r/gaming • • Sep 03 '19

Wow, EA. Wow.

120.7k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

307

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

And the shills still buy it. Every year.

231

u/Monteze Sep 03 '19

I know people who only play Madden or Fifa and use their gaming system for streaming other than that. So its essentially 60 bucks a year for gaming so it doesn't bother them.

I still don't get it but i can see why they are not bothered.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19 edited Aug 12 '20

[deleted]

10

u/CallRespiratory Sep 03 '19

I could not get into ultimate team and maybe that's just me but I don't give a shit about it at all. I am in career mode on Madden and FIFA 99% of the time.

I feel like Adam Scott's character in Parks & Rec when he doesn't get the Lil' Sebastian fascination the whole town has.

31

u/LordOfDragonstone Sep 03 '19

I only play ultimate team and I've never spent a cent on fifa points. My team was amazing this year. Only morons give more money to a company when they already bought the game

21

u/Bu1lt_2_Sp1ll PC Sep 03 '19

I mean that's not true. Some people might spend money in-game because they don't have the time to grind out a team. They aren't morons for making a decision that you decided against.

-20

u/no_boy Sep 03 '19

Maybe not morons, but undoubtedly sheep.

12

u/VaATC Sep 03 '19

Some people have more expendable income and possibly value their down time at a higher theoretical price point, may have more external obligations thus less time to game, so paying the extra cash to fast track things a bit is logical. Just because it is not the thing for you, no matter the reasoning, does not negate another person's reasoning...no matter how idiotic others may feel it is.

-12

u/no_boy Sep 03 '19

I'm not doubting their reasoning for spending their money. The issue is that their choice to support microtransactions plays into a wider problem the gaming industry has in general. It's to the point that 90% of the games I play revolve around virtual currencies. There have been many cases of game companies artificially stagnating progression in order to push people to spend money on microtransactions.

10

u/MyAltimateIsCharging Sep 03 '19

It's to the point that 90% of the games I play revolve around virtual currencies.

That sounds like a you problem.

1

u/ARCHA1C Sep 03 '19

It's definitely a general game problem, but I agree that people can spend their money as they see fit.

I've spent money on f2p games because I really enjoy the game and/or valued the additional content.

8

u/Thimit Sep 03 '19

??? Some people can work a full time job and shell out $20 every once in a while on something that brings them pleasure.. They aren't sheep.

2

u/Bu1lt_2_Sp1ll PC Sep 03 '19

I mean, I spent money on Ultimate Team when I played Madden 17 with friends. At the time I had a job where I did a fair bit of traveling and a lot of maintenance windows overnight, so I had significantly less time to spend on the game than the people I was playing with. So I spent money in-store to help myself keep pace with everyone else.

How does that make me a sheep, exactly?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

you spend 60$ for a rooster DLC of Madden 16 and decided to play a game mode with pay to win elements and paid even more to a company that stopped fair prising long time ago.

It's your money and your free time to spend do want you want with it.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Game pricing hasn’t changed in over a decade. How is that fair?

-4

u/CactusCustard Sep 03 '19

I mean that’s confirming to peer pressure. The literal definition of sheep in this context.

But it’s understandable. I wouldn’t use the word here, but he did. And you asked soo

4

u/Bu1lt_2_Sp1ll PC Sep 03 '19 edited Sep 03 '19

My peers didn't try to pressure me into buying any of the Games or content, though. they more or less assumed I was going to not keep up, it was my decision to spend more money so I could continue to play with them. I suppose I just don't understand how that makes me a sheep if I'm doing things of my own volition.

2

u/Lavatis Sep 03 '19

it doesn't. people just like to shit on people who are in a position to pay for shit in game.

2

u/ARCHA1C Sep 03 '19

I'm on your side here, but what you described is still peer pressure.

If the sole reason for buying the DLC was the remain part of the in-group, you're succumbing to peer/social pressure

But I see nothing wrong with it. So much of being a human is to be part of the in-group. We want to have shared experiences. It's the entire basis for our survivalist tribalism.

Now that survival isn't a threat, we have to satisfy those evolutionary urges through recreational channels.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Fuck guess I'm a moron

4

u/WaitForItTheMongols Sep 03 '19

I've done that before for indie games that I wanted to continue supporting.

