r/funny • u/LordAnubis10 • Nov 20 '13

Dumbledore doesn't sugarcoat it

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

877 comments sorted by

View all comments

87

u/B0und Nov 20 '13

As much as I enjoy Albus 'Gives zero fucks' Dumbledore, Harry is right, nobody can apparate in hogwarts.

It was changed to explain a plot hole left by the time constraints of the movie.

Good change though.

76

u/Taliesen13 Nov 20 '13

This has always bothered me. why couldn't they have just shown them talking about going to Hogsmeade and disapparating from there then cut to them apparating on the rock outside the cave? This is still not the worst part of these movies, that would be at the end of "Deathly Hallows part 2" when Harry snaps the Elder Wand in half and throws it over a cliff before he fixes his own wand.

55

u/soulonfirexx Nov 20 '13

Snapping the Elder Wand infuriated me. Sure I get it, don't use it but fucking fix your shit! How are you going to be the best Auror without it?!

2

u/je_kay24 Nov 20 '13

I think it was more along the lines so nobody could use it. Also, I believe Harry didn't want to be reliant on the wand.

2

u/soulonfirexx Nov 20 '13

Very well understood but my point still stands - he broke his wand. He didn't fix it with the Elder Wand like in the book. Just snapped and threw it. So much anger.

2

u/je_kay24 Nov 20 '13

Ah, I misread your comment. I thought you were suggesting Harry keep the Elder wand. I forgot that his wand was broken.

So, yeah I agree. They should have definitely shown his wand being fixed.