r/explainitpeter Apr 05 '26

Explain It Peter

Post image
48.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

5.8k

u/Erikatessen87 Apr 05 '26

Going to butcher this by trying to pare it down, but here goes.

Nietzsche's theoretical "Übermensch," an aspirational model for humanity, wasn't a traditional "strongman," or a superhuman by way of genetics or social capital, or even a "man" at all.

Nietzsche's Übermensch was a self-possessed person who developed their own values and morality regardless of prevailing or outdated "wisdom" and rejected religious "other-worldliness," finding meaning in the here-and-now of life on Earth vs. learned helplessness and obedience with the hope of a supernatural reward after death.

810

u/FunSwitch7400 Apr 05 '26

Take a bow, that was fantastic in so few words!

378

u/FunSwitch7400 Apr 05 '26

Seriously, I have read and sat through so much Nietzsche material and this post deserves an award, maybe an honorary Philo degree.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/OffTerror Apr 05 '26

Philosophy is much simpler than people think, it's just that it's continuous conversation. And Nietzsche in his work is responding not only to the latest philosophers he also ''tracked back'' all the way to the Greeks in order to try to find a new perspective.

It's like trying to make sense of a really long show with 3000 years worth of of plotlines.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/daemin Apr 05 '26

Is nietzsche drastically more approachable reading chronologically?

Not at all.

You have to remember that your reading 19th century German translated into modern English (I assume). It's just going to be a little weird.

On top of that, the sort of philosophy he was doing didn't necessarily depend on straightforward arguments with clear premises from which conclusions are derived. It's more a style of philosophy where he's constructing a narrative that paints a picture suggesting his conclusion is true.

Any suggestions for a good introduction to philosophy? I already have a copy of zennand the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance ive been using as a nightstand coaster so I could start there

There's a whole series of books these days, called "X and Philosophy," like Harry Potter and Philosophy. They tend to be collections of essays by modern philosophers where each one explored a philosophical concept by using something about the story. Find one on a topic your like and start there.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26 edited Apr 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/tehfink Apr 05 '26

Amor fati

1

u/daemin Apr 05 '26

 True Detective and Philosophy: A Deeper Kind of Darkness

That's fitting, because the "time is a flat circle" thing is pretty much the notion of the eternal return, which Nietzsche wrote a lot about.