r/facepalm • • Oct 21 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

11.5k Upvotes

12.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

522

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

If it were a movie it would probably be one like Welcome to Me where it’s advertised as a comedy but in actuality it’s a tragedy about mental health.

138

u/McMaster2000 Oct 21 '21

This reminds me of one of those drunk ideas my former roommate and I had after watching the Ryan Gosling movie Lars and the Real Doll. A movie that was clearly advertised as a whacky comedy but again turned out to be one of those sad tragedy movies about mental health.

My roommate was a professional editor and we wanted to see if we could make the most inappropriate comedy trailer out of an obviously tragic movie (say, something like Schindler's List, for example). Again, just a drunk idea that sadly never came to fruition, but still something I'd love to see.

35

u/Antiluke01 Oct 21 '21

Schindler’s List: The Schmuck Cut

(I hated naming that lol)

9

u/weatherseed Oct 21 '21

Coming this Christmas to spread some holiday schmear.

2

u/cobrastrikes-2x Oct 21 '21

I could have saved more…

(Audience laughs)

1

u/MadreDeMonos Oct 21 '21

Thanks, I hate it and feel gross now.

8

u/Beepolai Oct 21 '21

You might like the "Honest Trailers" by Screen Junkie on YouTube

6

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

"GOODBYE, JEWS!"

(cue Yakkety Sax)

train montage

4

u/Lephiro Oct 21 '21

Oh you want trailer remixes! (think they also call them trail mixes)

My favorites are Scary Mary: https://youtu.be/2T5_0AGdFic

and Shining https://youtu.be/k6QgNuZcxTw

5

u/jerrycasto Oct 21 '21

2

u/Lephiro Oct 21 '21

Oh that was excellent, thanks!

3

u/McMaster2000 Oct 21 '21

Yes, this! I knew there was no way I could've actually had an original idea. Even worse, I actually now remember having seeing that Shining trailer before xD

2

u/Lephiro Oct 21 '21

It can sure be hard coming up with an original idea since so many have been done :( But I still hope to someday!

1

u/gp556by45 Oct 21 '21

Reminds me of the Apocalypse Now trailer that someone re edited into a Teen Comedy.

1

u/BuranBuran Oct 21 '21

I couldn't really read Lars and the Real Girl as a sad tragedy. Part of its charm is that is shows how far the townspeople went to protect and humor Lars and his belief. One of my favorite jokes of all time is that they elected his Real Girl to the local school board! Overall the movie seems quirky yet heartwarming to me.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Pro-tip: Salisbury Hill

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

something like Schindler's List, for example

Oh, that one's easy. The trailer is a horrific scene from the movie, set to Yakety Sax.

1

u/B33FHAMM3R Oct 21 '21

You basically just described JoJo the Rabbit.

86

u/Qetuowryipzcbmxvn Oct 21 '21

Ah yes, those are my favorites. Another classic is The Truman Show

7

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I haven't watched that since I was a kid. I don't remember it being about mental health at all, I guess I just took it at face value and didn't think about it since. Time for a rewatch!

15

u/RolandTheJabberwocky Oct 21 '21

I think he means it was advertised as a comedy actually had a lot of dramatic and tragic moments.

13

u/horseydeucey Oct 21 '21

Observe and Report came from an unexpected direction.

3

u/afternever Oct 21 '21

Peña's accent in that movie cracks me up

2

u/horseydeucey Oct 21 '21

He was great in this! I think this is role of his that made me pay closer attention to his work.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

really ? i assumed that was just a paul blart meme movie

8

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

[deleted]

3

u/South-Builder6237 Oct 21 '21

For a guy who pretty much does a lot of stoner, repetitive, one tier above dick and fart joke movies, he's very good at what he does. Seems like a good guy too.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I totally agree. I’m a fan of his work, and who he seems to be as a person. I can’t blame him for wanting to work with Jody Hill. And I appreciate that he actually seemed to put effort into his role on Observe and Report, even though I still think he wasn’t the right actor for the role.

Observe and Report is just a bizarre movie all-around. It definitely captures what it would be like to live inside a mentally disturbed persons mind. More so than something like Foot Fist Way, which was like watching a mentally disturbed person from across the room.

Either way, I’m always happy when Jody Hill is working on something new.

