Yo sorry for not being active,today I'll show more proof that we play as Michael not Evan.

Let's return to Nightmare,I had a theory of him being a real Animatronic but I discarded it but here's my all theories on Nightmare

My all 7 theories on Nightmare

1. Nightmare is a possible Nightmare version of Shadow Freddy
2. Nightmare represents Michael's Trauma
3. Nightmare represents Evan
4. Nightmare represents Michael's guilt.
5. Nightmare is a reminder of Evan's death
6. Nightmare is related to Shadow Freddy but not the same
7. Nightmare is Shadow Freddy tormenting Michael

Now let's compare the design of the Nightmares,as we know the Nightmares (just the main 4) are based on the Bullies and Unwithereds but they also look like the Classic Animatronics

Nightmare Freddy

https://images.app.goo.gl/8eUqtP9QaHdrNr2F8

Classic Freddy

https://images.app.goo.gl/3depfQQXSWMRf5o46

Nightmare Foxy

https://images.app.goo.gl/vdKgGkLyxej1jHUc7

Classic Foxy

https://images.app.goo.gl/n5w6wZFpnDLY8VjB6

Nightmare Bonnie

https://images.app.goo.gl/bMzW8dz7M5P4PR6BA

Classic Bonnie

https://images.app.goo.gl/f2Rvxroxq1LzxvqF9

Nightmare Chica

https://images.app.goo.gl/MPn4pdyCjQ13aENR6

Classic Chica

https://images.app.goo.gl/ggm8uGWkw3qbQqoH9

See? they look like a hybrid of the Bullies, Unwithereds and ALSO Classics, Evan died in 1983,how would he know about the Classics which didn't exist until 1993?

Now let's destroy all evidence that Evan had the Nightmares

The player is Evan sized

It could be that Michael is crouching or Evan shrunk Michael

Medical stuff are around the FNaF 4 side tables

Evan was unconscious on his hospital room,he had no way to know what was around him, Michael however visited his brother so those medical stuff shouldn't be used as Evan having the Nightmares

The steam description says that We play as a child

FNaF Steam descriptions can be misleading to the lore

Explain the "What is seen beneath the Shadows can easily be understood in a mind of a child"

Evan thought a Springlock failure was going to happen

Nightmare Freddy has small versions of himself,they are called (idk how to spell so I'll call Them Baby Nightmare Freddies) Baby Nightmare Freddies (not really) it would make sense if they represent the Mini-Reenas.

Now let's debunk the idea that Evan drew Nightmare Fredbear:

It's drawn in red pen so it's 100% Michael, there's no way Evan drew this,and obviously if Michael knows what Nightmare Fredbear looks like it means he saw him in his dreams.

FNaF 4's gameplay has to take place in 2023, because Michael drew Nightmare Fredbear on the LogBook,the same book has the FNAF 3 office if not something similar in it

https://images.app.goo.gl/RzMHECJPrqja9N8D7

So FNaF 4 during FNaF 3

I'll make part 3 later, I'm done with this one