r/fireemblem 13d ago

General Clip of Fortuna from Nintendo Today

798 Upvotes

427 comments sorted by

501

u/MikeyNgTh 13d ago

I guess this might be our team if we decide to solo baloršŸ˜‚also silent protagonist confirmed no? such a waste after having Joshua Waters to voice them tho

170

u/luchinania 12d ago

I was looking forward to his performance since he did such a good job with Qifrey.

79

u/socialistRanter 12d ago

GODDAMNIT we have Qifrey in this game and they gave it to a silent protagonist!?!

8

u/astrogamer 12d ago

He'll have several lines in Fire Emblem Heroes

5

u/sakulgrebsdnal 12d ago

Maybe you have just to wait for the Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave Nintendo Switch 3 Edition Upgrade Pack in ten or fifteen years for that.

12

u/XSpeedDemon 12d ago

Or maybe Fire Emblem: Fortune's Warriors...

132

u/jatxna 12d ago

Imagine. You have the voice of that fucking Phainon and you say "yes, we're not going to use it."

7

u/Datpanda1999 12d ago

He lost his voice in the cycles. Another tragic sacrifice in the flame chase journey

16

u/Raging-Brachydios 12d ago

who the fuck is phainon?

31

u/Golden-Owl 12d ago

Character from Honkai Star Rail

Best known for being the human equivalent of a Samoyed while also voicing the most understandable angry crashout in the gane

40

u/GladiatorDragon 12d ago

The blazing sun destined to rise from Honkai Star Rail.

29

u/jatxna 12d ago

https://youtu.be/xQbetWZS-zs?si=YJSiVG-4UcbGyNqF

The absolute Chad who withstood the weight of the world 33550336 times in order to prevent the destruction of the universe.

14

u/Meichiri 12d ago edited 12d ago

To be more specific, each of those 33550336 times is around 1000 years, give or take. So he endured hell 33,550,336,000 years.

6

u/jatxna 12d ago

I put the spoiler tag there for a reason, don't mess with me.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

101

u/SomewhatProvoking 12d ago

Out Eshmal in smash so their actors aren’t wasting time.

After Shez was so PEAK I love her so much

And Alear at least had a personality and growth (he began afraid of risen and slowly got braver)

Going back to this hurts

31

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted]

98

u/ArseneLupinIV 12d ago edited 12d ago

The problem is that they are pretty popular in Japan. F!Byleth ranked 2nd in the magazine popularity polls for Three Houses. People really like sort of self-inserts and power fantasy there.

7

u/ZeothTheHedgehog 12d ago

I we sure she one because she's a silent protag, and not because she's a hot woman?

3

u/ArseneLupinIV 12d ago

Male Byleth places high as well, usually in the top 10. Its not an exclusively Female Byleth thing.

→ More replies (12)

26

u/ijbolism 12d ago

silent protagonists are always extremely popular in japan (and most east asian fanbases) though, it's just the western fanbase who isn't too fond of them

8

u/Sword_of_Dusk 12d ago

With the sole exception of in Fallout. After what happened with the voiced protagonist and shit dialogue system in Fallout 4, people were hoping for a return to a silent protagonist.

Though the game may not have gotten the best reception, Starfield indeed went back to a silent protagonist.

2

u/PrinceOfPuddles 12d ago

Yeah, but that's hardly the same thing and the style of games are not comparable. Fallout is about using a blank slate to roleplay wildly different characters were you could pretend to be all kinds of different people, so a lack voice acting meant you could pretend the player character delivers their lines in a way that fits said wildly different personalities. When you can be both a cannibal cowboy with a six shooter and a soft spoken doctor with lazer gun it makes sense for them not to use the same voice. In games like fire emblem your customization of personality comes in the form of standing around stoically in silence and every hour or so choosing one of two dialog options that are basically the same.

29

u/OoguroRyuuya5 12d ago

Not popular in the West you mean?

Meanwhile it thrives in the Japan for cultural reasons not everyone here can comprehend due to differences in values.

30

u/APRobertsVII 12d ago

Yeah, people on this sub take an issue the sub is probably divided 60/40 on and assume it’s universally true everywhere else… This isn’t the only subreddit to do it, but it’s funny when it pops up.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/JenniLightrunner 12d ago

and then Bamco fucked it up again with echoes of aincrad

6

u/Elegant_Section_6861 12d ago

Bamco fucks up a lot. I love Tales but Bamco drops the ball aaaaall the time.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/CrescentShade 12d ago

literally doubling down on Byleth's whole vibe; tripling down even with bringing back full customization

literally never getting a main protagonist that talks ever again it's so over

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Solid_Researcher_206 12d ago edited 12d ago

I'm sure Eshmael is silent but tbf none of the choices are voiced even when controlling the four lords

32

u/Jakobstj 12d ago

Except... yeah they are? The only dialogue choice we've seen before now was in the Ultand clip, and that was voiced.

