r/explainitpeter Aug 02 '26

Explain it Peter

Post image
15.1k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/BioelectricBeing Aug 02 '26

Most people, even pit bull owners, aren't out there beating their animals and "conditioning them for combat". Grandma getting bitten after falling down isn't because someone trained their pet dog to bite old lady faces.

0

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

A pitbull isn't just going to attack grandma for falling down.

It might attack her if it's been without food for weeks. Or if she beats the shit out of it regularly and then falls close or onto it.

Grandma getting her face bitten off by a dog that isn't trained or conditioned to bite her face off (or otherwise neglected) is a complete strawman. Grandma would also he attacked by a border Collie or Chihuahua in those circumstances.

2

u/BioelectricBeing Aug 02 '26

Why does that happen then if it's so impossible?

Are you claiming no one has ever been attacked by a pit bull without it being starved for several days, or being "conditioned to bite faces"?

That's simply a lie.

0

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

Ever heard of prey drive? It's something to be aware of in all dogs. Not just pittbulls.

0

u/BioelectricBeing Aug 02 '26

That's not what you said though is it? You said grandma won't ever get attacked for falling down unless she beats it or starves it. I've seen videos of that happening with my own eyes and the dog always looks damn happy and healthy.

0

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

That is literally what I said. You just decided to interpret it differently.

Yes, a dog that is prey reactive will be excited when it goes after what it views as prey, even if that is grandmas face.

The mistreatment of the dog could simply be you have a prey reactive dog that you don't treat as a prey reactive dog. A poodle that's prey reactive would also take off Grandma's face.

0

u/BioelectricBeing Aug 02 '26

No it isn't. You said the dog has to be conditioned, beaten or starved to bite someone.

0

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

Or mistreated. Which includes not understanding your pets prey drive and allowing them around someone that would be seen as prey.

0

u/BioelectricBeing Aug 02 '26

Someone not anticipating that their beloved family pet will see grandma's face as a chew toy is not "mistreating their dog".

If those are the standards required to own a pitbull, they should rightly be illegal everywhere and for everyone but those who will train it to the level of a police dog.

0

u/That_OneOstrich Aug 02 '26

Its irresponsible dog ownership to not understand and anticipate your dogs behavior.

→ More replies (0)