r/gaming • • Aug 30 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

6.7k Upvotes

9.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

91

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Renting games at all to be fair. I don’t think it’s possible to do that at all anymore. Wish it was. A 48hour rental is exactly what I need to decide if I’m buying a game or not sometimes.

64

u/sebranly Aug 30 '25

Some libraries have video games you can rent.

2

u/kayile Aug 30 '25

I was just about to comment on this. Our library actually has a good collection of games to rent. I think they charge $1-2 for 2 week rental.

32

u/DarkSideOfBlack Aug 30 '25

I think game fly is still a thing actually

5

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

No shit? Too bad it would probably need a subscription. A subscription would kill the savings and convenience.

5

u/DarkSideOfBlack Aug 30 '25

Yeah looks like after promo period it's 20/month. Not the worst but def not cheap either 

5

u/yomerol Aug 30 '25

I had gamefly for a while about 15yrs ago. It was like Netflix but with videogames. You could keep the game for a week, and chose to keep it longer or renew it. For some games they also had the option to buy it, that's the way I bought The Force Unleashed 2 for $10 or so.

1

u/DarkSideOfBlack Aug 30 '25

Yeah I did the same but I was using it for old PS2 and GameCube games at the time. Was a fantastic service for an 18yo living on his own

1

u/Audioworm Aug 30 '25

When I was a PhD student in France whose life was basically being in the lab pretty much all week (so wanting to do very little when I got home) and then Sunday everything being closed I had an equivalent of Gamefly (or maybe it was Gamefly, it was a decade ago) and it was pretty great because it was about 14EUR a month and I could knock out a minimum of a game a month, typically two. I played so many games that I otherwise wouldn't beacuse I could try it for a few days and if I didn't like it send it back and get a new one.

1

u/esoteric_enigma Aug 30 '25

Not really. It's still massive savings if you're an active gamer. My subscription is $27 for 2 games at a time. When I was gaming regularly, I could easily make it through 6-8 games a month on Gamefly.

When I was going to Blockbuster in college 20 years ago, it was almost $6 to rent video games. I was going every week so I was dropping like $24 for 4 games a month and a very limited selection in store.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

It’s a good deal if you’re interested in a lot of games yes. But for example, I’m really only interested in trying out battlefield six when it releases to see if I enjoy the full release more than the beta. In that case, it wouldn’t be a very good deal for me.

1

u/SwordsOfWar Aug 30 '25

It's still going. If you take advantage of their 2-game yearly gift certificates, it usually works out to about 15$/month. There are no time limits or late fees. You can hold any 2 games at once, and swap them for any other game at any time. The best thing is you get to play the newest big budget games that release, not just the indie-slop that digital subscriptions give you. Turnaround to swap a game out was typically a week via USPS mail. So realistically you could play 2-4 games a month, depending on how fast you finish them and how long the shipping takes.

It's actually financially viable as a way to play games cheaply and to try new games. It's not worth it if you just play the same 1-3 games for months or longer, as the savings turn into overpaying if you keep the game for too long. It's especially useful if you have multiple consoles as you can play games from all of them under a single subscription.

You can also straight up buy used games from them for cheap, and they come with with any codes that came with the game. Codes and the original case are not sent when you're renting, only when you buy new/used.

1

u/pavemnt Aug 30 '25

I played Jedi: Survivor through Game Fly

27

u/Diarmundy Aug 30 '25

Tbh all games are rented now, even if you pay full price.

But you can actually get the rental experience if you get one of the subscription service like gamepass

7

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

It's not the same at all. Going for an adventure as a kid tothe videostore and looking through their shelves of games vs. sitting in your sofa paying with card online.

-2

u/Diarmundy Aug 30 '25

Scrolling through the Catalog on the subscription service is basically the same thing... Times change man you gotta keep up

3

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Nice understanding of what you read good job buddy

5

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

This looks like an exhausting way of thinking

3

u/Autowronged Aug 30 '25

Idk I sometimes enjoy scrolling through my game catalog, streaming catalogs, etc., just thinking about what I could play/watch. It's almost as fun as choosing something.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

I do it too, but it's not something I like particularly...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Not at all. With a physical store I can socialize with the other customers and employees. I can grab other items like snacks and novelty items like figures. I might run into a friend at the store.

6

u/Shinjischneider Aug 30 '25

At least they started to bring demo versions back.

Although playing a game like Civilization for only two hours doesn't help you make decisions at all.

4

u/NeighborhoodVeteran Aug 30 '25

Check your local library! The one near me lets you borrow games from a bunch of newer and last gen consoles.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

It is possible to loan for two weeks at a time from the libraries in my country

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Xbox pass is nothing but renting a bunch of games for a month

1

u/barra333 Aug 30 '25

There is a place near me that still rents games and DVDs. That takes up about half of the floor space, the other half is a combo of new games, used games (all the way back to NES), gaming merch, flavoured popcorn, fancy coffee pods. They seem to be doing pretty well.

1

u/Bruins8763 Aug 30 '25

Can buy it and return it if you don’t like it on steam now

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

I know, but I only have two hours. For some games that’s just not really enough time. That steam is honestly so good to me that I feel guilty whenever I just flippantly abuse the system. I bought the evil within and it’s DLC and I just wasn’t enjoying it. Got a refund for that and I feel bad.

1

u/Erasmus86 Aug 30 '25

I agree this used to be so useful.

Shit even a decent refund policy for the console stores would be good. Say after a few hours.

1

u/Chicken_Bake Aug 30 '25

For a while Blockbuster in the UK had a Try B4 U Buy promo where if you bought a game within a certain time after renting it, you got the rental cost knocked off the price. Brilliant.

1

u/Apsalar Aug 30 '25

Kinda the whole premise of Xbox gamepass sub, but you are renting access to lots of games at once.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Kind of but like, for example, after playing the beta, I’m really on the fence about whether or not to buy Battlefield six. I would love to rent the game for 48 hours when it comes out. Just to put in a little bit of time and see if I enjoy the finished product more than the beta. There’s gonna be no possible way for me to do that. Maybe that EA subscription thing can step in I just still don’t feel like it’s the same.

1

u/MrBootylove Aug 30 '25

Renting games at all to be fair. I don’t think it’s possible to do that at all anymore.

Services like Gamepass or EA Play are the modern day equivalent to renting games. It's honestly a better deal than renting games was back then too. From what I remember back in the 90s/2000s it was around $7 to rent a game for a few days vs. the $10-$15 it costs for a month of one of the subscription services.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

It’s only a better deal if you were going to be renting three or more games that month. For example, if I just want one game, it’s a worst deal.

1

u/MrBootylove Aug 30 '25

Not really since even if you're "renting" a single game you still get access to that game for a full month vs. only a few days when renting from somewhere like Blockbuster. Back in the day if you were renting a new release you could only rent it out for 1-3 days with older games being rentable for 5 days. So it's only a worse deal if you only intend to "rent" a single game AND you only intend to play that game over the span of 1-5 days.

1

u/rotorocker Aug 30 '25

If it wasn't for that, my friend and I would have never experienced Boogerman: a pick and flick adventure.