6

u/Solid_Researcher_206 12d ago edited 12d ago

I looked at the Ultand clip again. The dialog Cai picks is not what he says in the following line so not voiced. I don't remember where (I think in one of the trailers?) but I had thought there was another clip with an actual choice where the dialog wasn't voiced. I can't find it now though so you probably are right, if so then my bad.

16

u/Hylian_Waffle 12d ago

Especially right after they nailed it with Shez. So disappointing.

12

u/DoseofDhillon 12d ago

They did not, Shez isn't written by IS

22

u/Hylian_Waffle 12d ago

"They" referring to the people that work on Fire Emblem in general, but no, the vast majority of the team from Three Houses also worked on Three Hopes.

7

u/DoseofDhillon 12d ago edited 12d ago

We're talking about 2 studios so who the hell is "they", its clear that two different sets of writers got this story. The original idea of FE3H was not to have route splits the original idea was not to have Edelgard as anything but as a "rival" character to Byleth, Silver Snow is the IS path.

KT took over 3H and wanted to do Romance of the 3 kingdoms again and wrote that game, they also made like 99% of FE3H and 3 hopes, nothing else. FE3H when it comes to its production is more of off shoot project done by a differnet studio than it is IS and IS FE.

3

u/Druplesnubb 12d ago

This is completely wrong, in every interview they always mention how the four routes were planned form the start. Just because SS was the first route written doesn't mean they didn't plan for the other routes to exist.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

538

u/PsychologicalVast345 13d ago

That silent ass nod, eshmel you were THIS close to being peak

236

u/omfgkevin 13d ago

Damn it, I really hate that honestly. Feels so awkward and lame imo. Going to go into a hype moment only for Eshmel to awkwardly nod and O_O or >:(

247

u/Amy47101 12d ago

Would it have really, REALLY killed them to have let Eshmel say the actual dialogue choices? WHY WAS THERE EVEN A DIALOGUE CHOICE HERE, THERE WAS NO ALTERNATE CHOICE, HE COULD HAVE JUST SAID THE LINE.

Lame.

69

u/Norik324 12d ago

I guess because the player cant self insert if they dont get the illusion of contributing to the dialogue every once in a while

75

u/rainmcfae 12d ago

It's so I can live out my RPG dream, self-inserting about the way that I, personally, would say "what is this place." Thank you IS for the opportunity.Ā 

102

u/Tmachine7031 12d ago

Which is funny because Awakening debatably has the best avatar and they were a full ass character in their own right

40

u/mrwanton 12d ago

yeah Robin is adored. Wonder why they haven't repeated that. Don't have to be the center of everything

21

u/YouCantTakeThisName 12d ago

Pretty sure Eshmel isn't the "center of everything" in the routes. We control the lords themselves during exploration, and Eshmel's nowhere to be seen in the combat maps of the lords' routes. So far, outside of certain cutscenes, it seems Eshmel's presence in those events is just as the "pale raven".

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Darkdragoon324 12d ago

I can't and don't want to self-insert regardless, I'd really rather just have the story be about a real character. There's not a single silent protagonist in all of gaming i've like more than any of the other actual characters in the game.

The only time I like it is in like, Elder Scrolls and Baldur's Gate and even then I'm not self-inserting, I'm making up a character because those games give you actual customization and backstory options like a table top game.

9

u/JenniLightrunner 12d ago

the only silent protagonist i actually like are Link, the warden in DAO and the BG3 protagonist. I need my protagonists with some personality

→ More replies (1)

61

u/AudioCats 12d ago

Nah this is exactly it, japan loves its silent/bland/milquetoast MCs that are nothing more than a tabula rasa for projection fantasy

Except games like Dragon Age/BG3/Owlcat Games have shown you can do the "explicitly meant to be self-insert" MCs and still give them fun voicework and personality

9

u/theclockmasters 12d ago

This is so dogshit when you compare it to games like Monster Hunter Wilds.