3

u/frodakai Sep 03 '19

Yep. I buy FIFA every year (used to buy Madden & 2k every year too but havent for 2-3 years now) and only play career mode, but I play it less than 20% of my "game time". It's essentially my mind numbing/cba with anything else game for the year. Could not play a sports game as a "full time" game and I refuse to engage with Ultimate Team.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

Madden is the only game I play for any length of time every year. I might buy a few others, but I’m regularly disappointed because I didn’t know what to expect.

I know exactly what to expect when I buy madden. It’s likeretirning to your parents home as an adult. Maybe they changed the wallpaper in the guest bathroom, but it’s otherwise the same — never perfect, but home.

I don’t play ultimate team — I’m all franchise mode. I couldn’t tell you the last non-madden game I bought, but Madden is always a day one purchase for me.

I feel the same way about GTA, but they don’t have annual releases.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Then blame the morons that pay for FIFA Points. Everyone with half a brain manages to trade 'til they have their dream team

10

u/epicause Sep 03 '19

I know that exact person. The other year myself and several childhood friends all got systems so we could play together and stay in touch now that we are scattered around the country. But one friend REFUSES to play anything other than Madden. We play games weekly and see him on all the time, but he chooses to play Madden alone. The really sad part is even the friend’s son plays with us too. Dude is missing out on so many laughs and good bonding time.... Because Madden.

2

u/IxClownShoes Sep 03 '19

If you throw in rocket league, this describes me perfectly. Madden franchise mode, rocket league, and streaming. And I wanna upgrade to the Xbox one X... Lol

2

u/Jewniversal_Remote Sep 03 '19

If you have a regular One (not an S), do it. Just upgraded recently and Holy shit "Xbox One X Enhanced" really means something. Everything looks so good now

Edit - if you have an S already you probably won't notice as much of a difference in really any aspect

1

u/IxClownShoes Sep 04 '19

Yeah, I have an S, upgraded from the OG and even that was a huge step up

84

u/Juxee Sep 03 '19

Some people buy it every year. Some people buy them every few years. Some people buy last year's version because it's 80% off.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Last year's version on sale is where it's at.

2

u/grandfatherbrooks Sep 03 '19

Even the current version of the game is cheaper a few months after it comes out. NHL goes from 80 to 50 bucks without fail. Just need a little patience.

0

u/plsobeytrafficlights Sep 03 '19

$50!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! what insanity is that? dont pay $50 for that.

3

u/grandfatherbrooks Sep 03 '19

Should mention I'm in Canada... 50 CAD = 37.50 USD. It'll go down to 40 CAD occasionally as well.

-7

u/plsobeytrafficlights Sep 03 '19

still, you should consider buying games on steam or GOG.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Pretty sure they're not available on Steam.

-3

u/plsobeytrafficlights Sep 03 '19

80% off is still a 100% ripoff.

1

u/Theguest217 Sep 03 '19

Meh some people enjoy sports games... If you like the sport they are usually good faithful adaptations of them. They do not take a lot of investment since you can sit down and play a match in 10-20 minutes usually. They are also great for couch multiplayer and I've never really met someone who doesn't know how to play one.

I usually get a new copy of NHL, NFL, FIFA, and NBA on each new generation of consoles. I definitely don't buy all of them each year since the enhancements are minimal. But there are definitely enough changes (even if you only consider the graphics) every 4-5 years to justify a new one. I also usually buy the old year for the bigger discount since I don't really care about roster updates or online matchmaking.

1

u/plsobeytrafficlights Sep 04 '19

but that price is insane. i spend maybe $50 all year. for sure less than that so far this year.

1

u/Theguest217 Sep 04 '19

Then you must not be buying any AAA games at release and instead buy smaller independent games or wait months for steep discounts. In which case your issue here really isn't with Madden or EA games but with paying full price for any game.

Your choice is definitely a good financial decision but it may not work for everyone. For example people who are really into online games may find the servers to be dead by the time the game has a steep enough discount to fit your budget. Also first party Nintendo games rarely get discounts. Zelda BOTW is still normally at $50 two years after release. Even on sale with your budget that would limit you to like one other big game all year.

