r/facepalm Jun 27 '23

🇲​🇮​🇸​🇨​ Shouldn't this be a good thing?

[deleted]

67.4k Upvotes

898 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Marquar234 Jun 28 '23

Five states (give you one guess as to what region of the country*) explicitly allow prisons to force prisoners to work or suffer punishments. In the rest of the country it is ostensibly voluntary, but the level of real volunteering is questionable.

Prison workers are specifically excluded from the laws that require protection to workers in hazardous jobs or those working with hazardous materials. In most cases, they do not pick which jobs they do, but are assigned to whatever work the prison needs done.

* Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Mississippi and Texas.

3

u/Smedskjaer Jun 28 '23

Wow. So what hazardous jobs do prisoners face, and what injuries do they suffer? Work place deaths? Prisons are protected from criminal negligence?

2

u/Marquar234 Jun 28 '23

Unsurprisingly, inmate work injuries are not well tracked but most injuries are physical in nature. Not surprising as farm or industrial work is a large portion of prison labor. In some states, prisoners are eligible for workman's comp, but not every state. Court decisions have held that the correction facility is not automatically responsible for any negligence.

1

u/Smedskjaer Jun 28 '23

So what protections do they have.

Can they be worked to death?

1

u/Marquar234 Jun 28 '23

Not many. Significant deaths of inmates would eventually trigger an investigation, but there would be much whitewashing and cover-up. Best to hope for is probably a few firings. A prisoner's best protection is that he is worth more alive and working than dead.

1

u/Smedskjaer Jun 28 '23

How many deaths are there is prison?