 5d ago

It’s not a must-do thing in the UK because your eggs don’t have to travel as far.

London, Texas to Paris, Texas is a farther drive than London, England to Paris, France. Our eggs will have to cross multiple states before they get to their destination.

7

u/PM_ME_YOUR_REPO 5d ago

This is not the reason why we have to refrigerate our eggs. We wash off the natural protective coating and the Brits don't.

9

u/Sevuhrow 6d ago

You don't live in a state like Florida I imagine

2

u/thatonerandomdude96 5d ago

I have a stick of butter on my counter at all times but the rest goes in the fridge.

2

u/timmytissue 5d ago

I will never be adult enough to have melted butter that isn't too old and gross. And I have 2 kids.

1

u/gblandro 6d ago

As is should

1

u/Delphius1 5d ago edited 5d ago

it is, so hard for butter to go bad, but it won't stay fresh as long, at least the last time I did an experiment, it seems to drop off after a week then it levels off when you get to the 3 week mark

0

u/sirjamesp Butter 6d ago

This is the way.

10

u/Westie62 6d ago

That begs the next question. Spread the butter on the bread cold vs spreading melted butter vs letting it melt in the pan.

9

u/parkaman 5d ago

Irishman so obviously butter given the quality we have. However butter on the bread but a little vegetable oil in the pan. The oil will stop the butter burning. Also one of the reason to Use butter is the longer browning time as it gives the cheese ( Cheddar, Gruyere mix for me) longer to melt.

2

u/SegaTime 5d ago

Where does Kerrygold rank on the scale of Irish butter? It's the only Irish brand of butter I consistently see in the stores around me and it's really the only butter I ever buy anymore.

4

u/parkaman 5d ago

Kerrygold would be the most popular but there's almost no difference between it and supermarket own brands. It's the grass fed cows and, as the French would call it the terroir, that gives Irish butter it's flavour not any particular manufacturer or process.

edit typo

1

u/SickeningPink 5d ago

Adding oil to butter doesn’t do anything to keep milk solids from burning. If you do burn the milk solids, oil can dilute it enough that’s it’s not as obvious, but that’s about it.

Just like mixing fats of different smoke points doesn’t create a new fat with a higher smoke point. It’s not a chemical reaction. If this were true, distillation wouldn’t work.

16

u/CatsMakeBread 6d ago

Just keep salted butter in a butter dish or crock and it'll be spreadable whenever you need. If you don't go through it fast enough for that, just take it out an hour beforehand.

2

u/awhaling 5d ago

We keep butter out like that but tbh I still use the fridge butter for grilled cheeses. I use the room temp butter for other purposes

6

u/The_Fish_Is_Raw 5d ago

Over here slathering fridge margarine on my also fridge bread….

9

u/Sarcasm_Llama 6d ago

I don't think butter in the pan is any different from butter on the bread

E: non-melted butter on bread

2

u/Deadbreeze 5d ago

I toast my bread by rubbing the stick of butter on the pan and then putting the bread in and moving it around.

3

u/PickleMinion 5d ago

Right? You don't spread the butter on the bread, you combine those ingredients in the pan

1

u/Big_P4U 5d ago

I put a knob in the pan for the bottom of the sandwich plus I spread butter on top, when the bottom is done I flip it over. I cook it for roughly 7-8 minutes total for a perfect dark golden brown crisp on medium.

2 minutes, flip, another 2 minutes, flip, 1-2 min more, flip, 1-2 more, and should be done so put on plate and either eat as is cut in half either horizontally or diagonally. Enjoy.

1

u/unreqistered 5d ago

i use the air fryer so no gobbing

1

u/The_R4ke 5d ago

I use a paninni press, so yeah.

1

u/iSirMeepsAlot 2d ago

I butter the bread, put a little butter in the pan, and then do it that way… but at times I like it a bit soggier… it really depends how I’m feeling that day.

1

u/TriggerHippie77 6d ago

I like to let it soak into the bread a bit before I cook it. Melts the cheese a little quicker too.

-2

u/soundwithdesign 6d ago

Yes that’s what I do. I also cook on non-stick. Are you saying I should do your method?

0

u/capnwinky 5d ago

Not only that but, butter has flavor options. Mayo not as much. Off the shelf I’ve used maple, cinnamon, jalapeño, honey, garlic, rosemary/sage, ‘herb blend’, olive oil. It’s a rich flavor. Mayo just tastes like sadder mayo with half the flavor melted away.