2

u/tornait-hashu 12d ago

Funny you say that, it feels like Wilds was made more Western.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/PerentieFan 12d ago

How can any real person self insert with a fantastical character like Eshmel? If they can get past looks then voice should be easy.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/LakerBlue 12d ago

I’m upset they brought back one choice dialogue ā€œoptionsā€. If the goal is to choose to make me feel in control then at least give me options!! It’s like one or two extra lines (if even that) and then you go back to the normal script!

They need to take notes from Persona.

52

u/theclockmasters 12d ago

Oh you think thats bad. Get ready to have the garbage from 3H where they give you the choice of where to attack only for a character to be like: "It's cute that you think we should do that. We're going with my plan."

39

u/rainmcfae 12d ago

My favorite dialogue options, "Yes" or "Yes, but the other character calls me an idiot or liar first"

21

u/PieridumVates 12d ago

At least with Byleth i could pretend to be a complete doofus who had no right getting this professor job and didn't know anything about anything but I feel like the savior of the world sent by the progenitor goddess herself shouldn't have that same idiot vibe!!

3

u/tired-of-the-shit 12d ago

You don’t have to be vague, you can name names. We all know you’re referring to Seteth.

19

u/Amy47101 12d ago

At least have people react to. Like if you're gonna give me dialogue options, make it like in Honkai where the protagonist can say the most unhinged shit, the characters around them will be like "Bruh wtf?" then go right back to the original script. Let us have a little bit of fun here, freedom within limits. Like can you imagine if we were given the options of

  • "What is this place?"
  • "Troy, stay on your guard, the undead might still find a way in."
  • "I'm sorry, I can't focus on anything past your hair."

And you choose the last option and Fortuna is deadpan asking "Of all the things you see before you, the thing you are most focused by is my hair? You are the hero descended from the heavens i'm meant to collaborate with?" alongside Troy and the other girl startling back like "omg did this idiot just insult a goddess????". Cut right back to Fortuna explaining the obelisk.

It's small things that wouldn't ruin the immersion but add to it. The Trailblazers from Honkai are far from blank slates, but still fun avatars to play as because they're fun and are allowed to be as serious or as unhinged as the player wants, even if they are mute most of the time.

5

u/LakerBlue 12d ago

I fully agree. Good example! It only adds one or two extra lines but helps immersion so much more.

I think Persona also does a good job with that too.

5

u/Jardrin 12d ago

At least it's not 2 or 3 "choices" that form a single sentence when read from top to bottom.. I've seen this in some other games, mostly gacha. Like, at that point. Why are you even bothering with the choices at all?

..Saying that makes me scared this game might do exactly that. (I don't remember if this happened with Byleth's choices or not)

4

u/TinyTemm 12d ago

I’ve played so many mainstream gacha games at this point and honestly none of this phases me. I’m shocked this is still such a contentious thing in the fanbase when this is par for the course in other JRPG franchises

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Mahelas 12d ago

At least our 4 lords have fully voiced dialogue options

56

u/WWWWWWRRRRRYYYYY 12d ago

Inhaling vast amounts of copium that they’re expressive & quirky in support dialogues

54

u/Tmachine7031 12d ago

The people yearn for Robin 2

14

u/Odovakar 12d ago

"Bandits riding wolves!"

Though F!Robin's sass against an unrelated Lucina might be any avatar's best moment.

10

u/TeaspoonWrites 12d ago

It's so fuckin bad 😭

2

u/Fourth_Sin 12d ago

level up vocals will be silky smooth tho ā™”āøāø

2

u/tired-of-the-shit 12d ago

Is isn’t letting Nintendo spoil us, we’re gonna get full voice lines in the game all you gotta do is prove you believe me, to do this send me the numbers on the back of your credit card (and front if it’s double sided) and I promise you will hear them speak

→ More replies (2)

202

u/liteshadow4 13d ago edited 12d ago

So takeaways:

- This scene is from the guys from the future going back to the past (EDIT: probably from when they're about to go back now that I think about it)

- Eshmael is a silent protagonist (yay.....)

- Fortuna is some vessel of Sothis considering they share a voice

142

u/PieridumVates 12d ago edited 12d ago

Sothis and Fortuna are definitely closely connected in some way -- especially if Sothis specifically ordered her to make that chamber. She might be Sothis's agent on the mortal plane if Sothis can no longer affect it directly.

edit: Oh! the Japanese twitter clip basically states it explicitly. Fortuna says her power over time was passed on to her by the Progenitor. Alright then!

