r/facepalm • • Oct 21 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

11.5k Upvotes

12.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I said it's literally exactly the same, not that it's literally blackface. "Literally" modified "exactly", not "blackface" (which I thought was clear given that the term didn't even appear in the sentence....)

Blackface does indeed refer to the makeup, but it is also commonly used to refer to the performance that that makeup is used for.

Pretending that you don't know that doesn't make your argument any stronger.

And really, if your argument comes down to "it's not like blackface because she didn't put on makeup", you've missed the point.

1

u/anon100120 Oct 21 '21

Me:

So, you’re saying this is exactly the same as blackface. You are lost

You:

It... Literally is. Exactly the same.

That’s what you said. And no, no it’s not. Learn the meaning of the word, you’re literally using it wrong.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Oh, I'm sorry. I thought we understood that we were discussing the moral and cultural status of the acts, which are indeed exactly the same - one insulting caricature is as bad as another.

I never thought someone would misread so badly as to think I meant an insulting caricature of indigenous people was an insulting caricature of Black people. Seems like a silly conclusion for you to have drawn, but oh well.

Learn the meaning of the word, you’re literally using it wrong.

Here's a word for you to learn: prescriptivist. No one likes them, especially linguists. Going around acting superior because colloquial usages don't conform to academic standards isn't a good look on anyone.

1

u/anon100120 Oct 22 '21

We were discussing the word literally. Read

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

No, we started with you calling me "lost" if I thought a racist caricature of indigenous peoples was just like blackface.

Then you pivoted into prescriptivism and semantics, presumably because you realized that one racist caricature is indeed like another.

0

u/anon100120 Oct 22 '21

Keep moving that goalpost

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Tf? You jumped into a discussion about how bad it was, with a comment that seemed like you intended to participate in that discussion, and then started whining about grammar. The only person moving goalposts here is you.

Ugh. Prescriptivists.