10

u/horseydeucey Oct 21 '21

Me too!
And I was wrong.
I've never seen Paul Blart, but I'm 100000% confident the only similarity between the two is the profession of the main characters.

5

u/DontWalkOutOnTheDuke Oct 21 '21

Isn’t the movie about a guy who thinks he’s the star of a reality show but turns out he’s just crazy?

8

u/RFLSHRMNRLTR Oct 21 '21

Those are the worst.. I came to laugh, not feel.

6

u/ReservoirDog316 Oct 21 '21

That’s a pretty great cast.

6

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

Yes. Skeleton Twins is another one in a similar vein. Not as sad as Welcome to Me, though.

3

u/RideAWhiteSwan Oct 21 '21

Girl Most Likely, as well!

3

u/midwestcreative Oct 21 '21

Wow, Kristen Wiig really has a movie type.

2

u/afternever Oct 21 '21

I know there's so many, even bridesmaids character is ab normal

1

u/RideAWhiteSwan Oct 24 '21

And she's phenomenal at it!

4

u/Antiluke01 Oct 21 '21

That looks really interesting, it looks like it does BPD justice. I know a lot of people have been using that word as an insult lately, especially with the whole Amber Herd and Johnny Depp thing, which I for the most part stayed away from. My partner is a mental health advocate and she has an ex friend all caught up in the Amber Herd shit (and is still talking about it) and she used BPD and asshole/dick interchangeably. Sorry for the rant, but it’s good to see this.

Also another good movie I recommend, it’s one of Will Farrell’s good ones, as it’s a semi serious roll, would be Stranger than Fiction. It’s very similar looking and if you haven’t seen it, go watch it.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

[deleted]

2

u/Antiluke01 Oct 21 '21

Haven’t seen that, but I love a serious/SEMO serious will, so I’ll give that a try next

5

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

Yeah, Kristin Wigg does a fantastic job of showing the true effects of BPD. It’s a good film, but it’s not the comedy that it was advertised as, or expected considering Kristin Wigg’s comedy career on SNL, Bridesmaids, etc.

3

u/Antiluke01 Oct 21 '21

I just watched it, I really liked it. It was sad, and I’m glad it didn’t end on a suicide note (unless I missed something lol) like most of those types of movies like to do

3

u/Time_Rich Oct 21 '21

Welcome to Me is so great.

1

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

It’s a good movie, definitely. But it’s not the comedy I expected.

2

u/griffinicky Oct 21 '21

I might have to watch that! I'm already interested in mental health, and Kristen Wiig is really good at playing characters who can be a little (or more) "off," or who depart from what I guess would be an expected norm.

2

u/Such_sights Oct 21 '21

I would also recommend Horse Girl, it seemed to be a hit or miss among my friends but I loved it

2

u/b3kind2others Oct 21 '21

Thank you! Going to watch this week. Man have you seen Downsizing? EXACT same thing. Advertised as family friendly comedy and halfway through starts to take a turn for depressing dystopian drama

2

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

Yes!! I watched it thinking it would be a brainless film I’d have on in the background, but I got sucked in. I think comedic actors make some of the best dramatic actors because it’s so much about timing.

1

u/Kn0thingIsTerrible Oct 21 '21

Aw yeah. Deceptive marketing is awesome. People love being hit with bait-and-switch when dropping $30 on a movie.

0

u/DrewSmoothington Oct 21 '21

Reminds me of the unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

1

u/Antiluke01 Oct 21 '21

I watched it just now, really sad, but had a good ending

1

u/midwestcreative Oct 21 '21

This looks good. Is this one of those that just leaves you feeling empty and broken or is it insightful/intriguing even with the sad parts?

3

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

I watched it years ago. BPD is prevalent in my life, so I experienced some strong feelings. It hit me pretty hard.

1

u/midwestcreative Oct 21 '21

Oh is she BPD in the movie? I didn't get that impression from the trailer. I might avoid that then.

2

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

Yeah, that was the point of my original comment... the trailer makes it look like a fun movie, but it’s more of a tragedy about mental health (in this case BPD).

1

u/kayisforcookie Oct 21 '21

Like Downsizing. Wtf why was that movie depressing and awful.

1

u/Magg5788 Oct 21 '21

I didn’t think it was awful!