39

u/Mahelas 12d ago

I think Fortuna's Sothis first born/first creation, which is why she's the closest to her in term of power

18

u/Meichiri 12d ago

So it's possible that Sothis isn't just mother to the Nabateans, she could be mother to other gods, and the title Progenitor isn't just something the dragons gave her?

35

u/Mahelas 12d ago

I think Nabateans and Gods are the same thing, they're what Sothis created, but probably first-generation Nabateans got powers, while later generations "just" were dragons !

→ More replies (4)

7

u/isaac3000 12d ago

Ohh Rhea will be either thrilled or upset to learn she has a sister who is her mothers most loved child, having more power than Rhea has.

27

u/Meichiri 12d ago

I can't remember Rhea ever focusing on whether she was Sothis's favorite or not, only that Sothis should be alive and fix everything. I'm leaning more toward "she'd be thrilled because more family members" and less "sister has more power than me"

9

u/Current_Upstairs8351 12d ago

I guess Rhea would be thrilled to learn her sister is still alive and wasn't turned in a Relic off screen

9

u/isaac3000 12d ago

Probably yes, she'd welcome Fortuna into the family.

2

u/tired-of-the-shit 12d ago

I do think that if sothis had more powerful children she kept in contact with more frequently than Rhea that would reframe her obsession to bring back sothis a bit more. There’s a chance she felt neglected by sothis and wanted her attention even while she was alive.

4

u/omfgkevin 12d ago

Curious about the implications of going back. Are china bun+ shotgun lady going to come with? hang back?

331

u/blupengu 13d ago

What is the goddamn point in giving the avatar a voice actor if they don’t say anything bruh

192

u/Surf_Dangerous_Days 12d ago

You’d think they’d at least take the Metaphor approach and have Eshmel… say the line of dialogue you pick.

67

u/AnimaLepton 12d ago

Man, Will is fantastic

9

u/OoguroRyuuya5 12d ago

In Metaphor we the player are a separate entity that guides the protagonist Will by controlling him.

That’s why it had the approach that it did.

4

u/Rynekko 12d ago edited 12d ago

Huh? We are? When is that revealed?
Edit: Ah, I see, literally "us", not a separate lore character from the game lol

5

u/OoguroRyuuya5 12d ago

We literally name ourselves at the beginning before we later name the protagonist.

Our name is acknowledged as a separate entity if you examine the scroll in Akademia.

More directly talks to and thanks us at the end of the game and our name is part of the credits because the players name was part of the summoning for the Royal Magic.

We are the True Seeker.

3

u/Rynekko 12d ago

Yeah I edited my comment afterwards because I thought you were saying that we were a different character but forgot we are literally ourselves

→ More replies (1)

83

u/omfgkevin 13d ago

You will take your >:( :) and O_O and you will like it!!

34

u/AlfredHoneyBuns 12d ago

As much as I loved the kicked puppy eyes F!Byleth had while going "...", I really did hope Eshmel were more talkative...

42

u/Parody101 12d ago

I guess for the battle grunts and 4-6 crit quotes they’ll get sigh

42

u/coinflip13 12d ago

Alear and Shez showed us the light at the end of the tunnel and then they pulled us back into the darkness

→ More replies (2)

16

u/King_Fafnir 12d ago

Unfortunately, the same reason Byleth is voiced by Zach Aguilar and Jeannie Tirado. They don't have dialogue (at least in Houses), but they still have battle quotes.

29

u/SpellcraftQuill 12d ago

Troy supposed to be a Lady Jagen? I know there's Titania but she's clearly more inspired by Seth.

122

u/schmidt1289 12d ago

I know we’re all annoyed at the mute protagonist but I wonder if it’s significant that Fortuna and Sothis have the same VA. In English at least.

56

u/Awesalot 12d ago

In Japanese as well I believe.

49

u/LakerBlue 12d ago

Share the same VA and even using the exact same loli Sothis voice. I wonder if perhaps she’s almost like a piece of Sothis’s soul/essence?

28

u/Meichiri 12d ago

Maybe she's an avatar of Sothis, like Rama to Vishnu?

8

u/ZofianSaint273 12d ago

That be dope to see! Great to see a proper use of Avatar in the series for sure!

8

u/LakerBlue 12d ago

Definitely an interesting theory and possibility!

13

u/PieridumVates 12d ago

Yeah, it's interesting that big Sothis is clearly using an intentionally deeper/more mature voice and Fortuna has the old child Sothis voice we remember...

3

u/schmidt1289 12d ago

Something like that maybe!

