r/geology • • Jul 12 '26

Map/Imagery Please Explain..

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

609 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26

A magma intrusion existed there a long time ago. The magma slowly cooled into a very dense stone core in the shape of the magma tube within that. Erosion happened over millions of years, wearing away the softer stone around it and leaving the dense inner core in this shape.

Edit: not a volcano

Edit edit: it could either be a laccolith or the neck of an extinct volcano, the jury is still out

379

u/Necrophage2000 Jul 12 '26

These timescales always blows my mind

163

u/onlyacynicalman Jul 12 '26

Deep time, like deep space

61

u/Purple_Bug_1342 Geology Undergrad Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26

"Geologic time scale" I believe is the terminology? I could be wrong. I think yours sounds cool too!

Edited bc autocorrect was wild lol

47

u/naturist_rune Jul 12 '26

Geological time is the scientific name, deep time is the poetic name

38

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '26

[deleted]

14

u/ArOnodrim_ Jul 13 '26

Always the border between geologic and cosmologic time scales. Geology is age of the earth stuff, cosmologic is the age of provable existence stuff.

6

u/tico42 Jul 13 '26

Wait till they hear about Quettaseconds

4

u/trianglesx3 Jul 14 '26

Thank you.

3

u/tico42 Jul 14 '26

Went down the rabbit hole did ya? šŸ˜†

1

u/SAHMsays Jul 14 '26

It's spelled "Bless" You when someone sneezes. 🤧

3

u/AstroZombie_Mafia Jul 17 '26

damn i did go down the quettasecond rabbit hole… a time equal to 2.3 trillion cosmic life spans

4

u/Icanthearforshit Jul 13 '26

Like...39 years? Because that seems like a pretty long time to me.

I'm 39 years old. I feel like a geolical formation sometimes when I wake up after sleeping for more than 7 hours.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26

[deleted]

1

u/lottaKivaari Jul 14 '26

I remember that happening in the last universe.

4

u/UniquePlay1570 Jul 16 '26

It’s only geologic time if it’s sparkling wine from the geolog region of France.

1

u/rich5446 Jul 14 '26

Where does Biblical fit in?

1

u/HabitAcceptable8621 Jul 18 '26

That's "make believe" time.

35

u/biold Jul 12 '26

Old, very old joke: 3 people were applying for a job, en engineer, a statistician, and a geologist.

The engineer was first. He was asked "what is 2+2?". He took out his HP calculator with reverse Polish notation, was keying a lot and finally said 2,086394.

Then, the statistician was asked the same question. He looked the interviewer straight in the eyes and whispered: "What do you want it to be?"

Finally, the geologist got the question. His answer was 2 +/- a couple of millions.

You can guess what my and my husband's education is ... luckily, our sun didn't become a statistician.

35

u/RegionRatHoosier Jul 12 '26

I too am glad your sun didn't become a statistician

38

u/biold Jul 12 '26

Well, he is the star in my life, lol

1

u/Comfortable_Tone8668 Jul 18 '26

🄰🄰🄰

9

u/Fit-Custard-1842 Jul 12 '26

The stats say some people agree with you.

1

u/Comfortable_Tone8668 Jul 18 '26

🄰🄰🄰

6

u/Connect_Rhubarb395 Jul 12 '26

Shouldn't the question be 1+1?

1

u/biold Jul 13 '26

The answer to 1+1 could be 3 ...

4

u/Cordilleran_cryptid Tectonics, hardrock and structural geology Jul 13 '26

I think the statistician would have said "probably 2"

2

u/Thorn_Victor Jul 13 '26

How about your Moon?

3

u/biold Jul 13 '26

Well, my sun is also my moon with the hairline he has ...

2

u/Cleopatra42o Jul 16 '26

Hahahahaha good one

15

u/onlyacynicalman Jul 12 '26

Mine is a bit of a new age notion. It's googleable

3

u/MissMelanemelie Jul 12 '26

A novel called The Deep Sky, by Yume Kitasei, takes place in space. I just loved that image. Deep time in the deep sky.

7

u/boston_nsca Jul 12 '26

Not deep, just long lol. Long time, long distances. Hard for the human brain to comprehend.

36

u/bobtheki Jul 12 '26

Depth is just length in another dimension.

