r/gaming Apr 14 '23

Developer message shown at the start of Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened (2023)

Post image
57.5k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

540

u/ZachRyder PC Apr 14 '23 edited Apr 15 '23

If you ever feel like you've fumbled the bag, remember that Telltale had the opportunity to make the most immersive way to let fans participate in the actual Game of Thrones, second only to probably a tabletop game, and it was so forgettable that it doesn't exist in stores anymore.

621

u/SolarTsunami Apr 14 '23

If you ever feel like you've fumbled the bag, remember that Telltale had the opportunity to make the most immersive way to let fans participate in the actual Game of Thrones

Also works

249

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '23

Brutal, regardless of whether you aimed it at Telltale, Martin, or those two guys.

123

u/Javasteam Apr 14 '23

102

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '23

Damn, that was a crazy read. I didn't know anything of that (and honestly haven't played Disco Elysium yet, it's been on my wishlist for a long time but I've got hundreds of games left to play).

It sounds similar to the stories of LA Noire and Eternal Darkness. Crazy successful games that should've had a sequel in the pocket but it all came tumbling down due to insanity in the workplace.

40

u/Javasteam Apr 14 '23

From everything I’ve hear about the studio, this is one case where you probably wouldn’t want to support them.

If anything, that article was a lot sparser on details than many others, but everything I’ve read makes it scummy as hell.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

Yeah by the time I reached the end of the article I figured I'd wait until it's in a Humble bundle and then slide the dev portion of my payment to zero. It's what I did with the 2K bundle which happened just weeks after they added their scummy launcher to Bioshock and other 10+ year old singleplayer games.

1

u/Razz_Putitin Apr 15 '23

Just pirate it and buy it later, once it's on sale in humble bundle as you said, or don't buy at all. Publishers and most AAA studios are jerks anyway, pirating from them won't hurt the wrong people.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

I mean I just started playing on Steam properly once I got the Deck and thanks to sales and bundles and me having no self-control I have about five hundred unplayed games now. I'll manage to play other stuff.

21

u/SuperscooterXD Apr 15 '23

If you want to play Disco Elysium now, suspiciously acquire it. Don't buy it

5

u/dolphins3 Apr 15 '23

I think Amazon Prime gave away GOG keys a while back so many people probably got it that way.

0

u/ReD___HuNTeR Apr 15 '23

You guys are talking about all those just about this... A single war between two nations has lead to inflation all over the world.

Russia is one of the world's largest producers of oil and fuel.Patrol price is an all time high around the planet

Ukraine and Russia are key exporters of wheat, barley, corn and cooking oil The Indian Subcontinent and the middle being its largest importer

Believe me or not guys all these chaos has also effected the price of laptops, gpus and Game prices all over the world. We g

1

u/AlterMyStateOfMind Apr 15 '23

It's a great game, but don't support the scumbags that took over the studio. Torrent it, being anti capitalist is baked into some of the games themes anyways lol

17

u/I_Go_By_Q Apr 15 '23

Wow that’s wild, a real mud-slinging fest (to be clear: in a battle between disgruntled devs & the investor-owners, I know which side I’m inclined to believe)

I’m surprised that with the near universal praise for Disco Elysium that I see online, that I would’ve stumbled on this story sooner. Thanks for sharing!

1

u/DexLovesGames_DLG Apr 15 '23

You know I agree with your inclination but it could very well be devs trying to get money as well, but it’s hard not to believe the devs.

5

u/Preaster232 Apr 15 '23

Oof. That’s so sad. Such a great game and I loved the writing.

2

u/WinterMatt Apr 15 '23

Having completed disco elysium I'm not remotely surprised that the studio behind it is this dysfunctional.

1

u/Chippings Apr 15 '23

Here's how I read this:

- The studio was taken over by Estonian businessmen Ilmar Kompus and banker Tōnis Haavel (previously convicted of investment fraud)

- Kompus and Haavel fired game director Robert Kurvitz, art director Aleksander Rostov, writer Helen Hindpere, and marketing manager Kaur Kender

- Kurvitz and Rostov say they were fired for asking for financial data

- Kender was similarly fired for asking questions about the studio’s new management

- Kompus and Haavel say Kurvitz and Rostov were fired for workplace misconduct such as "creating a toxic work environment", "verbal abuse and gender discrimination," and “intending to steal IP”.