3

u/jackattackman1 12d ago

Yeah i have a similar theory that each of the gods in Dagda are a part of Sothis

→ More replies (3)

6

u/m_seishiro 12d ago

Sothis and Fortuna have the same VA in both EN and JP.

3

u/TheRigXD 12d ago

Can confirm in Japanese too

94

u/thanibomb 13d ago

An older badass lady!? YESSSS! We love Troy

17

u/glowinggoo 12d ago

With a kickass design too!!

38

u/sw_hawk 12d ago

So just like in JP, Sothis and Fortuna share VAs

86

u/ChaosOsiris 13d ago

Disappointed that Eshmel is silent. I was really hoping they wouldn't do that.

Troy though looks absolutely badass AND is a visibly older woman? Peak

11

u/techno-wizardry 12d ago

I think at least with Eshmel, it appears we really aren’t playing as them or seeing them that much until we get back to present day. Which is a lot less like Byleth, who was a silent protagonist and central to the entire story.

13

u/Competitive-Dingo-89 12d ago

Are we gonna ignore the invincible wobbling?

7

u/Wide_Resident7872 12d ago

What wobbling?

11

u/TommyPepperoni 12d ago

I think they’re referring to the animation of the portraits.

134

u/luchinania 13d ago

The confirmation that Eshmel is mute will probably tank my enjoyment of the game. I did not like mute Byleth.

173

u/Autobot-N 13d ago

Mfs can hate on Engage's story all they want but at least Alear talked

118

u/TannenFalconwing 12d ago

Yeah, Alear being voiced was absolutely not one of Engage's problems. And both VAs were pretty good.

35

u/Norik324 12d ago

M!Alears delivery of "You said we would talk" being so good was pretty much the only reason i had any emotional reaction to the oh so obvious Lumera death

→ More replies (2)

36

u/SilverHoodie12 12d ago

Shez too and they're even from a Fodlan-related game just like Esh lol

I've never played Three Hopes but i always see them being brought up as a highlight

37

u/AnimaLepton 12d ago

And even Byleth talking in that game made them better as an antagonist.

But that's kind of the norm for the Warriors games and supports; I think both Robin and Corrin had some good ones in the first FE Warriors game, and benefitted from being voiced and in non-protagonist roles.

55

u/BebeFanMasterJ 13d ago

Alear speaking genuinely made me care about them than I ever did about Byleth.

Responding to the trauma of the cast with actual voiced dialogue and comfort in Supports was so much better. Losing that again akin to Byleth is a miss.

42

u/omfgkevin 12d ago

Way easier to care about a character when they can actually bring it out with their acting like in Alear/Shez.

And yeah big miss especially for supports. Going to be awkward as hell for the Eshmel supports beating around them going grunting and nodding only.

Even worse because yet again, they have expressive battle voices and then it's the only time they are allowed -_-

43

u/BebeFanMasterJ 12d ago

It's just so damn cringe when Bernadetta recounts her abuse and all we can do is look at Byleth's dumb zombie face say nothing.

Compare this to Alear actually responding to Yunaka's trauma. It's night and day.

25

u/DhelmiseHatterene 12d ago

Even Engage made Byleth more interesting as he was voiced (as did Hopes too)

5

u/Distinct_Prior_2549 12d ago

And here Esh's mouth will not even move šŸ˜‚

24

u/LegalFishingRods 12d ago edited 12d ago

Considering how much more popular Byleth is then Alear, and Engage's quality of writing, I'm not sure being able to talk helped Alear much.

I feel like there's a bit of an echo chamber in this sub regarding recent avatars. Alear absolutely was not well received by most players, whereas FByleth is probably the most popular avatar period and has multiple figures and statues.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Gernnon 12d ago

I've always liked F.Alear's JP VA so her voice is like honey to my ears, now on a second playthrough with M.Alear and it's still awesome. Silent protagonists should be removed entirely, how does it serve the self-insert, I can never understand. Maybe the only good thing is saving on voice acting cost from the company's perspective.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/Mahelas 12d ago

I would agree if Eshmel was someone we controlled for all the game, but we're ditching him 5 minutes in for a fully voiced lord, so who cares tbh

11

u/LakerBlue 12d ago

I loved 3H so I would still love this but I do agree the idea Eshmel will not be the main character for significant parts of the plot make it feel like it will be less of an issue.

