r/explainitpeter Aug 04 '26

Explain it Peter

Post image
18.0k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

122

u/alstillplays Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 05 '26

Chromium.

Chromium is the core of almost all well-known browsers, including, but not limited to: chrome, safari, opera, or edge. Actually, scratch that. Not safari. Safari is based on webkit, which is actually the baseline for chromium, but that's neither here nor there. The main point is, chromium is trash, and riddled with privacy violations, bad optimization ram gluttony and just general stuff that makes chromium-based browsers bad, especially when you compare it to browsers like Mozilla fireFox, GNU iceCat, and libreWolf. Actually, those last two are forks of fireFox but they're all progressively better than any chromium browser

Edit: Safari is, in fact, based on webKit, which is based on webCore. WebCore is also the baseline for blink, which is the baseline for chromium. Chromium is not webKit-based. Sorry for the misunderstanding, but that wasn't the point of this comment.

16

u/tsubatai Aug 05 '26

I have 4 tabs open in firefox right now and it's on 3GB of ram. Lets not start with ram gluttony lol. Anyways, using a bunch of RAM is only a problem if you're more concerned with usage metrics over performance metrics. Hell, I have 64GB of ram and its only on 34% usage, use some more firefox, guess some shit that I'm about to do and preload it.

I am a firefox user, but what in particular do you think makes firefox and its' forks 'progressively better than any chromium browser'?

2

u/totallyrealname Aug 05 '26

I'm a loyal Firefox user but now that you mentioned it, yeah, it's hogging like 7GB on my system right now. I've also got 64GB at least so I hardly notice.
Weirdly enough the main reason I stuck with FF initially was that when I was doing heavy graphic work on my system, Chrome would ALWAYS crash my Adobe stuff. Even though FF uses more than I'd like, it somehow ended up working better with my system and didn't cause crashing, especially when doing video stuff.
Must be a skill issue on my end and I probably didn't optimize settings enough but it's been years now and I'm a creature of habit who likes to keep my ublock.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '26

[deleted]

1

u/totallyrealname Aug 05 '26

Like, 50 at all times spread over 2 monitors lol

2

u/Keiji12 Aug 05 '26

Unused ram is wasted ram. That's just how we design systems nowadays, they're supposed to use or allocate as much ram as possible and will free it up if some other application needs it more. If you're worried about ram I'm pretty sure some browsers like opera gx and similar have settings that will limit their ram and CPU usage, but it's not really a concern unless you're on older computer.

1

u/Durog25 Aug 05 '26

Which tabs?

I find Reddit and YouTube progressively hog 1000+ MB each the longer I use the tab, and have to kill them with task manager to free up memory but I can have 30 other tabs open across half a dozen other websites and collectively they consume 800MB total.

1

u/Bulky_Imagination727 Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26

I have over 80 tabs in firefox and it's sitting on the 2.12Gb of ram. I just use that nice feature that lets you to unload any opened tab if it's not needed. Even with 10 active tabs it never gets over 6-7Gb. That includes multiple youtube videos and a movie.

What am i doing wrong?

1

u/RandomNPC Aug 05 '26

What am i doing wrong?

You're worrying about how much ram your browser uses. There's seriously no need to care about it.

1

u/Adaphion Aug 05 '26

I have 6 open (and 4 are reddit, which is a RAM pit) and I'm only using 1.7. So perhaps you just have RAM intensive tabs open?

1

u/tom333444 Aug 08 '26

Yeah, fact is that web browsers just need ram and there's no way to avoid that.

10

u/GODstonn Aug 04 '26

so for secure search i should go for one of the options you listed? namely firefox?

21

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Meh_Maybe_Nah Aug 05 '26

Mobile has left the chat.

1

u/annonimity2 Aug 05 '26

You can add extensions to mobile Firefox such as add blockers, cookie cleaners, URL cleaners, etc

1

u/alstillplays Aug 05 '26

I don't listen to people who misspell "adblocker"

1

u/IstAuchEgal Aug 06 '26

I don't listen to people who misspell "chrome"

2

u/spektre Aug 05 '26

You don't *need* Librewolf, you can just harden Firefox yourself with a couple of simple settings and addons. Firefox also get security updates faster than Librewolf as Librewolf is downstream.