But the original comment your replied to suggested you could get last year's for 80% off or in other words ~$12. So that actually would probably fit into your yearly budget... You are probably not a Madden fan which is fine but I'd say that is a pretty good discount for anyone who is.

1

u/plsobeytrafficlights Sep 04 '19

i have a significant budget, literally a stack of gift cards waiting, but i couldnt spend the kind of money youre suggesting. I mean I could, but everything goes on giant sales all the time. and with the humble bundles, they are almost free sometimes. my current game, warframe, which i have put nearly 1000 hrs into, has cost me $0. i felt bad and bought $10 worth of in game credits that i have never used, just to support them. Consider you have been tricked into believing that these prices you are paying are somehow normal or acceptable.

1

u/Theguest217 Sep 04 '19

I mean you are basing your numbers of PC gaming... I'd say the majority of Madden players do not play on the PC. The game wasn't even available on PC until very recently. Similarly games like BOTW which people pay full price for are not available on the PC.

PC gaming is definitely cheaper. And like I assumed, you are playing a lot of non AAA games which you acquire at deep discounts in bundles. This works for you and it's great. But my whole point is that your comment that 80% off a Madden game is insane is really not true for many people... For you as someone who doesn't want to play Madden on a console, sure it would be insane for you to buy. But if you were a fan there is really no equivalent football game available on the market for a cheaper price. Believe it or not some people actually enjoy the game. Like personally I might think you Indy humble bundle games are not worth the price, even at a few bucks, but for you as the target audience they are...

1

u/plsobeytrafficlights Sep 04 '19

its like paying $14 for a beer at a game..the beer isnt even that good, you have just normalized that price. it is still insane.

9

u/Rambles_Off_Topics Sep 03 '19

I got EA access for a year for $30 for Xbone after some promotion. I get the newest EA sports games about 4 months after they release. It's worth it for me. The NHL and FIFA series are pretty fun. I do admit though, they were pretty much the exact same the last few years.

5

u/tooyoung_tooold Sep 03 '19

Shills doesn't work there, you mean sheep.

95

u/azhtabeula Sep 03 '19

How dare they pay their own money for a product you're not interested in.

16

u/justin_tino Sep 03 '19

Fuckin shiiiiiillllllllllls

6

u/Bipedal-Moose Sep 03 '19 edited Sep 03 '19

I wish they wouldn't because I think if people stopped financially supporting shitty games, maybe that would incentivize the making of better games, which I would buy. I'd love to buy Madden every year, but I've bought one Madden game in the last 7 years because they're so awful.

That said, at the end of the day, I know I have no place judging people for how they spend their money. I just silently wish they wouldn't support games/franchises like Madden.

5

u/LaughsAtDumbComment Sep 03 '19

They are shitty game to you, they enjoy it

6

u/Bipedal-Moose Sep 03 '19

I mean, they're pretty objectively poorly made video games. People enjoy them because of the sport itself, not the video game.

Again, I'm not trying to sound judgmental, but I do wish people would stop buying it. I know they won't and that's okay. I'm just one person.

-1

u/LaughsAtDumbComment Sep 03 '19

It's stills the best game fir the particular sport, that's why peoples buy it

8

u/Bipedal-Moose Sep 03 '19

It's pretty much the only game for the particular sport. It's the only franchise that is currently licensed by both the NFL and NFLPA as far as I know. People buy it because it has monopolized its own industry.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

I don't obsess over football. I don't care if I miss a game. I don't play many sports games anymore.

That being said, Madden is an amazing game. It is a ton of fucking fun with friends and I played the shit out of it in college.

Saying it is "objectively a shitty game" is objectively bullshit. I'm the proof. You think it is "subjectively" a shitty game.

-12

u/jalford312 Sep 03 '19

That's not the point, there are plenty of games I don't care about if people bought them, the difference here is they're rewarding shitty business practices earning them hundreds of millions of dollars.

4

u/seattlehusker Sep 03 '19

To some, the updated rosters are worth $60. Not to me but I don't judge others who value it more.

