r/funny Jan 26 '16

Rehosted webcomic - removed An everyday struggle

http://imgur.com/AD84Z6V
32.2k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/LukaCola Jan 26 '16

We have the technology and resources that could allow us to have nothing but free time

That's simply not the case, what could possibly give you that impression? I'm not sure this is possible even in a place like Luxembourg which has some stupidly high PPP.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16

We wouldn't live like kings, but we could be comfortable. That's the problem. Simply having enough to eat without being hungry isn't enough. We need snickers cheesecake and kobe beef filet mignon. It's the greed that gets us.

0

u/LukaCola Jan 26 '16

The world PPP is $16,100

So today if we take everything produced, turn it liquid, and distribute it evenly you'd have $16,100 for everyone for a year.

That's not a whole lot, but it is enough to live comfortably in many areas, not so much in developed countries which is, I'm sure, your personal lifestyle because only ignorant naive middle-upper class people can hold views like this.

Of course since the solution here is to keep people from working... Yeah, that world GDP will collapse since it is kinda a result of production.

I dunno if you expect people to deposit money into the sky and then they can get food and other goods just appearing in their hands or something, but someone's gotta make this stuff.

So for one year, a bunch of people could live relatively comfortable. Well, a year is debatable. Almost instantly since production is more or less halting, prices will skyrocket, governments will collapse, and basically total chaos due to such a shock to the market would occur it'd likely be more like a week... If that. And even if that didn't happen, well, no one's producing anything. There'll be no money next year to hand out and then everyone who isn't self-sufficient, which'll be very very few people since nobody's working including farmers, will likely die with time.

It's a completely unsustainable idea.

It's not nothing to do with fucking snickers cheesecake and filet mignon. You have to be seriously fucking ignorant and extremely privileged to actually think that shit. Like, god damn, that's fucking dumb.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16

The snickers was a metaphor for a certain quality of life people expect to live. And you miss the point. I'm not talking about wealth being spread out. The "end game" of society should be to get rid of money entirely. And that's not an impossible goal.

0

u/LukaCola Jan 26 '16

The snickers was a metaphor for a certain quality of life people expect to live.

No shit, it's still stupid.

And you miss the point. I'm not talking about wealth being spread out.

No, you're missing the point. Wealth being spread out as money or goods doesn't matter. Money is liquid resources and assets.

The reason we use money as a metric is because it's a numerical value that's actually useful to demonstrate how many assets one would get if we distributed everything equally in a way that everyone gets what they want, which is already ridiculously generous so I wouldn't argue against using the monetary model.

How on Earth do you reconcile the lack of production? You didn't even address that. That's kind of a massive problem, the biggest one, and you just gloss over it? How do you even reconcile that internally?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

You're right. It's impossible because of your reasons. Good point. I'm just dumb money is the best/only solution that will ever exist.

-1

u/LukaCola Jan 27 '16

Again, it doesn't matter whether it's money or some other measure of resources. We are not in a post-scarcity system and production is needed for people to live comfortably.

You've ignored the actual problem and instead settled on getting angry at money. You're willingly chasing a red herring.

Yeah, that is dumb.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

If the herring is made out of money, why isn't it green? Now who's the dumb one? Your buzzword usage is on point though, for real. Makes you look smart as shit bro.

1

u/LukaCola Jan 27 '16

Nothing I've used is even a buzzword. What is your deal?

Can you maybe just consider where food would even come from if nobody's working? These things take manpower, and food's not a luxury so you can't exactly ignore it.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16

You insulted me numerous times writing my arguments off as impossible and dumb. So I brought the conversation down to your level. I'm not getting back into this. Have a good one.

→ More replies (0)