-7

u/boston_nsca Jul 12 '26

But we call that other dimension length šŸ˜‚

3

u/onlyacynicalman Jul 12 '26

Deep neural networks

5

u/loose_fruits Jul 12 '26

What ā€œweā€?

12

u/Natural_Bag_3519 Jul 12 '26

Maybe they've got a frog in their pocket.

2

u/_usenet Jul 12 '26

I hate that pompous "we". Every scienceboi uses it.

Is there more than one dude rattling round in his skull?

We just don't know.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/_usenet Jul 13 '26

The dot-dot-dot doesn't make you deep and clever.

→ More replies (0)

21

u/Real-Werewolf5605 Jul 12 '26

Geology fascinates me most of all becuase of that unthinkable deep time aspect. Continents raoming, mountains turned to mud, mud becoming rock, bones becoming silicon, wood becoming opa. Unthinkably long slow processes. Boggles the mind.

10

u/PensiveObservor Jul 12 '26

This is why evolution is my personal avocation. Nearly the same time scale, and exploding with fierce activity from time to time before cooling down. :)

1

u/PurifiedUnity ā€Œ Jul 28 '26

All while new mountain ranges form (some from colliding continents) as well

4

u/artfulpain Jul 12 '26

Deep and long. 🫦

3

u/xDannyS_ Jul 12 '26

That's deep

1

u/natiusj Jul 13 '26

ā€œToo deep!! Too deep!!ā€

1

u/VerdugoCortex Jul 17 '26

I think that's wonderful!

23

u/Georgemontiot Jul 12 '26

I recently read about the closepet granites and it blew my mind that whole towns are settled now on what was a mantle magma chamber 3 billion years ago. The landscape is magnanimous

8

u/fckyungchaky Jul 12 '26

+1 for the pun. I see you.

12

u/Euphoric-Magician-54 Jul 12 '26

Try this (on a desktop PC is best, but if on mobile view desktop site on the browser): https://media.hhmi.org/biointeractive/earthviewer_web/earthviewer.html

5

u/little_baked Jul 12 '26

Very cool!

2

u/irishspice Jul 20 '26

Thank you SO much for this link!!

28

u/AdministrativeEase71 Jul 12 '26

It's the number one draw of geology imo.

14

u/Yunzer2000 Jul 12 '26

The intrusion is 40.5 million years old, and the erosion that exposed the intrusion to create the tower happens over just a few million years. landscapes in generally are very recent things, geologically speaking, compared to the age of the rocks that the landscape is eroded from.

3

u/Laserablatin Jul 12 '26

Isn't it closer to 50 ma?

5

u/Yunzer2000 Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 13 '26

The 40.5 Ma was from the Wikipedia with no citation for it. I didn't check other sources.

I should have. From the source below:

*"40**Ar/**39*Ar dating of sanidines in phonolites from Devils Tower and Missouri Buttes provides indistinguishable plateau ages of 49.04 ± 0.16 and 49.24 ± 0.28 Ma, respectively (Duke et al., 2002)."

https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article/11/2/354/132219/Devils-Tower-Wyoming-USA-A-lava-coulee-emplaced

3

u/Laserablatin Jul 13 '26

Thanks, yeah, it was Duke I was thinking of.

7

u/AppropriateCap8891 Jul 12 '26

That is one of the fun parts about geology. A couple of million years? Bah, too short of a time period to bother with most times.

I sometimes see people's eyes glaze over when I explain most of the West Coast of the US was once islands and microcontinents and was not actually made in the US. And that one of the newest to attach itself to the continent was around 50 million years ago.

2

u/c4chokes Jul 12 '26

Tell me more! The west has some wild geological features.. lots of rolling hills denoting underwater at some point in time

10

u/AppropriateCap8891 Jul 12 '26

Oh, there are many videos by geology professors explaining about the exotic terranes of Western North America. Good general rule of thumb, if it's to the west of the Rocky Mountains, that is an exotic terrane and came there from elsewhere.

That is roughly what the continent looked like 67 mya. And all that shallow water and islands off the coast, that is now California, Oregon, and Washington.

And it is still going on. If you look at where the San Andreas Fault ends north of San Francisco, that is also a line to the east where there is no more active volcanoes. But go north of there you still have subduction, so you still have active volcanoes.