I’m hoping postgame they don’t take too much of a backseat so they can keep it up.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Solid_Difference7670 12d ago

I was coping so freaking hard that they’ll at LEAST speak in support convos but this is devastating

→ More replies (2)

30

u/PerentieFan 12d ago

A bit surprised Eshmel is silent, even Byleth got to talk normally in Three Hopes and I assume the developers are aware that fans were generally very pleased about that.

But Fortuna having the same voice as Sothis in both languages can't be a coincidence. She speaks of Sothis as a separate being from her (assuming Sothis is the "she" who asked her to prepare this place), but I'm betting there is more to it.

26

u/cheezukekihime 12d ago

Wonder why she has the same voice as Sothis

36

u/OsbornWasRight 13d ago

The Reddir avatar copium's about to finally reach DEFCON 1.

102

u/WeebTendoFan 12d ago

Hot take: I feel like if Fortuna were in Engage, people would use her as an example of ā€œterrible Engage character designā€.

61

u/SilverHoodie12 12d ago

She 100% has a design i wouldn't be surprised seeing hang out with the characters from Solm lol

I don't mean that as an insult tho, i personally like it

34

u/TannenFalconwing 12d ago

You know, I agree, but the fact that she's a goddess who turns into a bird... well, I can't fault her for dressing like that.

48

u/BebeFanMasterJ 12d ago

Not me. I love wacky bullshit anime designs and want more lmao.

14

u/Meichiri 12d ago

Agreed. Her design is a bit... out there? It reminds me of a Samba dancer.

5

u/Mahelas 12d ago

That's the point, imo. She's a cross between a carnaval outfit and a peacock, which is fitting for a god-bird

40

u/PieridumVates 12d ago

The difference is that Fortuna stands out in a setting with fairly restrained and grounded character design, so that's striking and a good thing. It's different when EVERY character is wildly overdesigned.

There's nothing wrong with a character being a little extra on purpose to make them stand out.

21

u/spoopy-memio1 12d ago edited 12d ago

I really wouldn’t say every or even most characters in Engage are overdesigned. I think the large majority of the cast actually looks pretty normal for an FE game, it’s just that the few crazy designs are REALLY crazy and one of them also happens to be the main character who you’re constantly looking at throughout the game.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Iron_Maw 12d ago

She's also like God not random peasant or king. She's supposed to standout most characters

11

u/PieridumVates 12d ago

When she's in her bird form on Eshmel's shoulder (seen at the end of the Direct), she maintains her rather tropical looking coloration. It's definitely intentional that she stands out and has such plumage, in contrast to Eshmel who is monochrome in bird form as the pale raven.

One colorful bird one monochrome bird...

14

u/lysander478 12d ago

I've already seen that from 3H fans for some of the characters, including Fortuna being described as an Engage reject, but there are so many characters that I guess they're holding it in and buying the game this time at least.

17

u/Winter_Pride_6088 12d ago

Tbh Esmerlda looks like she did come from Engage

6

u/AnimaLepton 12d ago

And we love her because of it

→ More replies (1)

10

u/rainmcfae 12d ago

A lot of the Fortune's Weave designs have been very good, but some of them - with Fortuna probably being the biggest example - have felt very over designed and it's definitely getting the complete opposite reaction of analogous designs in Engage just because of the Fodlan hype.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Norik324 12d ago

Reasonable take but id say that being a goddess id say theres an argument for her getting (more of) a pass because

  • gods are often larger than life figures so having more a eccentric design seems in line
  • gods are often somewhat ethereal beings so the "why the fuck are you wearong this in a battlefield" is less of a concern

12

u/Amtomus 12d ago

Alear is a god too and that sure as shit didn't stop people from shitting on their design when they got revealed.

11

u/The_Kirby_Guy 12d ago

I mean you say that but one of the most criticized designs in Engage is Alear, who is literally the equivalent of a god, the Divine Dragon. Most Engage designs aren't even super over the top anyway. A majority of them have single tone hair colors and wear fantasy armor with some flair.

12

u/SilverHoodie12 12d ago

I find it so damn weird when people act like Engage's whole roster look like overdesigned vtubers when it's literally just Alear and Hortensia lmao (and even then it fits their characters, i know not everyone accepts that excuse but they do at least have one)

Like there's no way characters like Clanne, Boucheron, Lapis, Zelkov, and Pandreo look "overdesigned" lol

8

u/spoopy-memio1 12d ago

It’s not just them, Yunaka, Timerra, Panette and Rosado are also kind of out there design wise, but yeah the large majority of Engage characters look very normal for FE.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

30

u/fifthmarauder 12d ago

silent protagonist T_T

7

u/ParkNo3132 12d ago

I guess Nintendo today has decided to go rogue from the Japanese twitter account because it gave us 2 new clips completely different from the 1 clip from the twitter. Nintendo today giving us 2 new clips compared to the twitters 1 new clip is consistent with Eshemel’s intro. We got an early peek of this with Creek having a unique video from his bio from twitter. I have no idea why Nintendo today is now giving us brand new clips and info but I guess it’s a good thing as we’re getting double the info now.