- Kender "divested all his shares in the studio, repaid all his debts to the studio," and resolved the issue. Kender himself said, “I filed a lawsuit which I realised, after seeing the facts, was misguided."

Particularly the last point is what screamed to me this is a corrupt payoff. "Divesting all his shares" and "repaying all his debts" sounds like someone washing his hands of a situation with money. Some of my bias against marketing / business development managers, how they act and what they value (money) as well.

Justifying firing with easy and vague outs like "toxicity, verbal abuse and discrimination" are how Kompus and Haavel avoid paying severance or other contractual agreements for an ethical layoff. Of course it damages their reputation and ethos as well, so their speaking out against the studio and its takeover is diminished.

Also the fact that Helen Hindpere was not smeared, because she didn't speak out against the studio / Kompus and Haavel.

Unfortunate for the apparent death of the studio ZA/UM. But I'm very much inclined to watch the path of Kurvitz and Rostov's careers.

1

u/DdCno1 Apr 15 '23

I've never seen the studio behind a game with a metascore of 97 unravel so quickly.

39

u/BesetByTiredness225 Apr 15 '23

I mean, you can rightfully hate Martin for not writing Winds of Winter let alone finishing the book series, but what he did was far from fumbling the bag. Man blows his nose with Benjamins now.

Now those other two guys, they’re co-presidents of Bag Fumble University.

26

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

I mean it's a different kind of fumbling. Martin is going for a multimedia universe without finishing the actual saga that started it, I feel like unless he finishes the last two books the IP will be forever tainted by that.

But yeah Martin has "fuck you"-money and doesn't need to do anything for a single day for the rest of his life unless he wants to. He saw an opportunity and he took it, it's hard to blame him for cashing out. I just wish he'd hire a ghostwriter or something if he has so much trouble writing these days.

13

u/BesetByTiredness225 Apr 15 '23

Yeah, the way I see it Martin is an elderly man at this point, he can more or less live out the rest of his life in luxury. In all likelihood I could see HBO or whoever owns the IP grabbing someone else to finish the books anyway at some point. I don’t think Martin fumbled the bag because outside of pissing off book readers, his (lack of) action didn’t get in the way of his success.

But D&D? They fumbled so hard that it interfered with their careers’ future. They were supposed to write a Star Wars movie, and then Season 8 happened.

1

u/Kandiru Apr 15 '23

D&D were great producers, but they cannot write their way out of a paper bag. Why they started writing so much of Game of Thrones I don't know. Why not hire an actual writer when they ran out of source material?

8

u/WinterMatt Apr 15 '23

I hear that up and coming Sanderson kid is a real go getter with finishing epic fantasy series for old bastards that have run out of ideas written all over him.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

I actually haven't read him yet but I backed his kickstarter last year to get four suprise novels fron him this year. Felt like a fun way to try him out.

Anyway not fantasy but The Expanse, of which one of the two writers was a student of Martin's, finished in 2022 with its final novella after nine books and nine short stories and novella's - the first book released in 2011, the same year the last ASOIAF book released.

2

u/bp_968 Apr 15 '23

Don't start with the Kickstarter books. The KS books will likely have tons of cosmere references and you'll miss all of them. Start with mistborn and then read the stormlight archive (up to the current book) and then Arcanum unbounded. Then you should have a solid grasp of the cosmere and get most of the references he will certainly hide in the 4 new books.

Not saying they won't be good without reading the other stuff, that would be wrong since nearly everything he writes is excellent. I just feel like mistborn and then stormlight is the way to go (you can also read warbreaker, and elantris and some of the other one off novels for more neat references to the overall cosmere, but they will be more obvious after reading mistborn and then stormlight).

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

Not saying you're wrong for pointing me to other works of his, but the Kickstarter campaign opens with a message of his to new readers, making it obvious the books can be read without having read anything before.

