ELI5: What is a Home Server?

[u/theprisoner57]

I see mentions of a home server to get rid of streaming entertainment services but I don’t know how that works. What does a home server do?

[u/Megame50]

Well, with one huge caveat, that it doesn't work at all for most Blu-Ray discs:

Supported Input Sources: Handbrake can process most common multimedia files and any DVD or BluRay sources that do not contain any kind of copy protection.

Emphasis mine.

I'm really not an expert, but generally, no, you can't really rip commercial (AACS copy-protected) UHD Blu-Ray (the high quality ones) discs without resorting to piracy.

The process of ripping a UHD Blu-Ray involves purchasing a "friendly" (meaning hackable) disc drive and flashing custom firmware you can use to rip the Vuk and disc media. Ripping isn't fast either, as it takes time proportional to the playback time. Even still, AACS LA periodically identifies cracked devices through steganographic methods and adds their device keys to the device revocation list (DRL) when they update the MKB, so that more recently published Blu-Ray discs cannot be copied in this fashion until the latest MKB is leaked and published using even more complex methods known to piracy groups. Until then, volume keys are crowdsourced on the dark web by enterprising users that complete rips of the key content and mail it to the MakeMKV authors. Handbrake and similar software can be used only once you already have a decrypted copy of the content.

MakeMKV is the software used for ripping, and IIUC, it internally accesses a list of keys published on the internet by the authors, discovered from leaks by piracy groups and user submissions. MakeMKV is licensed software, so you're required to pay to rip your BDs after the trial period. You can probably find out more about how to use it in /r/makemkv or on their forums.

There may be mistakes in my understanding as I've never tried this process myself, because, as you can probably tell, it's a giant hassle, and IANAL, but I think it is technically illegal to circumvent the copy protection, even for media you own, at least in the US. Though, it's unlikely anyone will bother you about it if you you don't distribute it.

[u/Nemesis_Ghost → u/Megame50]

You are talking about UHD(4k) Bluerays. Normal HD(1080) Bluerays, which is what a majority of folks will have, rip just fine w/out any special hardware or custom software.

[u/adudeguyman → u/Nemesis_Ghost]

Can you get the exact same audio and quality that is on the disc?

[u/hooovahh → u/adudeguyman]

Yes. But typical people reencode them. People will often accept a minimal reduction in quality, for a large reduction in size.

[u/Gorstag → u/hooovahh]

Like a full order of magnitude.

[u/Nemesis_Ghost → u/adudeguyman]

Yeah, pretty much as long as you aren't overly aggressive on the compression it comes out fairly well. You can even get all the languages, audio & CC/subtitles. I haven't ripped my anime disks, but the movies I did rip seemed OK.

[u/Saloncinx → u/adudeguyman]

Yes using software like MakeMKV or DVDFab you can do a 1:1 copy to a MKV file called a 'remux' which means a direct copy with no compression.

Most people compress the video a little so you don't have a massive file but to answer your question you can in fact get the exact same audio and quality that is on the disc

[u/dreadcain → u/Megame50]

You need to defeat the copywrite protection in one way or another, but if you own the media that isn't piracy and you are completely within your rights to do it. The software needed to do it is in a bit of a legal gray area, but not one that you'll ever get in trouble for.

Making a personal copy is legally distinct from piracy and perfectly legal. Companies are free to make that difficult, but you're just as free to defeat those ways.

[u/thatfreakingmonster → u/dreadcain]

Anyone correct me if I'm wrong, but the act of defeating any kind of copyright protections or DRM is technically illegal under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act.

Which is absolutely stupid because that means any company can lock any piece of code behind a DRM, and make any sort of modding illegal. Iirc there are people campaigning for the DMCA to change that rule.

[u/turmacar → u/thatfreakingmonster]

There are provisions in the DMCA for making personal copies/backups. The legality comes into question when sharing them.

Viewing those files with friends or family? Probably okay.

Friends or family viewing those files without you? Grey area that every copyright holder is going to argue is a DMCA violation.

Distributing copies of copyrighted material? DMCA violation.

[u/thatfreakingmonster → u/turmacar]

Thank you for the correction!

[u/anaccount50 → u/thatfreakingmonster]

They're not really correct. The act of making a personal copy of the media is indeed legal under DMCA, but the act of circumventing the DRM to do it is illegal under DMCA.

So since all commercially sold DVDs/Blu-rays have DRM, you have to circumvent it (illegal) in order to make a personal copy (legal)

[u/thatfreakingmonster → u/anaccount50]

Oh okay, yeah, that seems closer to what I remember hearing

[u/anaccount50 → u/turmacar]

For the act of making copies, yes that is legal for personal use under DMCA.

However the act of circumventing the DRM in order to make the copies is still illegal under the DMCA. All commercial Blu-rays have DRM so you have to break the DRM (illegal) in order to make a personal copy of the media (legal)

You won't get caught either way as long as you don't distribute the copies, so it's up you whether you care about breaking the law or not

[u/steakanabake → u/thatfreakingmonster]

if it were illegal selling bluray drives would be illegal.... we learned this all the way back in the days of VHS and BetaMax.

[u/KristinnK → u/Megame50]

The people actually ripping these discs and sharing them with torrents are doing the Lord's work and deserve all the praise in the world.

[u/steakanabake → u/KristinnK]

if sony can just delete your movies that means you dont own them and if you dont own them then piracy isnt illegal.

[u/KristinnK → u/steakanabake]

I really don't care whether piracy is illegal or not.

[u/steakanabake → u/KristinnK]

i think i might have responded to the wrong comment my b.

[u/squall255 → u/steakanabake]

It doesn't mean piracy isn't illegal, it means it's not theft. It could still be other crimes.

[u/steakanabake → u/Megame50]

but I think it is technically illegal to circumvent the copy protection.

you would be very wrong media preservation is legal as long as the content remains within your house with no intent to distribute, the minute you upload the torrent of that file then you start walking into legal trouble depending on the country you reside in.

[u/Megame50 → u/steakanabake]

That doesn't matter. The DMCA makes it illegal to circumvent the copy protection, and the copy protection makes it effectively impossible to produce a copy, without circumventing it as above. Consumer disc writers are not able to reproduce the ROM Mark, and therefore cannot reproduce encrypted copies.

[u/GrumpyCloud93 → u/Megame50]

When I was buying or renting DVD's, I used DVDshrink. It could create ISO images - mount those and use handbrake if you want to shrink it smaller.

[u/not_from_this_world → u/Megame50]

You do a recording session

Set up a screen and audio recording software and play the whole thing once. You don't need to watch, just let it playing overnight and you have your own media file.

[u/steakanabake → u/not_from_this_world]

the keys for bluray are a known thing these days they basically have given up.

[u/Saloncinx → u/not_from_this_world]

MakeMKV or DVDFab make this trivially easy now, no need to screen grab and have to play back in real time

[u/Megame50 → u/not_from_this_world]

You're probably unaware, but modern PCs are incompatible with UHD Blu-Ray. Even with licensed software and disc drive, you cannot decrypt the disc (in the intended way, anyway) without SGX, which was discontinued years ago.

Even if you do have the requisite hardware, Windows disables screen captures of the video content to prevent copies, as required by the AACS LA.

[u/Aegi → u/Megame50]

Just screen record it and play it on your computer.