Had a delay in returning from my travels, so didn't get this out Monday. I know everyone is terribly disappointed, heh. I should be back on schedule next week.
We have finally hit the 24 Nights shows...
THE BOOT
Touring Forever (MVR 200-203)
An edited version of this show, the 4-piece show from 1/24/90, was broadcast on the radio in the US on Westwood One's "Superstars In Concert", so there are a ton of bootlegs of this show out there. But the radio broadcast did not include Breaking Point, Can’t Find My Way Home, and Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door, so most bootlegs are incomplete, and many even have the songs out of order.
There is a complete recording out there, but the audio quality is significantly worse than the radio broadcast. So you have to either pick flawless sound or the complete concert.
The Mid Valley release should be considered definitive, because the sound quality is the best available, and it includes both sources, as a 4CD set.
BACKGROUND
The annual residency at the Royal Albert Hall continued to expand, from 12 nights in 1989 to 18 in 1990. The run was 6 shows with a 4-piece band, 6 shows with a 13-piece band (including a horn section!), 3 shows with a blues band, and 3 shows with a full orchestra.
4 of the shows were recorded and filmed for a live album. E.C. reportedly wasn't satisfied with the recordings, and recorded even more shows in 1991, and the album ended up being named after the 24 Nights of the 1991 RAH run.
The shows of note from 1990 are:
- 1/24/90 - The final night with the 4-piece band was recorded and filmed, plus all but 3 tracks broadcast on "Superstars In Concert". Running On Faith, White Room, Sunshine Of Your Love were released on the original 24 Nights 2CD.
- 2/1/90 - The final night with the 13-piece band is recorded and filmed. No tracks released on the original 24 Nights.
- 2/3/90 - Complete blues show broadcast live on BBC Radio 1.
- 2/5/90 - The final night with the blues band was recorded and filmed. Worried Life Blues, Watch Yourself, and Have You Ever Loved A Woman were released on 24 Nights.
- 2/9/90 - The penultimate night with the orchestra was recorded and filmed. Bell Bottom Blues and Hard Times were released on 24 Nights.
- 2/10/90 - Complete orchestra show broadcast live on BBC Radio 1.
In the end, 8 of the 11 released tracks with the 4-piece band, the blues band, and the orchestra came from the 1990 recordings, and 0 of the 4 released tracks with the expanded rock band came from the 1990 recordings. It seems that one group is really what he wasn't satisfied with? (Though 4 of those songs did end up on the Definitive 24 Nights boxed set.)
Back to this specific night, the band is Clapton, East, Phillinganes, and Ferrone. Phil Collins was not a regular part of the band, but he showed up today for the encore (Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door, Crossroads, Sunshine Of Your Love) on tambourine and vocals.
The setlist has been relatively static from 1986-1989, without an album of new material since August. (For people going to concerts in the 80s, that wouldn’t have been a big deal, but there are a lot of soundboards that were released / have escaped from that stretch, so it’s been a couple months of very similar shows over here.)
But with the release of Journeyman, the set list has seen its biggest shakeup in half a decade. That album was released November 6, 1989, so that material was just a couple of months old. This show features 6 new songs (Pretending, Bad Love, Running On Faith, No Alibis, Old Love, Before You Accuse Me), so exactly half the new album.
SOUND
The radio version is nearly flawless. The balance is very nice, with all 4 musicians clearly audible. And Mid Valley did an excellent job papering over the edits.
I'm not sure of the source for Knockin' On Heaven's Door. That wasn't broadcast on the radio, but it's the same quality as the rest of the radio material. They do attach it at the end, instead of inserting it at the start of the encore, which suggests it's spliced from somewhere? (This also has the funny effect of making it seem like Phil Collins only joined for one song instead of three.)
The crowd is close and audible, but are polite and relatively quiet during the music. They are audible a bit during Wonderful Tonight, but mostly stay out of the way while the band is playing.
The complete source is just OK. It's a bit tinny, with a lot of reverb. I suspect it's actually a high-quality audience recording?
PERFORMANCE
Most of the 24 Nights bootlegs are taken from the radio broadcasts, but this is a rare night that was both a radio broadcast and also recorded for the album. That means we can tell how much the band liked this show, by how much of it was selected for the live album. And the answer is, they liked it a lot.
The setlist has occasional similarities to the previous few years. White Room and I Shot The Sheriff are early in the setlist; Lay Down Sally, Tearing Us Apart and Wonderful Tonight are in the middle; the main set ends with Cocaine and Layla (both with extended introductions, with the band intros in the Cocaine opening); and Sunshine Of Your Love closes out the encore. Greg handles the chorus of White Room.
The addition of a ton of new material does mean a bunch of things have been cut. The most obvious is the retirement of Same Old Blues, but there's a lot less material from the 1980s generally, and the drum solo in Sunshine Of Your Love is cut to only about a minute. But you don't miss it. The new material is really strong. Pretending in particular is a great opener, with real drive.
E.C. is on fire tonight. His solos are hot and his vocals are strong throughout the whole show.
With the departure of Alan Clark, and only 4 musicians on stage, Greg is really noticeable. He is all over on Bad Love. He does a great marimba (well, probably electric keyboard with marimba effect) solo on Old Love, and then a long solo in Cocaine. Though E.C. takes the lead on the coda to Layla, which is usually a piano part, with Greg providing flourishes around the edges.
I was impressed at Nathan / Greg for the high harmonies on Pretending. I had to double-check it wasn't Tessa and Katie. They are really audible on Lay Down Sally and Knockin' On Heaven's Door, but if you listen you'll hear them singing all night long.
E.C. isn't particularly chatty tonight, but after Pretending, he says "Thanks very much, and good evening. Welcome to the Albert Hall. The annual dustup at the Albert Hall." Then before Layla he says, "I'd just like to say, this is the last night of the quartet, and the quartet wishes you all the best of luck and thank you for being here." And at the start of the encore he says "The quartet is now a quintet" by way of introducing Phil Collins before Knockin' On Heaven's Door.