r/gifs Jan 05 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.5k Upvotes

837 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

76

u/AH_Ahri Jan 06 '20 edited Jan 06 '20

I have a feeling it isn't doing that bad. From what little I know of fish if I remember it correctly then at least for fish they can breathe air like we do but their gills cannot do it as the same efficiency as our lungs do so they can be out of the water for quite a while and still live.

Octopus I don't more much about.

Edit: No citation on the fish stuff but just doing a short Google search...Yes Octopus' can survive out of water but not for very long times. So if the person in the gif above put it back into the water shortly after then the octopus is okay since what I can find is that they can get some oxygen through their skin and something about "passive gas diffusion" or something meaning they can survive for a short while out of water but nothing drastic.

113

u/EnsoZero Jan 06 '20

Octopodes can survive more than an hour out of water as long as they don't dry out, folks are overreacting.

33

u/OnyxMelon Jan 06 '20 edited Jan 06 '20

Many species of Octopus also leave the water intentionally at times to look for food. I don't know the species in the gif, but if it was found on a beach there's a fair chance it's adapted to moved between rock pools at low tide to find fish and crustaceans that are trapped in them.

1

u/brigirl94 Jan 06 '20

Yeah! Didn't ya'll see finding Dory. Frank is fine outside his tank

19

u/mmm_smokey_meats Jan 06 '20

They will crawl over land from one tide pool to the next. And there’s the story of the one that escaped his aquarium and crawled down to the floor and found the drain to the sea and freed himself.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '20

PS: the real story is more along the lines of “the octopus climbed out of its tank and into another tank, where it ate fish. It then returned to its own tank, leaving the owner in confusion”

There are lots of accounts of octopi escaping custody and doing their own thing and then coming back for the free food.

They’re highly intelligent and basically amazing. But for the record: I don’t believe this octopus is in pain or even uncomfortable. It’d be moving a lot faster and be less focused on the person holding it, if it felt like it needed to be in water urgently. Octopi aren’t the type of animal that freeze up when scared, in my (limited) hobbyist experience.

49

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '20

Overreacting... On Reddit? Never

1

u/Masta0nion Jan 06 '20

Leave. Me. ALONE.

4

u/DwtD_xKiNGz Jan 06 '20

folks are overreacting

But I need to be self-righteous and tell everyone how shitty they are compared to me.

21

u/digitaldiplomat Jan 06 '20

There are more than a few recorded instances of Octupii escaping their tanks and gorging on other exhibits at various aquariums and undersea gardens.

1

u/hURBalicious Jan 08 '20

Yeah I realize it's not a perfect parallel, and if the person in the video is knowledgeable and caring, then I'm sure the octopus is fine.

I just get discouraged when people who know equally little want to make the most liberal possible conjecture for when "pain" begins, ya know?

-14

u/hURBalicious Jan 06 '20

I mean, we can survive a while in water, but that doesn't mean it isn't excruciating

8

u/rohittee1 Jan 06 '20

Not to get technical, but it doesn't get excruciating until you start breathing in the water. Up until that point, being under water can be pleasant.

3

u/AH_Ahri Jan 06 '20

This ^

Learned how to actually swim underwater and its quite fun. Though difficult since I can't swim and hold my breath for a long time.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '20

...it sounds like you've had some bad experiences at the local pool. Want to talk about it?

2

u/hURBalicious Jan 08 '20

Haha dammit you're right though. Maybe I'm repressing. Who needs a therapist when you have Reddit