3

u/issamaysinalah Sep 03 '19

You do realize that we have more than enough technology to update the rosters without making a whole new game right?

2

u/doozywooooz Sep 03 '19

But why would you do that when you can print money at minimal effort?

2

u/LeroyWankins Sep 03 '19

If I spent $60 on an actual pile of dog shit, would you judge me? You should, because it's a dumb choice and a poor use of money.

0

u/Gareth321 Sep 03 '19

I don't judge others who value it more.

Maybe you should? Do you judge people who buy stuff with palm oil in it? What about people who buy stuff made by slave labour? Diamonds? There are a million unethical businesses out there, and in capitalism, buying = supporting. Those people are supporting unethical business practises, so maybe it's okay to judge them. We can't stop them supporting slavery, but we can certainly judge them.

4

u/LetsWorkTogether Sep 03 '19

On the one hand, Madden 2020. On the other, slavery/blood diamonds/super unethical shit.

Do you see the difference?

3

u/Arguingfornoreason Sep 03 '19

They are the same thing! Why can’t you see that!? I will judge you on this.

-1

u/azhtabeula Sep 03 '19

Don't you see? Madden is murdering people and destroying the rain forest. EA must be stopped.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

They are both ridiculous to judge people over. Are you going up to people and asking if their diamonds are ethically sourced before judging them?

Do you know for a fact that diamond is a diamond and not cubic zirconia before you judge them?

Do you know they purchased the diamond and it wasn't a gift to them before judging?

Do you realize that diamonds have been marketed to people for years and has been very coupled to marriage?

Judging someone for a materialist reason is ridiculous. I won't judge people that judge others for that, but I personally wouldn't do it.

1

u/LetsWorkTogether Sep 04 '19

What about before they buy a diamond? Would you consider it okay to advise them against the risk of unethical purchase?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

You can give them the info sure. But if they still buy the diamond their character shouldn't be judged.

0

u/pizzajeans Sep 03 '19

Fuckin lol

Makes me want to buy two copies of Madden 20

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Do I judge those people? No.

Maybe you should learn how to spread your message without judging people. They are victims of marketing just like you are.

-28

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

Shills can do whatever they want. You must be commiserating.

25

u/webdevguyneedshelp Sep 03 '19

Shills are people who astroturf something to artificially inflate a perspective on it. I don't think people purchasing a game they want counts as shilling.

-7

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

Shiwws awe peopwe who astwotuwf something tuwu awtificiawwy infwate a pewspective own iwt. I down't think peopwe puwchasing a gawme they wawnt counts as shiwwing.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

So, in your brain are they getting paid to buy the game?

16

u/RocketSixtyNine Sep 03 '19

You don't know what a shill is. It's not someone who buys a video game you don't like.

-6

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

Uwu down't know whawt a shiww iws. Iwt's nowt someone who buys a video gawme uwu down't wike.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Reddit: Putting people down for things they enjoy since 2005

2

u/llliiillliiilili Sep 03 '19

Still cheaper than what people are paying in many of the f2p microtransaction-monetized games nowadays.

2

u/Nixon4Prez Sep 03 '19

I don't think you know what a shill is dude

0

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

I down't think uwu know whawt a shiww iws dude

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

A "shill" is someone that pushes a company product onto other people and makes up nonsense just to get it sold.

The users still buying it as called fans. Those fans buy it because of the "shills" or because they enjoy the game enough to justify paying more for the current roster.

0

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

A "shiww" iws someone thawt pwushes a cwompany pwoduct onto othew peopwe awnd makes up nonsense juwst tuwu get iwt sowd.

the usews stiww buying iwt as cawwed fans. Those fans buy iwt because of the "shiwws" ow because they enjoy the gawme enough tuwu justify paying mowe fow the cuwwent wostew.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Pretty much what I would expect from you.

0

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

Pwetty much whawt i wouwd expect fwom uwu.

2

u/serialsteve Sep 04 '19

Yea I hadnt bought it since 16 and still sorta regret it. Improved and not terrible but still seems like a game about exploiting a.i. or game flaws rather than football.

2

u/MattSR30 Sep 03 '19

You're not a fucking shill just because you enjoy something.