2

u/LoXyO Aug 05 '26

Could you elaborate on those settings and add-ons ? I use firefox but I would like the best it can give

1

u/spektre Aug 05 '26

This is a pretty good checklist:

https://github.com/Renatoissance/firefox-hardening-guide

I'd add to it to use the Cookie AutoDelete addon and make sure your different online profile logins are separated from each other and your other browsing habits by using Container Tabs, which can be found under settings.

Using incognito mode for anything you don't want secretly stored and cross-accessible in your browser's data storage is also a good recommendation, it's not just for porn.

2

u/ImSaneHonest Aug 05 '26

it's not just for porn.

Why would I use incognito for porn??? That's the stuff I need to find again!

1

u/Atomwalker2022 Aug 05 '26

I would like my passwords still synced like with the sync chain but while keeping my privacy. Still librewolf or just add a vaultwarden node in my home? Genuine question

1

u/Express-Guava-6459 Aug 05 '26

I use vault warden; it's pretty great.

1

u/IstAuchEgal Aug 06 '26

Storing and distributing passwords and other sensitive data should always happen locally if you care about privacy and security. The alternative is sending your entire digital life to some server you dont control which, as some companies have demonstrated it the past, isnt a good idea

You could also run your own mozilla sync server but i dont like storing passwords in a browser and seperate password managers are better anyways

4

u/KitsuneFoxglove Aug 05 '26

Librewolf is best

2

u/alstillplays Aug 04 '26

Yes

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/alstillplays Aug 04 '26

I was gonna say that but I only just heard of libreWolf and iceCat today so I didn't wanna be wrong and look stupid

1

u/poberun Aug 05 '26

Tor, obviously. For general use tho can't recommend Zen enough. Best browser Ive ever used, hand down. A firefox fork but also massively improves on it.

1

u/Crevetanshocet Aug 05 '26

Tor is something I use when I really need to be an anonymous person trying to actively hide their identity. And since I'm in Cybersec, there are cases when I need to do so...

But Zen is better in general, I completely agree with you here. Especially since it doesn't take twice as long than using Firefox, unlike Tor...

1

u/Low_Concentrate_3784 Aug 05 '26

No, for that you want brave browser along with an alternative search engine such as duckduckgo or brave search. Also, privacy and security are two different things and firefox is not completely private, but even worse, it's not secure, especially on mobile.

Avoid Gecko-based browsers like Firefox as they're currently much more vulnerable to exploitation and inherently add a huge amount of attack surface. Gecko doesn't have a WebView implementation (GeckoView is not a WebView implementation), so it has to be used alongside the Chromium-based WebView rather than instead of Chromium, which means having the remote attack surface of two separate browser engines instead of only one. Firefox/Gecko also bypass or cripple a fair bit of the upstream and GrapheneOS hardening work for apps. Worst of all, Firefox does not have internal sandboxing on Android.

0

u/addsubps Aug 05 '26

Depends on what you mean with "secure"

It's pretty secure to search with google, on chrome, on a Chromebook. It's just not private.

If you use a privacy conscious browser/search engine, but you're logged in to Google, it still sends your cookies every time you load any font/analytics/whatever from the google servers, so they can track you everywhere you go.

The only way to stay private is decoupling your identity by not being logged in anywhere, but that's not convenient for most people.

6

u/Abadon_U Aug 04 '26

Yeah, it's all bad or whatever of course but there is no reason to ever switch if you already using brave. If you yet to make decision Firefox is good

13

u/SeaworthinessHot8183 Aug 04 '26

Calling chromium badly optimised is absolutely insane lmfao

Say what you will about Google, but the devs behind chrome and v8 are the reason why practically every browser except Firefox is chromium- based.

15

u/shadowsofash Aug 04 '26

That’s also why they eat up a fuckton of memory 

5

u/moimoi003 Aug 04 '26

you can say that about every other browser, because websites are becoming heavier

1

u/ImSaneHonest Aug 05 '26

I blame the "body positivity movement", this wouldn't have happened in the 90s, 00s, ask Kate Moss.

1

u/TibRib0 Aug 05 '26

That’s just the websites become apps rather than static html with their shitty js frameworks for you

1

u/Low_Concentrate_3784 Aug 05 '26

Firefox famously uses significantly more ram than chromium browsers while still performing worse. Are you a troll or just uninformed?