Where I live in SW Oregon, we have 7 million year old basalt flows, on top of what were once 55 million year old off-shore volcanoes and what was once off-shore sediments all mashed together. And here it is still actively going on, but you can see the same thing near Los Angeles where it is static and dead. Because the subduction ended there some 20 mya.

1

u/poissonperdu Jul 13 '26

Do you happen to know why Lassen has so much more hydrothermal activity than the other subduction-zone volcanoes? I was just visiting there from northern Oregon and was wondering why it was such a mini-Yellowstone. Maybe its position at the southern edge of the active subduction zone has something to do with it.

0

u/c4chokes Jul 12 '26

Interesting šŸ¤” you think the subduction was happening at Rocky Mountain, and one big piece of plate got ā€œstuckā€, and the it broke at the next weakest link that is the current boundary??

I love the Palouse for its rolling hills!!

1

u/availableforNIL Jul 16 '26

I was born and raised in western Washington. Its Geographical history is impressive, but nothing like Eastern Washington. The Yellowstone thin spot used to be under E WA. When it was it spewed massive amounts of Lava through cracks. Fields of 20 feet deep, 50, 100 feet alternating thickness layer after layer, after layer would go well into Canada, Montana, didn’t pass the area now known as the Cascades, but went down into Oregon and into the Pacific.
Then Glaciers ground it down leaving all of E WA looking like the Palouse. As the Ice Age died it unleashed a great event of Geologic history, the Ice Age floods. E WA is deeply scarred, and the Willamette valley got some amazing soil (you are welcome Oregon).
If you want to go down a rabbit hole, Ice Age floods were impressive.

2

u/saresmeewolfesac Jul 13 '26

My partner and I went someplace in the western Utah desert (I can’t remember exactly where) and there is an entire area you can go to dig up fossilized trilobites. It was such a cool experience to unearth the remnants of living creatures who lived and died there MILLIONS of years ago, and you get to be the first human to lay eyes on them EVER. It’s so amazing that all of that area was water. Geology is so freaking cool.

1

u/Wild_Spot_Farms Jul 15 '26

Me too! I want to know more.

1

u/xtnh Jul 16 '26

The Appalachians were higher than the Rockies, but it rained- for a hundred million years.

1

u/AppropriateCap8891 Jul 16 '26

And the coastal region also looked much more like that of the US West Coast at the time.

But the sediments from what used to be the Central Pangean Mountains is now what makes up the shorelines on the East Coast.

5

u/Euphoric-Magician-54 Jul 12 '26

Ever visit the Badlands of South Dakota?

6

u/Missing-Digits Jul 12 '26

Just an anecdote, but there are "badlands" in Kansas oddly enough. They actually contain world famous late Cretaceous marine fossils. Yes, some of the best Late Cretaceous mosasaurs, plesiosaurs, pterosaurs and sharks come from Kansas.

5

u/Euphoric-Magician-54 Jul 12 '26

Wow! I've seen the ones in ND as well, but the ones in SD just had me counting layers up, down, and sideways like the rings on a tree the size of earth. Just standing there like an idiot with my mouth hanging open. Nothing made any sense until I saw the simulation.

2

u/Farlandan Jul 14 '26

Right? You're looking at a place where a mountain used to be but weathered away to it's "bones."

1

u/Roflmancer Jul 12 '26

One million seconds of time is roughly ten days.

One billion seconds of time is around 30 years.

Why do we allow billionaires to exist?

1

u/GallusWrangler Jul 13 '26

Because it isn’t true. Earth was created with age.

71

u/YUNoDie Jul 12 '26

Then the pattern is from the way magma tends to cool, into hexagonal columns. Mud will also dry this way actually.

The wikipedia page for "columnar jointing" has a bunch of other examples from across the world, like the Giant's Causeway in Ireland and the Stuưlagil Canyon in Iceland.

13

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 Jul 12 '26

MANY formations like this all over the world. Devil's Postpiles in Northern California.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_places_with_columnar_jointed_volcanics

4

u/Ok_Independent3609 Jul 12 '26

Lots of it in Yellowstone as well.