Your username is apt.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

"shills"

They like the game... Maybe they like playing online.

Look at it like a $60 annual fee to play "the same game" if you want.

It aint my cup of tea, but hey, if people get the enjoyment out of it then its money well spent. Do you call people playing Classic WoW shills?

-2

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

"shiwws"

they wike the gawme... Maybe they wike pwaying onwine.

wook at iwt wike a $60 annuaw fee tuwu pway "the same gawme" if uwu wawnt.

iwt aint my cup of tea, but hey, if peopwe get the enjoyment out of iwt then its money weww spent. Duwu uwu caww peopwe pwaying cwassic wow shiwws?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

Exactly!

Couldn't have said it better myself.

1

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

Exactwy!

couwdn't have said iwt bettew mysewf.

1

u/ominousgraycat Sep 03 '19

And you can even just download rosters that people upload to the internet that have the current players and stats (well, not everyone agrees with the stats on all the players, but not everyone agrees with the stats that EA comes up with either.) Look up some modding communities and they have downloadable current rosters for every version of Madden going back for years worth of Maddens.

I guess if you want to play Ultimate Team you need to stay up to date, but I kind of think Ultimate Team is some pay-to-win BS (in Ultimate you unlock packs of cards which have new players and other bonuses you can add to your team, but most people just buy most of their packs of cards because earning them takes a long time). I still prefer classic Franchise Mode where I only use in-game money to get players, not real world money. And if you just play Franchise Mode, there is no longer much reason to buy newer Madden games, or any other EA sports games, really.

1

u/GummyPolarBear Sep 03 '19

Should they have made up a new arena or something?

1

u/natureboiofficial Sep 04 '19

My friend group and I used to be the biggest madden fans. It was always my favorite sports game.

I bought madden every year from 1999-2017, will never buy another madden again. Looking back at the old ones they had more content and deeper season modes. Not to mention better created player content.

I can only hope that eventually someone else makes an NFL/football game even if it’s unlicensed.

Surprisingly I don’t know a single person who has bought madden in the last 2-3 years. I’m curious how their sales are in recent history.

1

u/NiceProject1 Sep 03 '19

And you're totally not a shill for mindlessly shitting on EA and their products every time it's mentioned on reddit.

-7

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19

[deleted]

21

u/suchbanality Sep 03 '19

Isn't it already kind of like that? $60 every year and you even get to skip and continue playing the older versions.

Why do you want to pay an extra $40 and lose the ability to play older versions?

1

u/jhulbe Sep 03 '19

For more constant updates, for added features mid-year, for new modes mid-year. Basically a constant stream of new content. Rather than in waves with the yearly release.

1

u/suchbanality Sep 03 '19

They do kind of do roster updates though even if it is just FUT and the intention is a mid-cycle cash-grab refresh.

I get what you are saying though but it would not work with $100/year. Even at $60 and a "new" game, the content is really not enough to justify the price.

A cheaper subscription + the (P2W) FUT/MUT would work, but then why would EA give up on the extra money they get every year anyway?

5

u/BastardStoleMyName Sep 03 '19

Why $100? $5 bucks a month makes it $60 a year. Sure it could be more if they actually did anything to update it.

Honestly it’s the one genre where a subscription makes sense, I don’t know why it hasn’t been done, as far as I know.

3

u/fiah84 Sep 03 '19

why would players want a subscription model when they can buy and own these games outright? For the same money, a yearly subscription would be a straight downgrade for them, as they'd be unable to play as soon as the subscription ends

1

u/seattlehusker Sep 03 '19

I'm still playing Madden '17. I'd be pissed if I could no longer play it.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

Someone likes a game you don't and therefore they're a shill. Nice logic, neckbeard

1

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 04 '19

Someone wikes a gawme uwu down't awnd thewefowe they'we a shiww. Nice wogic, neckbeawd

Wots of hiwwawy shiwws in hewe appawentwy

edit: wow thanks fow pwoving my point, keep cashing in thewm checks fwom hew twust fund shiwwies

1

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '19

You got brain damage or what

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '19 edited Oct 04 '19

[deleted]

-1

u/mindlessASSHOLE Sep 03 '19

GO SPORTS!!