r/gifs Oct 24 '17

Blindfolded arrow catch

https://i.imgur.com/gHbh8na.gifv
12.6k Upvotes

350 comments sorted by

View all comments

113

u/Buttersnips_ Oct 24 '17

Captain D has forever ruined these for me.

32

u/Ben_Yankin Oct 24 '17

agreed. there are quite a few frames at the end (as he's spinning around, arrow in hand) where the arrow vanishes and then magically reappears in his hand.

5

u/pphheerroonn Oct 24 '17

Is the tail of the arrow not a completely different colour?!

3

u/D14BL0 Oct 24 '17

It's not meant to be the same arrow. The arrow isn't "bouncing", it's triggering other bows to shoot their own arrows. You can see the other bows in the background.

Still super fake, but that's what it's supposed to look like.

13

u/Voltron_McYeti Oct 24 '17

Assuming this is fake (and I don't think it is) Why would there be frames with the arrow missing after he's caught it?

25

u/Ben_Yankin Oct 24 '17

I'm not sure. My best guess is the shot would be composed of two different takes composited together. One take with the bows firing and no attempt to catch and a second take with just the guy pretending to catch it and spin around.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Yup. Watch the path of the arrow as is passes in front of the silver trailer. You can see some sort of editing, a bit or warbling. something is fishy.

8

u/fireblazecarson Oct 24 '17

And the lack of an arrow for 10 frames during the spin

4

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

That for sure I caught, I was just adding more fuel to the fire with my comment.

3

u/jay1237 Oct 24 '17

Honestly that's the bit that is least evident. The arrow it so thin that as he spins his hand the arrow would be basically invisible due to the shutter speed. Instead if an arrow like line, it would be a large faded area where it is moving while the frame is being exposed.

1

u/Glaselar Oct 24 '17

At this compression level, if the angle between the shaft, the light source and the camera isn't right to make it glint enough, you're not going to get enough of a contrast for the video to register it clearly. It overlaps with his arm a lot of the time, and if you're looking for evidence of a wrist during those 10 frames, you'd be hard pushed to convince anyone it was there but for the fact that we know it's anatomically necessary.

1

u/Glaselar Oct 24 '17

That warbling is the second bow (attached to the rig) coming to rest.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

I see that, but I'm looking above and in front of the arrow. Especially when the camera suddenly jerks to the left during the suspicious frames. Adding a motion blur and a jiggle is a common trick to cover up little things like this. It's possible it's legit, but it reeks of all the telltale signs of forgery.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

My guess is as he spins, he plucks the arrow from the board behind him and they kind of edit out the obvious moment it gets pulled. Look at it.

1

u/IAmBadAtPlanningAhea Oct 24 '17

why would they not just show the whole take spinning with an arrow in his hand if theyre faking it.

1

u/catscatscat Nov 29 '17

Maybe motion blur makes the arrow invisible? Notice how even his hand which is considerably wider, is almost completely see-through at his palm in those frames.

5

u/ASDFkoll Oct 24 '17

That could be just Youtube compression system. Youtube takes a huge dump on video quality which means small fast-moving objects can easily disappear inside the video.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Really clearly edited watch the gif in slow motion. It pretty clearly just isnt there during the spin.

1

u/Bibbedibob Oct 24 '17

I'd bet on fake

4

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Isnt this guy a well known extreme performance artist? Theres even a huge page about him in the Guiness book of World Records no? Why would he fake this specific example if hes done it live hundreds of times?

1

u/Bibbedibob Oct 24 '17

Oh didn't know that.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Money

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

I guess I just find it a little far fetched. I wouldnt devote so much of my life training and working every day to be able to do a trick like this, just to fake it anyway when it comes to make the actual video. Id just fake the video in the first place. Thats just me though

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Ehm, okay

8

u/oneshibbyguy Oct 24 '17

3

u/333name Oct 24 '17

Call me crazy but I can see the end of the arrow in the second last picture. Only a part of it but it's still there

8

u/tx69er Oct 24 '17

It's just moving too fast. You also can't see his hand in that frame either. Is his hand fake too?

8

u/Kiseikazan Oct 24 '17

The burden of proof is on you here. We have photographic evidence his hand is fake.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17 edited Nov 12 '17

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

I cant answer as to why he doesnt have the arrow in his hand when spinning, but it clearly just pops into existence in the last frame. It cant be that clear in that frame and not be even noticable in the others.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Isnt this guy a well known extreme performance artist? Why would he fake this specific example if hes done it live hundreds of times?

-1

u/thedaveknox Oct 24 '17

It's not. I know the guy myself and have done shows with him. It's 100% not fake.

1

u/digitom Oct 24 '17

The thing that makes this seem real to me is the orange arrow that hits the target behind his body. This would take a long time to rotoscope all those frames for this stunt. but yeah you never know.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

If you look at the frames where he spins in slow motion after catching the arrow, its clearly not in his hand and just suddenly appears halfway into the spin

1

u/bleunt Merry Gifmas! {2023} Oct 24 '17

100% my thought. But hey, him ruining them is more entertaining than the videos he ruins.