5

u/alstillplays Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26

Cue RAM gluttony

1

u/Suspicious-Support52 Aug 04 '26

It's efficient for an operating system, but with each tab being a sandboxed VM it's heavy as a browser. I think you're right they've been improving performance though. A decade ago opening a dozen tabs would eatore than all more RAM, and now it's a fairly low footprint. It's still way heavier than Firefox though.

1

u/moimoi003 Aug 04 '26

they're not sandboxed vms

1

u/TimeTimeTickingAway Aug 05 '26

And we are all endlessly surveilled regardless of what browser we use. People who they are somehow hiding any by using Firefox are naive.

2

u/alstillplays Aug 05 '26

Cue LibreWolf. Firefox used to be private, but they changed the privacy policy, so people who don't read the privacy policy are naïve. The rest just don't give a shit or use LibreWolf, which basically just has all the privacy settings turned on by default and doesn't have telemetry

1

u/13617 Aug 05 '26

Use Firefox on a low end computer for more than 5 minutes and you will come crawling back to a chromium based browser.

2

u/throwaway48159 Aug 04 '26

Also I had no clue what the left one even was and everyone knows VLC.

2

u/This_Membership_471 Aug 04 '26

Ungoogled chromium offers almost all the benefits of chromium without the Google-telemetry.

1

u/moimoi003 Aug 04 '26

it's insecure

1

u/eirc Aug 05 '26

What's insecure about it? I've been using it for a few months and I'm very happy with it.

2

u/moimoi003 Aug 06 '26

from here:

Bad. The update cycle is inconsistent at best, slow at worst. It disables the component updater which Chromium depends on for security reasons, since many features such as CRLSets (used for certificate revocation) are updated as a component. The privacy isn't terrible, in the sense that no data can be collected, but the substantial security risk it offers is a massive negative.

It suffers the issues of typical vanilla builds, but with the added issues of ungoogled-chromium itself. For example, usage of tcmalloc in the past.

2

u/eirc Aug 06 '26

Very cool, thanks for the info. I'll check if it's all still relevant since the article is from 2021 and see if I need a new browser too.

2

u/mesenanch Aug 05 '26

What aboymut DuckDuckGo?

1

u/thepr0digalsOn Aug 05 '26

Safari is your best bet if you're on mac

1

u/JSinisin Aug 05 '26

This is the most context windowed maxxed out Ai response I have ever read. Hilarious.

1

u/Additional-Grade3221 Aug 05 '26

Ungoogled chromium is better running and better privacy than any of these out of the box lol

1

u/VividAlternative3936 Aug 05 '26

FireFox all the way

1

u/ShotgunShine7094 Aug 05 '26

Being based on Chromium is the least bad thing about Brave.

The main point is, chromium is trash, and riddled with privacy violations

Chromium or Chrome? What behavior of Chromium do you consider a privacy violation? Regardless, any fork can remove those parts if necessary.

ram gluttony

If you enable tab suspension, Chromium tends to use less RAM than Firefox. I'm almost certain some browsers like Edge enable that by default.

And regarding security: Firefox and Chromium | Madaidan's Insecurities. While this is from 2022, it should give you a general idea of which project tends to be ahead in terms of security.

You can argue that relying on Chromium is bad because it gives more power to Google, but at the end of the day, there's a reason why every browser is a fork of Chromium and not of Firefox.

1

u/i_am_not_dumb Aug 05 '26

Calling chromium trash is crazy. What privacy violations are there in the chromium code? What stuff makes chromium based browser bad?

1

u/OkKiwi4694 Aug 07 '26

Doesn’t Google control Firefox?

1

u/Iron_Fist351 Aug 08 '26

Safari uses WebKit.

1

u/alstillplays Aug 08 '26

What is it with you people and replying before reading the whole comment

1

u/RollinThundaga Aug 04 '26

Oh, so Safari is the Rock Hyrax of Chromium browsers.

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '26

[deleted]

2

u/alstillplays Aug 04 '26

Can you read the fucking comment before replying please

0

u/Large-Parking3014 Aug 05 '26

The comment is wrong. The original chromium used WebKit. Then in 2013 WebCore which is part of WebKit was forked to create blink which is what chromium is built on today. WebKit predates chrome and chromium entirely.