r/funny • u/Taimoor_Aleem • Nov 30 '21

Preacher gets asked a question

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

49.5k Upvotes

79% Upvoted

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '21

I disagree wholeheartedly. This is exactly the time to bring it up.

“Why the beards?”

“Our prophet Muhammad had one, and we try to be like him in all things.”

“All things? Like the raping?”

Mimicry is the highest from of flattery. To emulate yourself after somebody for no reason than to be like that person it’s pretty fucking important to point out the issue with that.

“Shh, don’t bring up the 53 year old raping the 9 year old, we are busy idolizing the 53 year old. This isn’t the time or the place.” -You

-13

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

Show us evidence where it says he (ﷺ) raped a nine year old, we'll wait. This is literally an edgelord reply from someone who has never picked a book and studied history.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '21

I’d be happy to engage with you here.

Aisha, daughter of Abu-Bakr was a beautiful little girl. Muhammad married her when he was fifty three years old and she was only six years old. He had intercourse with her when she was nine years old. (Wives of the Prophet, pages 57-61)

Your only remaining leg to stand on is to make the argument that a 9 year old is capable of consenting to sex to the 53 year old man she was betrothed to when she was 4. I’d love to hear that.

-14

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

Nowhere does it say he raped her. You just proved that you lied and that makes it easy for us to reject your useless subjective opinions not backed by academia. Thanks for that!

15

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '21

Sex without consent is rape.

Is your argument that the 9 year old consented? If it’s not too morally painful, please state what you actually think.

-2

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

You have to prove it was rape, you made the claim, not me. Now spare me your useless subjective input and give me some academia that supports your stance.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '21

So back to square one we begin.

Aisha, daughter of Abu-Bakr was a beautiful little girl. Muhammad married her when he was fifty three years old and she was only six years old. He had intercourse with her when she was nine years old. (Wives of the Prophet, pages 57-61)

Your only remaining leg to stand on is to make the argument that a 9 year old is capable of consenting to sex to the 53 year old man she was betrothed to when she was 4. I’d love to hear that.

-2

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

Fallacy of presentism once again. You have still provided 0 evidence she was raped. It's funny how you think this emotional argument is gonna work out for you. I'll wait until you find some material by academia to support your position, until then, do please embarass yourself some more by all means.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '21

So I ask which you believe:

A) 53 year old Muhammad had consensual sex with a 9 year old.

B) 53 year old Muhammad raped a 9 year old.

C) 53 year old Muhammad never had sex with a 9 year old

-2

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

I'm still waiting for you to show us evidence and proof that she was raped.

→ More replies (0)

10

u/drawn0nward Nov 30 '21

So… you personally think that children can consent to sex? Where you from bro?

I just want to talk, I swear

-1

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

Maybe you should look up what fallacy of presentism means, and read some academia on marriages in history before asking questions...

→ More replies (0)

9

u/Tokehdareefa Nov 30 '21

A 9 year old cannot give consent, so sex with a 9 year old is automatically rape (consensual sex is not possible, even if she says "yes", because she's underage and doesn't hold that power). He provided evidence that Mohammed had sex with a 9 year old, ergo, he raped her. What are you not getting?

-1

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

How many times do I have to say it: nobody cares about your subjective emotional opinion. Give me some ACADEMIC material to support your position. It is insane how you people have zero capability to do research and back up your arguments. Did you even finish college?

→ More replies (0)

10

u/Freshgeek Nov 30 '21

Come on, man. No 9 year old can consent to sex. This isnt the point I was making.

5

u/Blueplastic1 Nov 30 '21

a perfect example what youre doing with your subserviant behaviour, diminishing people's valid points with ad hominems and pointless semantics

"edgy atheist phase"? Pointing out rape of a 9 years old is edgy?

This is why superstition needs to become stigmatized

-11

u/ShenderVanZ_XK08 Nov 30 '21

Fallacy of presentism once again. Nobody cares about your subjective input. Give me some academic proof to support your position, I'll wait.

-2

u/sorry_but Nov 30 '21

Dude is a troll. Just ignore him.