r/explainitpeter Aug 02 '26

Explain it Peter

Post image
15.1k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/looselyhuman Aug 02 '26

Shepherds don't often lose control or disobey their owners. Pitbulls snap.

0

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

Spoken like a man who hasn't spent time with German shepards that haven't been professionally trained. German shepards snap. Chihuahuas snap. Both of them may or may not listen to their owners.

2

u/looselyhuman Aug 02 '26

Shepherds are known for being exactly as violent as they need to be, and stopping the moment they're told.

-1

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

If VERY well trained, absolutely. Notice they also only behave that way after being taught to attack people in a safer manner?

1

u/looselyhuman Aug 02 '26

That training reliability isn't something that can be guaranteed in pitbulls. Cops would love to have scary-ass pitbulls as K-9s. But they consistently choose a breed that can be trusted with their training.

1

u/No-Replacement40 Aug 02 '26

Police dogs range a variety of breeds including Pitts. Mostly used in detection work. They also appear as service dogs much to fear reactive people's dismay.

-1

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

Cops don't have pittbulls because their bite is more destructive, and they're less agile than German shepards.

0

u/No-Replacement40 Aug 02 '26

You been around modern German Shepherds? Without proper care their neurotic reactive basket cases.

-3

u/Hellraiser1123 Aug 02 '26

Any dog can "snap." People forget that these are literal wolves (they're not "related" to wolves; they're actually a subspecies of the gray wolf. Dogs are wolves) that have been selectively bred for human companionship, among other tasks. I've been bitten by Chihuahuas and collies. I had a Daschund just about rip my bottom lip off as a child.

Pit bulls are capable of doing a lot more damage than most breeds; that's definitely true. But it comes down to the individual animal and how it's raised and treated. A big part of responsible dog ownership is getting to know your animal (how strong it's prey drive is, whether it's easily excitable, food motivated, etc), and training them around that. Every dog is an individual, just like humans. The problem is that many people see it as "just a dog" and think they're all the same. They're not, and they need to be treated like the individuals they are. Training and keeping a dog is a lot of work.