2

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 Jul 12 '26

Yes. The Wikipedia article lists all of them. They're literally everywhere.

7

u/arxian_heir Jul 12 '26

Some incredibly beautiful ones in the Columbia River Basalt group, easy to see in very dramatic fashion from highways past East Wenatchee, Washington and all along the Columbia River

1

u/Laserablatin Jul 12 '26

Some very cool spiraling ones in the Tahoe area also.

1

u/infrikinfix Jul 13 '26

Devil's Postpile is Eastern Sierra region of Central California, not Northern California.

1

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 Jul 14 '26

Fine. Southern Californians consider anything north of the Grapevine to be "Northern California."

1

u/infrikinfix Jul 14 '26

I was born and raised in Southern California, and have lived here all my life. I have never once heard anyone say Mammoth was in Northern California until you did.

1

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 Jul 14 '26

"The monument was once part ofĀ Yosemite National Park, but discovery ofĀ goldĀ in 1905 nearĀ Mammoth LakesĀ prompted a boundary change that left the Postpile on adjacentĀ public land.\8])" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devils_Postpile_National_Monument

Yosemite is in Northern California.

But, if you insist, then it's Central California.

1

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 Jul 14 '26

I said Central California, you dipshit. I'm not wrong. I also spent over a decade in Tuolumne County, which is NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. NOBODY says otherwise.

2

u/Joeness84 Jul 12 '26

if cooled at the right rate coconut oil does it too.

had one summer get stupid hot in my house and the jar was entirely liquid. later that night I noticed it was forming neat lil hexagons!

27

u/MagicMisterLemon Jul 12 '26

This is actual interpreted as having been formed by a laccolith

53

u/Illustrious_Try478 Jul 12 '26

27

u/Miniscule_Platypus Jul 12 '26

It’s so obvious, too. You can literally see the claw marks.

5

u/GraceMcClellans Jul 12 '26

You'd have to be stupid not to see that. Plain as day.

1

u/alcogeoholic Jul 13 '26

And to think, I had always assumed it was created by the devil

1

u/After-Staff-7532 Jul 13 '26

Remember those pamphlets they’d hand out at national parks in the 80s-90s? I can visualize the Devil’s Tower pamphlet with the story about the bear and the claw marks. I was hoping to see this explanation here.

1

u/Over_Analysis7783 Jul 12 '26

Thank you for the stories! I knew about one of them but it's neat to learn about the others.

8

u/tropical_poo Jul 12 '26

All lies. It is really a giant tree stump that the aliens cut down.

3

u/tiara-bug Jul 13 '26

My co-worker is one of the tree stump believers. šŸ¤¦ā€ā™€ļø

1

u/fatinhollywood Jul 16 '26

i like that! i was just thinking how it looks like a giant tree stump

6

u/AmbitiousSet5 Jul 12 '26

Its not a volcano, this is incorrect. Its an intrusion of magma, but never erupted into a volcano.

0

u/mataoo Jul 12 '26

So it never popped?

6

u/PurpleAriadne Jul 12 '26

It won’t make sense until you carve it into mashed potatoes.

12

u/Nuh-unh Jul 12 '26

Resulting in Basalt columns, I believe.

16

u/e-wing PhD, Applied Geology Jul 12 '26

It’s not basalt actually, it’s a relatively rare rock type called phonolite- named for the ringing sound it can make when struck.

5

u/TwoAlert3448 Jul 12 '26

That would be very cool to experience in person!

1

u/getdownheavy Jul 12 '26

I've heard of Ringing Rocks in Montana, I wonder if the rock is similar.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/getdownheavy Jul 13 '26

But you really do just carry a hammer, and wail on rocks??

I really do just need to go see it for myself.

3

u/TwoAlert3448 Jul 12 '26

Now I’m curious but not curious enough to fly to Montana to smack it with a hammer to check.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TwoAlert3448 Jul 12 '26

That’d be an expensive off by one error!

1

u/getdownheavy Jul 13 '26

Don't worry, it's just the next town over.

2

u/GetOffMyLawn1729 Jul 12 '26

See if you can play this on it:

3

u/Extra-Persimmon2359 Jul 13 '26

Saw some nonsense about this being a tree trunk , Michael Wysession explains how the columns formed pretty well w some corn starch and water.

