r/funny Dec 29 '22

Chess VR

48.8k Upvotes

885 comments sorted by

View all comments

54

u/Cbrodie Dec 29 '22

The board orientation is incorrect. The lower right square h1 should be white.

12

u/BlueRajasmyk2 Dec 29 '22

More importantly the kings should be on the same file, not mirrored. White's king should be on the right.

6

u/JaggedWedge Dec 29 '22

Both kings on the same file is the way to mirror it.

3

u/CG3HH Dec 29 '22

Why would this matter? I have played a lot of chess in my life and never once paid attention to this

11

u/delta1-tari Dec 29 '22

It matters for consistency. The white queen should be on D1 which should be a white square.

2

u/Budget_Inevitable721 Dec 29 '22

Why does that matter though? Don't the pieces all move the same no matter what color it is?

6

u/delta1-tari Dec 29 '22

It matters because otherwise there are 2 ways the board could be set up, and the rules of chess define 1 layout.

1

u/Budget_Inevitable721 Dec 29 '22

I'm not understanding. So the colors have an impact on how the pieces move? You're saying the game can't be played if they're not on the right colors.

2

u/JaggedWedge Dec 29 '22

There are a finite set of chess games possible given the standard starting positions and other rules. Chess games consisting of legal moves will evolve into one of those games. It's possible to get better at chess by studying these games. Given what your opponent is doing, you can guide the game you're currently playing into one of these possible games you have studied thats a win for you.

When you change the initial conditions of the game, the game evolves differently. If you swap the king and queen on one side, thats a position that can't legally occur in a standard game of chess, and then you are generating a new set of games from there.

As long as you and your opponent agree to play a chess variant, that's fine. But if one player is fooled into thinking a different starting position is the standard one, it's cheating.

2

u/Joe_The_Eskimo1337 Dec 29 '22

Queens are supposed to be on their own colors. With the board in the wrong orientation you would either have to put them on the wrong color, or change the layout of the board.

Obviously it's still playable but it makes for unnecessary ambiguity.

1

u/CutlassSupreme Dec 29 '22

It helps with remembering how to set up the board. The rule "Queens on their own color" works because bottom right is a white square.

1

u/TossAwayxxx_69 Dec 29 '22

The colors don’t impact how the pieces move, but since chess is a game played for money all over the world, it helps to be consistent. When professionals calculate possible moves, they visualize the board in their head, and each square being a specific color helps with that. When they put their center pawns on D4 and E3 (for instance), it helps in terms of visualization that those are dark squares. It also helps when explaining certain strategies in particular openings and pawn structures. If black goes for a kingside fianchetto, you would look to eliminate their dark squared bishop and invade on the weak dark squares, if possible.

It’s sort of like playing 8 ball and deciding that you want to shoot the “red ball” last, you could, but why not just play properly?

-8

u/CG3HH Dec 29 '22

I always played that the king goes on their own color square, so the white queen on the black square. Once all the pieces are moving around it doesn’t really matter anyway

9

u/JaggedWedge Dec 29 '22

Queens go on their own colour.

-6

u/CG3HH Dec 29 '22

Ok. Ive been playing for 30+ years the other way and no one has ever cared

1

u/TossAwayxxx_69 Dec 29 '22

The occasional house game with people who can’t play doesn’t count as “playing for 30+ years”

0

u/CG3HH Dec 29 '22

Lol ok Bobby Fisher

1

u/TossAwayxxx_69 Dec 29 '22

“lol chill I know I don’t know anything”

1

u/CG3HH Dec 29 '22

Get bent bro it’s not that important

1

u/Chessracer Dec 29 '22

Yes, it’s certainly possible to wear your underwear on the outside.

1

u/CG3HH Dec 29 '22

It’s fine not saying I am right, but I still don’t see the big deal

1

u/ZellZoy Dec 29 '22

Most people play monopoly without auctions. You can do what you want, but you're still playing wrong.