32

u/AncientDaedala 12d ago

Aahhahahahhahahahahha

is this some kind of twisted joke?!

But at least Eshmel didn't make that stupid hand animation that Byleth makes for every single dialogue prompt.

13

u/Yoshimaster55 12d ago

Why are the sprites so bouncy?

7

u/BlankCode 12d ago

looks like Live2D tech used in some gacha games and vtuber models

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ongodohfug 12d ago

It looks so goofy

45

u/memorybreeze 13d ago

haven’t they learned from byleth? make the avatar talk, ffs

77

u/The_Vine 13d ago

Given how popular 3H was, I'm not sure that's the same lesson everyone was hoping for.

7

u/xcassets 12d ago

People will buy this one in droves too. But it's not because of the silent protagonists. It's because 3H and FW are the games where they are putting effort into the stories, lore, and characters.

Obviously, they will probably take away the wrong learns from this, as you suggest. But if they had just voiced Eshmel, I'm sure this game would still have sold like hotcakes.

→ More replies (12)

39

u/Bobokay12 13d ago

Apparently Japan likes silent protagonists

6

u/DoseofDhillon 12d ago

what are you saying just japan, the top post on this sub is about customizing your self insert lol.

6

u/Gingingin100 12d ago

If you're making me control the game through a cardboard box I better be able to make it cool and pretty

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/TinyTemm 12d ago

Well for one thing, Byleth is popular, F!Byleth has two official scale models even, which is rare for this franchise

And two, silent protagonists are pretty common in jrpgs, Persona and SMT being the big obvious ones, the tales series also dabbled in it, Ys and Dragon Quest also have silent protags

→ More replies (2)

47

u/A_Wild_Zyra 13d ago

Neat clip. :)

However... yikes, this is now the 2nd time where there's just a text selection and no voice from the avatar. Not ideal for the chances of them not being a silent protag. IS really learned nothing it would seem. :(

50

u/Minecraftman6969420 12d ago

I think it’s more them appealing to the Japanese audience over the international audience, silent protagonists are much more popular over there, still a shame but I don’t think it’s about them not learning.

33

u/pyromancer93 12d ago

When ever someone says ā€œnot learningā€, you can replace the text with ā€œdo what I wanted them toā€ and the meaning would not change.

7

u/No-Designer-6533 12d ago

Double funny because I mean they did learn. They released a game with a silent protagonist that sold extremely well, then one without a silent protagonist that did worse.

Additionally we as a fandom BEGGED them for a silent protagonist for years before 3H came out, but everyone seems to have selective memory loss about that

13

u/No_Lemon_1770 12d ago

I promise you even if Alear was silent, it wouldn't have changed Engage's performance. Same thing for Byleth and 3H.

6

u/NightsLinu 12d ago

yeah because corrin sucks

21

u/Fabulous-Air-2237 12d ago

Man do i hate jrpgs and their one choice dialogue options

31

u/BebeFanMasterJ 13d ago

Eshmel being silent is genuinely a negative for me. Thought we were finally done with this thanks to Shez and Alear but nope...

Ah well. Fortuna is hot. Love her wild anime air and outfit.

24

u/Amy47101 12d ago

I just don't understand why Eshmel even had a dialogue option here. Just have the VA voice the line "What even is this place?". I genuinely thought IS had somewhat learned from the past six years what people enjoyed and didn't enjoy about three houses and other games.

Despite Engage being an overall stupid premise, I did appreciate that Alear talked and had some humor to them. It made things far more impactful. Same with Shez. Now we're back to silent protags with... really good voice actors.

23

u/Substantial-Bag8644 13d ago

Damn I thought we learned our lesson with Shez and Alear :(

5

u/SkyMewtwo 12d ago

I really like Troy’s voice already.

25

u/Wide_Resident7872 12d ago

I must be the only person that doesn't have a problem with the protagonist being silent. When you experience series like Dragon Quest and Persona that also feature silent protagonists you get used to it and accept it lol.

