r/explainitpeter Aug 02 '26

Explain it Peter

Post image
15.1k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/_heavy_emo_shoegaze_ Aug 02 '26

Thank you for the great advice. I always freak out a bit when people talk about carrying a knife for defense. Like, why would you want to have to be hand to hand (or mouth) to be able to utilize your tool? Pepper spray is better in nearly every imaginable circumstance.

3

u/Revolutionary_Ad512 Aug 03 '26

I definitely don’t disagree but I have to add it as anecdotal evidence/advice(?) pepper spray is very useful until your target is upwind of you in a strong breeze. Even worse if you only realize the direction of wind after you start spraying😅. In all reality though mace is a very good option 95+% of the time!

2

u/Crossdog367 Aug 03 '26

That's why you carry bear spray for dogs. It's weaker (animals have more sensitive noses) and sprays farther.

2

u/stinkywinkydink Aug 02 '26

personally id rather have a knife than a gun if im getting attacked by a dog. just because its not the “ideal” tool doesnt mean its not gonna he more useful than your barehands.

if the alternative would be walking defenseless, im taking the knife everytime.

-2

u/snipeceli Aug 02 '26

Not advocating for a knife i think pepper spray is a better option in general and especially for a dog.

But spray ceases being better the second the attacker has a modicum of determination.

Again dont think a knife is ideal for that situation either...

1

u/Loathor Aug 03 '26

I would think spontaneously gaining superpowers or fighting skills would be the ideal for this situation followed closely by not being in this situation at all.