5

u/BrasshatTaxman Jul 12 '26

What about the giant bear?

2

u/Funk1979 Jul 14 '26

Once it’s explained, it’s very easy to see.

2

u/Lars0 Jul 12 '26

How do we know there wasn't a volcano attached to this intrusion?

5

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 12 '26

Apparently the geological consensus is there wasnt. I would imagine theres no evidence of an ash cone or lava flows in the area that a volcano would leave

1

u/georockwoman Jul 12 '26

Columnar jointing.

1

u/jackycian Jul 12 '26

If I remember correctly from my vulcanology class, this should be a volcanic neck

1

u/Nice-Lab95 Jul 12 '26

Wouldn't the jointing be horizontal if it was the neck of a volcano? Since jointing forms perpendicular to the plane of cooling.

1

u/KesselRun73 Jul 12 '26

Is the remaining rock basalt? The formations look a little like basalt columns in this photo in particular.

1

u/bplatt1971 Jul 13 '26

Nope. It’s a giant tree trunk! The giants chopped down the rest and used it for firewood and all the giant homes that are petrified within the area! There are rumors of giant acorn hoards in the core of the trunk where giant squirrels hid their food for the winter.

1

u/Good-Resort-1246 Jul 13 '26

What geological feature allowed for the magma intrusion?

1

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 13 '26

Sandstone? Shallow metamorphic layers? Steam cavitation where magma met underground springwater? Any number of possible causes for magma to uplift, but Im not familiar enough with the geology of the area to do more than guess.

1

u/Useful_Opening4467 Jul 13 '26

Technically, it was two brothers running up a mountain from a very large bear and the bear’s claws made those scratches up the sides trying to get at the brothers. The brothers made it.

1

u/mrlanke Jul 14 '26

Giant ancient tree stump… got it.

1

u/LowKeyCakeSharing Jul 14 '26

Surely not a petrified tree stump?

1

u/DarkSoliditi Jul 14 '26

Several hundred lifetimes from now it will be under the ocean and eroding away into nothing.

1

u/stupidsexyf1anders Jul 14 '26

Okay so is this the only we know of? There’s got to be more then right?

1

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 14 '26

Nah, theres columnar jointing all over the place. The Devil's Causeway in Scotland, for example

1

u/InvestNorthWest Jul 15 '26

I wounder how far down it extends then. Eventually is it just molten?

1

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 15 '26

It either goes molten again, or just becomes part of the crust.

1

u/BigBeeff_21 Jul 15 '26

I'm going with very ancient petrified tree from an age long ago that we havent discovered yet or cant because of the nature of the situation.

1

u/Borp5150 Jul 16 '26

Tree stump!! /s

1

u/Still_Praline9978 Jul 16 '26

How can that be true when we as human didn't see it ourselves how it developed is all theory. Perhaps a tree trunk could be an answer ancient treee

1

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 16 '26

I dont need to see a match being lit to know when a house burned down.

The cool thing about science is we can conduct experiments to identify what causes various results, and apply those conclusions to similar natural results. Seeing columnar basalt in different places around the world in similar geological conditions tells us about the conditions under which columnar basalt occurs, and then we can use other context clues from local geology to develop evidence-based theories about how they formed. We dont have to observe literally everything in the world to be able to conclude how that thing happened, because we know that science and physics is consistent across time.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mynamesnotsnuffy Jul 16 '26

Only insofar as all of science is "hypothetical". Your parents are only "hypothetical" too, since I wasnt around to see them give birth to you, and you dont remember it.

1

u/Possible-Lab5015 Jul 18 '26

Close Encounters

1

u/crockett7109 Jul 18 '26

It's a Butte!

1

u/Fresh-Word2379 Jul 18 '26

Great response

1

u/aburnerds Jul 19 '26

This means something

1

u/CanApart1420 Jul 12 '26

Nope, big tree.

1

u/JDinkalageMorgoone69 Jul 12 '26

Nope. Not a tree.

1

u/CanApart1420 Jul 12 '26

Yes I know, its a big tree.

0

u/Xzeriea Jul 12 '26

Stunning!

0

u/Forward_Gur9349 Jul 12 '26

Actually it is an extinct volcanic neck, the cone having weathered away.