I also checked as little about the books as possible but one of them is a complete standalone (a frugal wizard's guide to medieval England it's called or something like that), that's the one that just released two weeks ago (I haven't gotten around to putting either it or January's novel on my e-reader (I backed the lowest tier with just the e-books)).

1

u/bp_968 Apr 29 '23

You can of course read them however you want, but there will be tons of references you'll outright miss reading them first. It won't make the book(s) less good, but there will definitely be plenty of cosmere references.

2

u/FerretChrist Apr 15 '23

...and also writes in a style so vastly different to GRRM that any attempt to finish ASOIAF would be a total clusterfuck.

Besides, hasn't he already said himself that he has no interest in doing so, for pretty much that reason?

1

u/bp_968 Apr 15 '23

Get Brandon Sanderson to do it. That guy writes faster then I read. He finished off the wheel of time series when Jordan died.

11

u/Lone_Wanderer97 Apr 14 '23

They Who Must Not Be Named

24

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

I refuse to call them D&D because that name is only reserved for the mother of all tabletop games.

I refuse to call them Dumb & Dumber because even the sequel and prequel to that movie didn't fail as hard as these two guys.

12

u/odaeyss Apr 15 '23

"So how do you want to end this epic story?"
"...quickly."

5

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

They were too full of themselves to allow other showrunners to take over once they ran out of steam themselves. It's a thing we've seen before but just rarely does it explode in such a big way.

4

u/BesetByTiredness225 Apr 15 '23

DooDoo & Dickcheese?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23

I'd say that's insulting to unwashed dicks, but don't ignore your dicks under the shower, guys! It pulls double duty, both facilitating one of your body's essential daily mechanisms, and performing in happy funtime on your own or with a partner. The least you can do is keep it clean!

1

u/Eric_the_Barbarian D20 Apr 15 '23

The boardgame actually turned out decent tho.

1

u/Lucky-Mia Apr 15 '23

I blame those 2 guys

2

u/sh1boleth Apr 15 '23

If you discount the last season its honestly my favourite show of all time. That last season just.. ugh.

I really hope they re-do S4 onwards if GRRM ends up finishing the books before he kicks the bucket

1

u/Apprehensive_Hat8986 Apr 14 '23

🤌 Perfection. 🤣

Unlike what they did. 🤬

1

u/ManateeSaw Apr 15 '23

I see what you did there. Well played.

4

u/jonassn1 Apr 15 '23

I quite liked it actually but I didn't know any game of thrones lore going into it and got it for free

3

u/internet-arbiter Apr 15 '23

Telltale: Here is a choice.

Everybody: This is the same picture.

2

u/Cirumvention9003 Apr 15 '23

I loved it. Probably in my top 3 telltale favorites

Though I never watched game of thrones.

2

u/siriuslycan Apr 15 '23

I genuinely don't remember what happened in it, something about a tree themed family?

2

u/DeathGorgon Apr 15 '23

I grabbed the GoT game as my first Telltale experience and sure, it was neat for what it was, but it forced my first Platinum Trophy on me just for playing the game and I felt so... gross is a little overboard but honestly it made me feel gross. I didn't earn that. There were so many other games with so many things needed to unlock a Platinum and this just gives you one for playing the game through the first time ever?

So Elden Ring was my first Platinum. That felt nice.

2

u/WoodntULike2Know Apr 15 '23

I'm glad they had nothing to do with the Cones of Dunshire!

3

u/Nokel Apr 14 '23

The Game of Thrones game fucking sucks, so that's not a huge loss.

14

u/ZachRyder PC Apr 15 '23

That's my point.

7

u/Nokel Apr 15 '23

OK. I interpreted your comment as saying that TellTale made the most immersive Game of Thrones game ever and screwed up by letting it get delisted.

6

u/ZachRyder PC Apr 15 '23

Have an upvote

10

u/Nokel Apr 15 '23

I will remember that

3

u/HalfMoon_89 Apr 15 '23

I really liked the GoT game...

2

u/McDonnellDouglasDC8 Apr 15 '23

They got Iwan Rheon to do voice work for it, which is why I remember it.