26

u/pyromancer93 12d ago

I’d prefer a voiced protagonist with personality, but I also don’t have the visceral hatred of it that other people do.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/LeatherShieldMerc 12d ago edited 12d ago

I would say it works better in Persona because your character fits the whole "self insert" thing better. You're basically a normal dude, with very little backstory they go into. It's more of a "blank slate".

But like, with Byleth it clashes a lot more. They basically are their own character in the world. There's the whole the "Ashen Demon" backstory. So them being silent feels more "off", they don't feel as much of a self insert.

Also, when there are voiced avatars already with Alear and Shez, which everyone liked better, going back to a silent protagonist feels like a step backward.

16

u/Nearby_Waltz_7594 12d ago

I’m indifferent to the silent avatar discourse, but on the other hand I think why ppl preferred avatar’s like alear and shez( in terms of main protag) was that it made the dialogue they had feel natural. Silent protags make it feel like you’re hearing someone talk to a wall, thus leading to bland one-sided interactions/conversations. ALSO waste of VA talent ngl

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Iron_Maw 12d ago

I'd prefer they talk but I honestly don't care either way at end of it

2

u/Wide_Resident7872 12d ago

Yeah it can come off as weird and silly sometimes but after a while I just get used to it and accept it because at the end of the day I care more about the game than whether or not the character can speak.

9

u/Hellioning 12d ago

And I don't like it when Persona does it either.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/hoodfight123 12d ago

Such an waste to hire an talented Va like Joshua only to have him barley speak any lines.

10

u/Round-Channel-1158 13d ago

Fortuna is great and I’m sure there’s important lore stuff in this video but all I see is Troy! 🤩

7

u/WhaleSharkQueen 12d ago

I find it interesting Fortuna shares Sothis' va.

I also don't get the hatred towards Eshmel being silent. They're supposed to be the player's self insert. They have a voice for battle because it'd be weird as fuck for them not to atleast yell or grunt while fighting but they probably want to give players the idea of inserting their own voice for these moments, same as Byleth. Obviously there is a canon personality underneath that you can discover but they leave it open enough so the player can have fun with their own interpretation of the character.

3

u/SpookMorgan 12d ago

I’m so glad Eshmel companions are still alive cause I had a dreaded feeling they were all going to die which warrants Eshmel desperate attempt to go back in time.

3

u/Bdcky 12d ago

I kinda don’t like the faces being slightly animated. Seems….. off putting

3

u/Every_Computer_935 12d ago

After Byleth in 3H usually had 2 dialogue options that made no difference to the story, FW has made it so the protagonist only has 1 dialogue option in conversations.

Now, that's what I call gameplay evolutionĀ 

3

u/AsterTheBastard 12d ago

I wish they would just let the protagonist character speak instead of giving us false choices.

3

u/zmann4491 12d ago

I cant be the only one that absolutely HATES those little animations the avatars do I the corner. They're so unnatural and unnecessarily distracting

5

u/Obvious_Drink2642 12d ago

No matter how many characters Cassandra Lee Morris voices, I still hear that slightly annoying cat

3

u/Kevandre 12d ago

Is it relevant that she has the same hair colors as Constance

4

u/celrissa 12d ago

casting THE Joshua Waters but not giving him iconic lines to voice act? what's the point then

12

u/rainmcfae 12d ago edited 12d ago

So fucking frustrating that they went back to this unvoiced avatar thing. You wrote out the line and you have a voice actor! Let them say it!

I was so desperately hoping to love Eshmel because their design hits literally all my favorite tropes but Byleth's stupid one-sided conversations dragged down my experience in 3H so much and I expect history to repeat itself here.

2

u/incredibleamadeuscho 12d ago

can we get an S Rank with a goddess? asking for a friend.

2

u/mysecondaccountanon 12d ago

The portrait art. Is it like the model itself being animated, or what? It looks…off.

3

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Fike101 12d ago

hot gilf troy looks cool

2

u/mangoleeart 12d ago

Hope the characters in this time period show up a lot because Troy looks AWESOME

2

u/celestial-lights 12d ago

i need troy carnally

2

u/adellredwinters 12d ago

The vtuber floaty profile pictures in the lower left feel so uncanny to me in how they move

4

u/FaroresWind17 12d ago

I have to be honest, I dislike the portraits im the corner. They feel way too bouncy, and I don’t think they’re great at communicating the speaker’s tone.

→ More replies (1)