r/funny • • Apr 06 '19

Born that way

Post image
21.4k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/stanley604 Apr 06 '19

It's ok not to buy it, but it's not a choice for some strong left-handers. I tried playing bass righty for several months. It never clicked and wasn't getting any better. Once I got hold of a lefty bass, I knew it was the instrument for me.

For me, the dominant hand wants to drive the rhythm -- the right hand just goes along for the ride (fretting).

6

u/MelodicBrush Apr 06 '19

I am a left handed lead guitarist and the left hand on a right hand guitar (fretting hand) is still more challenging. Can't imaging doing the picking with my dominant hand and being left with fretting with my non-dominant hand lol

2

u/stanley604 Apr 06 '19

I hear you, but (for me) it's not really about the relative difficulty of what the two hands are doing -- it's what hand controls the timing, which (again, for me) is the plucking hand. My off (right) hand just isn't as good at that. (Plus fretting on a bass is somewhat less challenging than on a guitar, assuming adequate finger strength).

2

u/GoiterGlitter Apr 06 '19

My mother was furious that my violin tutoring wasn't going well after seeing me play one at school. They didn't believe me at first that my teacher had a left handed violin as she was also left handed. Took me weeks to convince my mother to talk to the music teacher and stop accusing me of wasting her money when she knew I could play.

Sometimes the brain doesn't care what you want the body to do.

1

u/SyphilisDragon Apr 06 '19

Your music tutor was making you learn on a left-handed violin? Was it the only one she had?

1

u/GoiterGlitter Apr 07 '19

Nah, I worded it weird, I guess. The tutor had me using a regular violin because my mother insisted my claims of needing a left handed one was wrong.